🍅 Fruit or Vegetable? Botany vs. the Kitchen

4th Grade 🍎 Fruits & Vegetables

“Is a tomato a fruit or a vegetable?” is one of the most searched questions online. The surprising answer: both! Plant scientists and cooks use the same words but mean different things. In this lesson you’ll learn both definitions, and then you can answer the question for any fruit or vegetable.

Free · US Letter · no sign-up
Google Classroom Save to Pinterest Email me

A fruit, the way a botanist sees it

In botany — the science of plants — a “fruit” is the part of a plant that grows from the ovary of a flower. Usually this happens after the flower is pollinated, and the fruit holds the seeds inside. The flower wilts, the ovary in its center swells up and becomes the fruit, and the seeds ripen inside it. A fruit’s job is to help the seeds travel to a new place: an animal eats the sweet fruit, walks somewhere else, and the seeds are left behind to sprout.

By this definition, anything that grew from a flower’s ovary is a fruit — most fruits hold seeds: tomatoes, cucumbers, bell peppers, eggplants, zucchini, pumpkins, avocados, corn kernels, and even pea pods. Watermelons and bananas are fruits too — and a banana is actually a kind of berry (a fleshy fruit with seeds inside), even though its seeds are so tiny you can barely see them. (The bananas we buy grow without pollination, so their seeds never fully develop — they are still fruits.)

A vegetable, the way a cook sees it

In the kitchen, things are sorted in a completely different way. A “vegetable” is any part of a plant we eat mostly in savory foods — in a salad, a soup or a stew. A “fruit” in the kitchen is something sweet that tastes good on its own or as dessert. That is why tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers are vegetables in the kitchen, even though botanists call them fruits.

Vegetables come from every part of the plant. Carrots and beets are roots, a potato is a tuber (a stem that grows underground), onions and garlic are bulbs, lettuce and spinach are leaves, celery is mostly leaf stalks, and cauliflower and broccoli are actually young flowers that haven’t opened yet.

So what’s the answer? Tomatoes, avocados, cucumbers and more

Tomato: a fruit in botany, a vegetable in the kitchen. Avocado: in botany, a fruit with one big seed; in the kitchen, most people serve it like a vegetable — in a salad, in guacamole or on toast. Cucumbers, bell peppers and eggplants: fruits in botany, vegetables in the kitchen. Watermelon: a fruit by both definitions, even though it is a cousin of the cucumber and the pumpkin. Bananas and lemons: fruits by both definitions, even if nobody eats a lemon plain.

There are surprises the other way, too. A strawberry is called an “accessory fruit”: the sweet red part is the swollen base of the flower, and the little dots on the outside are the real fruits, each with a seed inside. And mushrooms aren’t plants at all — they belong to a separate kingdom, the fungi, even though cooks treat them like vegetables.

When the Supreme Court decided

In 1893 the question went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. Back then, people had to pay a tax on vegetables brought in from other countries, but not on fruits. A tomato importer argued that a tomato is a fruit, so he shouldn’t have to pay. The justices agreed that botanically a tomato is a fruit, but they ruled that for the tax law it is a vegetable — because that is how people eat it. It’s a great example of how one word can have two correct definitions, each one right in its own setting.

Key facts

  • In botany, a fruit is the part that grows from a flower and holds the seeds.
  • Tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, eggplants, zucchini and avocados are fruits in botany and vegetables in the kitchen.
  • A banana is a berry, botanically speaking, and a strawberry is an “accessory fruit.”
  • Cauliflower and broccoli are young flowers that haven’t opened yet.
  • Mushrooms aren’t plants — they belong to the fungi kingdom.
  • In 1893 the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that a tomato is a vegetable for tax purposes.

Quick quiz

  1. What is a fruit, according to botany?

  2. A tomato is…

  3. Which part of the plant is a carrot?

  4. What are we eating when we eat cauliflower or broccoli?

  5. What is special about a strawberry?

  6. Is a mushroom a plant?

  7. An avocado is…

  8. Why did the U.S. Supreme Court rule in 1893 that a tomato is a vegetable?

💭 Think and talk about it

  1. Pick five things from your fridge. What is each one in botany, and what is it in the kitchen?
  2. Why do you think plants “invest” in sweet, colorful fruit? What do they get out of it?
  3. Can one word have two correct definitions? Think of another example from everyday life.

Questions kids ask

So is a tomato a fruit or a vegetable?

In botany a tomato is a fruit, because it grows from a flower and has seeds. In the kitchen and in everyday talk it’s a vegetable, because we eat it in salads and savory dishes. Both answers are right — each in its own setting.

Is an avocado a fruit or a vegetable?

It’s a fruit in botany — it grows from the avocado tree’s flower and holds one big seed. In the United States people usually treat it like a vegetable, in guacamole, salads and sandwiches, but in some other parts of the world it’s made into sweet drinks and desserts.

What about cucumbers, bell peppers and watermelons?

Cucumbers and bell peppers are fruits in botany and vegetables in the kitchen. A watermelon is a fruit by both definitions — it’s sweet and we eat it as fruit, even though it’s a cousin of the cucumber.

🔎 Ask Thinkapedia another question