🎬 Dinosaur Myths

3rd Grade 🦖 Dinosaurs

Movies, toys and old books are full of ideas about dinosaurs that science now knows are wrong. Let’s check some of the most common myths — and learn how to ask “How do we know?”

Free · US Letter · no sign-up
Google Classroom Save to Pinterest Email me

Myth: people lived with dinosaurs

In cartoons and commercials you sometimes see cave people riding dinosaurs. It’s funny, but impossible. The non-bird dinosaurs died out about 66 million years ago, and modern humans appeared only about 300,000 years ago, by most estimates. More than 65 million years passed in between.

The woolly mammoth, which is a mammal and not a dinosaur, lived in the Ice Age — long after the dinosaurs. The same goes for saber-toothed cats and Megalodon. They are all “prehistoric animals,” but not dinosaurs, and they didn’t live with them.

Myth: we can bring back a dinosaur from DNA

In a famous movie, scientists take dinosaur blood from a mosquito trapped in amber and clone dinosaurs. It’s a brilliant idea for a movie — but science says it can’t be done. Genetic material, DNA, breaks down over time, and even in the best conditions it doesn’t survive millions of years.

The oldest DNA scientists have been able to read so far is about 2 million years old, according to reports — far less than 66 million years. So even if we find a mosquito in amber from the age of dinosaurs, we can’t rebuild a dinosaur from it.

Myth: Dilophosaurus spat venom

In the same movie, Dilophosaurus shows up as a small dinosaur with a frill that pops open around its neck and spits venom. In reality, Dilophosaurus was a predator about 20 to 23 feet long that lived about 190 million years ago in Arizona. It had two thin crests on its head — that’s where its name, “two-crested lizard,” comes from.

There is no fossil evidence of a neck frill or venom. The moviemakers added them to create a scary, unusual character. That’s fine in a movie — as long as we remember it’s made up.

Myth: dinosaurs were slow and dumb

A hundred years ago, people thought dinosaurs were slow, clumsy reptiles that dragged their tails on the ground and lived in swamps. In the 1960s and 1970s, scientists like John Ostrom, who described Deinonychus in 1969, showed that many dinosaurs were active, quick and closely related to birds. That time is called the “Dinosaur Renaissance.”

Since then we’ve known that dinosaurs held their tails up off the ground — there are almost no tail-drag marks in their tracks. Scientists also argued about whether dinosaurs were “warm-blooded” like birds or “cold-blooded” like lizards, and today many think the answer is somewhere in between and differed from group to group.

Myth: carbon-14 dates dinosaurs

You often hear that someone “carbon-dated a dinosaur.” But carbon-14 dating only works on young materials, up to about 50,000 years old. In something millions of years old, there is no carbon-14 left to measure.

To find the age of dinosaurs, scientists measure other radioactive elements, like uranium, in layers of volcanic ash above and below the fossil. These elements break down very slowly at a known rate, like a clock. With every myth, it’s worth asking the most important question in science: “How do we know that?”

Key facts

  • People and non-bird dinosaurs never lived at the same time.
  • DNA doesn’t survive millions of years, so a dinosaur can’t be cloned.
  • There is no evidence that Dilophosaurus spat venom or had a neck frill.
  • Dinosaurs did not drag their tails on the ground.
  • Carbon-14 works only for ages up to about 50,000 years; dinosaur ages are found with other methods.

Quick quiz

  1. Did cave people ride dinosaurs?

  2. Is a woolly mammoth a dinosaur?

  3. Why can’t we clone a dinosaur from DNA?

  4. What was really on Dilophosaurus’s head?

  5. What did John Ostrom show when he described Deinonychus?

  6. Did dinosaurs drag their tails on the ground?

  7. Up to about what age can carbon-14 measure?

  8. What is the most important question to ask when you hear a surprising fact?

💭 Think and talk about it

  1. Pick a dinosaur movie or toy. What about it is accurate and what isn’t?
  2. Do you think it’s okay for movies to change scientific facts? When yes and when no?
  3. If we could bring back a dinosaur — would it be a good idea? Explain.

Questions kids ask

What else do dinosaur movies get wrong?

Lots of things: wrong sizes (like a giant Velociraptor), missing feathers on dinosaurs that had them, dinosaurs from different periods meeting, and roars — we have no idea what sounds dinosaurs made.

Did dinosaurs roar?

Nobody knows. Some scientists think some dinosaurs made closed-mouth sounds, like the cooing of a dove or the rumble of a crocodile, rather than a lion’s roar. Hadrosaurs with hollow crests may have made trumpet-like sounds.

Where did the myths come from?

Some come from old scientific ideas that turned out to be wrong, and some were invented for movies and books. Science changes with new evidence, and it takes time for toys and books to catch up.

🔎 Ask Thinkapedia another question