📰 Free Speech and a Free Press

7th Grade 🏛️ Civics & Government

Freedom of speech is the right to say, write and publish what you think — even when the government doesn’t like it. In the United States it is protected by the First Amendment. Without free speech and a free press, citizens can’t find out what is going on or make smart choices when they vote.

Free · US Letter · no sign-up
Google Classroom Save to Pinterest Email me

What freedom of speech means

Freedom of speech is every person’s right to express their opinions: to talk, write an article, post online, hold a protest sign, draw a cartoon or sing a protest song. The right belongs to everyone — including people with unpopular opinions and people who criticize the government. In fact, the opinions that annoy the majority are the ones that need protection most, because nobody tries to silence opinions that everyone already agrees with.

In the United States, this right is written into the Constitution. The First Amendment, part of the Bill of Rights ratified in 1791, says that “Congress shall make no law … abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press.” The same amendment also protects freedom of religion, the right to gather peacefully and the right to petition the government.

Who the First Amendment protects you from

The First Amendment limits the government — Congress, the President, state governments, cities and public schools. It does not stop a private company, a store or a website from setting its own rules about what people may say on its property or platform. If a social media site removes a post, that is usually the company’s rule, not a First Amendment case.

Students have free speech rights too. In the 1969 case Tinker v. Des Moines, students wore black armbands to school to protest a war, and the Supreme Court said students do not “shed their constitutional rights … at the schoolhouse gate.” Schools can still set some limits — for example on speech that seriously disrupts learning.

Why a free press matters in a democracy

Newspapers, news websites, radio and TV tell the public what the government and other powerful people are doing. Reporters investigate, ask tough questions and publish things that people in power might prefer to keep hidden. That is why the press is often called the “watchdog of democracy”: it barks when something is wrong.

In the United States the government cannot usually stop a story before it is published. In the 1971 Pentagon Papers case, the Supreme Court allowed newspapers to publish secret government documents about the Vietnam War. For the press to do its job well, there need to be many different news outlets with different points of view, so no single voice controls what people hear.

The limits of free speech

Free speech is very strong in the United States, but it is not unlimited. You may not make “true threats” — serious statements that you mean to hurt someone. You may not encourage people to commit violence right away, which courts call incitement. And you may not spread false statements of fact that damage a person’s reputation; that is called defamation (libel when it is written, slander when it is spoken).

Courts set these limits narrowly. Speech is not illegal just because it is rude, offensive or makes people angry. To protect open debate about public officials, the Supreme Court ruled in New York Times v. Sullivan (1964) that a public official suing for defamation must prove the speaker knew the statement was false or recklessly ignored the truth.

Being a smart news consumer

Today anyone can publish online, so it is easy for mistakes, rumors and fake news to spread. A good citizen learns to check: Who wrote this? Does it name a source? Are other trustworthy news outlets reporting the same thing? Is this a news report, or someone’s opinion?

It also helps to notice when something is actually an advertisement, and to read sources with different points of view. People who only read what they already agree with can end up in a “bubble,” where it is hard to understand anyone who thinks differently.

Key facts

  • The First Amendment, ratified in 1791 as part of the Bill of Rights, protects freedom of speech and of the press.
  • The First Amendment limits the government, not private companies.
  • In Tinker v. Des Moines (1969), the Supreme Court said students keep their free speech rights at school.
  • True threats, incitement to violence and defamation are not protected speech.
  • A free press is often called the “watchdog of democracy.”

Quick quiz

  1. What is freedom of speech?

  2. Which part of the Constitution protects free speech and a free press?

  3. Why is the press called the “watchdog of democracy”?

  4. What is defamation?

  5. Which of these is NOT protected by the First Amendment?

  6. What did the Supreme Court decide in Tinker v. Des Moines (1969)?

  7. Does the First Amendment stop a private website from removing a post?

  8. What is the difference between a news report and an opinion piece?

💭 Think and talk about it

  1. Should we protect opinions that most people find upsetting? When yes, and when not?
  2. Where do you get your news? How can you tell if a source is reliable?
  3. What is the difference between strong criticism and a threat?

Questions kids ask

Can you say anything you want because of free speech?

No. True threats, incitement to immediate violence and defamation are not protected, and some other narrow kinds of speech can be limited. But speech is not illegal just because it is offensive or unpopular.

Do kids have free speech rights at school?

Yes, at public schools. The Supreme Court said in 1969 that students keep their rights at school, although schools may limit speech that seriously disrupts learning or is lewd or threatening.

Why do we need many different news outlets?

So the public hears different facts and points of view and doesn’t depend on just one source of information.

🔎 Ask Thinkapedia another question