Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions

32 silly, kid-friendly “would you rather” questions for Thanksgiving. Tap for a random question, or print the cards and pass them around the table.

Free · US Letter · no sign-up
Google Classroom Save to Pinterest Email me
Tap the button for a question!
Question cards, page 1

🤔 Thanksgiving Would You Rather?

Would you rather eat only pie or only mashed potatoes for Thanksgiving dinner?
Would you rather be a turkey that can talk or a pumpkin that can sing?
Would you rather watch the parade in person or watch it from your cozy couch?
Would you rather have stuffing for breakfast or pancakes for Thanksgiving dinner?
Would you rather sit at the kids’ table forever or the grown-ups’ table forever?
Would you rather carve the turkey or set the whole table?
Would you rather eat cranberry sauce from a can or have none at all?
Would you rather go for a turkey trot run or take a long Thanksgiving nap?
Would you rather have a pie the size of a car or a cookie the size of a house?
Would you rather be stuck in a corn maze or a giant pile of leaves?
Would you rather have feathers like a turkey or a shell like a pumpkin?
Would you rather only eat cold leftovers for a week or skip leftovers forever?

thinkabara.com/holidays/thanksgiving/would-you-rather

Question cards, page 2

🤔 Thanksgiving Would You Rather?

Would you rather help cook all day or wash all the dishes after dinner?
Would you rather have gravy on everything or whipped cream on everything?
Would you rather ride a giant parade balloon or march in the band?
Would you rather gobble every time you laugh or quack every time you sneeze?
Would you rather eat with a giant spoon or with tiny chopsticks?
Would you rather have Thanksgiving at the beach or in the snow?
Would you rather jump in a leaf pile or roll down a hill?
Would you rather invite your teacher or your favorite athlete to dinner?
Would you rather taste every pie or eat a whole pie of your favorite kind?
Would you rather make a turkey hand drawing or a paper-plate turkey?
Would you rather say what you are thankful for in a song or in a poem?
Would you rather have a pet turkey or a pet scarecrow that walks?

thinkabara.com/holidays/thanksgiving/would-you-rather

Question cards, page 3

🤔 Thanksgiving Would You Rather?

Would you rather eat dinner at 11 AM or at 9 PM?
Would you rather have only sweet potatoes or only regular potatoes?
Would you rather play football or board games after dinner?
Would you rather wear a pilgrim hat or a turkey hat all day?
Would you rather be a corn cob or a green bean?
Would you rather have your pie first or save it for last?
Would you rather be able to smell dinner from a mile away or taste it from a mile away?
Would you rather write a thank-you note to 10 people or say thank-you out loud to 100 people?

thinkabara.com/holidays/thanksgiving/would-you-rather

All 32 questions

  1. Would you rather eat only pie or only mashed potatoes for Thanksgiving dinner?
  2. Would you rather be a turkey that can talk or a pumpkin that can sing?
  3. Would you rather watch the parade in person or watch it from your cozy couch?
  4. Would you rather have stuffing for breakfast or pancakes for Thanksgiving dinner?
  5. Would you rather sit at the kids’ table forever or the grown-ups’ table forever?
  6. Would you rather carve the turkey or set the whole table?
  7. Would you rather eat cranberry sauce from a can or have none at all?
  8. Would you rather go for a turkey trot run or take a long Thanksgiving nap?
  9. Would you rather have a pie the size of a car or a cookie the size of a house?
  10. Would you rather be stuck in a corn maze or a giant pile of leaves?
  11. Would you rather have feathers like a turkey or a shell like a pumpkin?
  12. Would you rather only eat cold leftovers for a week or skip leftovers forever?
  13. Would you rather help cook all day or wash all the dishes after dinner?
  14. Would you rather have gravy on everything or whipped cream on everything?
  15. Would you rather ride a giant parade balloon or march in the band?
  16. Would you rather gobble every time you laugh or quack every time you sneeze?
  17. Would you rather eat with a giant spoon or with tiny chopsticks?
  18. Would you rather have Thanksgiving at the beach or in the snow?
  19. Would you rather jump in a leaf pile or roll down a hill?
  20. Would you rather invite your teacher or your favorite athlete to dinner?
  21. Would you rather taste every pie or eat a whole pie of your favorite kind?
  22. Would you rather make a turkey hand drawing or a paper-plate turkey?
  23. Would you rather say what you are thankful for in a song or in a poem?
  24. Would you rather have a pet turkey or a pet scarecrow that walks?
  25. Would you rather eat dinner at 11 AM or at 9 PM?
  26. Would you rather have only sweet potatoes or only regular potatoes?
  27. Would you rather play football or board games after dinner?
  28. Would you rather wear a pilgrim hat or a turkey hat all day?
  29. Would you rather be a corn cob or a green bean?
  30. Would you rather have your pie first or save it for last?
  31. Would you rather be able to smell dinner from a mile away or taste it from a mile away?
  32. Would you rather write a thank-you note to 10 people or say thank-you out loud to 100 people?

Frequently asked questions

What are good Thanksgiving would you rather questions for kids?

Silly food choices are the biggest hit: “Would you rather eat only pie or only mashed potatoes?”, “Would you rather have gravy on everything or whipped cream on everything?” or “Would you rather gobble every time you laugh or quack every time you sneeze?”

How do you play would you rather at Thanksgiving dinner?

Read a question aloud. Everyone picks an answer — and explains why in one sentence. No wrong answers! For a moving game, point to two sides of the room and let kids walk to their choice.

Can I use these in the classroom?

Yes. They work as morning-meeting questions, opinion-writing prompts (“I would rather… because…”) or a quick brain break before a holiday break.

More free printables from Thinkabara