Plants need light: a fair test
🎯 Objective: Students plan a fair test to show that plants need light.
🦫 Thinkabara · Lesson booklet
Plants need light: a fair test
2nd Grade · Science · 2-LS2-1
🎯 Students plan a fair test to show that plants need light.
- Teacher’s lesson plan
- Easier worksheet
- Student worksheet
- Challenge page
- Quiz
- Answer key
Teacher: ______________________ Class: ____________
📘 This lesson comes as a booklet: teacher’s plan, student worksheet, challenge page, quiz and answer key — all in one printable booklet. Teach from this page, print it all, or give the quiz to the class online.
Full-screen slides for the projector: goals, opener, every drawing already made, the exit ticket and the quiz — click or use the arrow keys.
🗓️ Lesson at a glance
⏱️ 48 minutes
- 5 min Opener (pick one)
- 6 min Teach: one thing changes
- 7 min What stays the same?
- 12 min Set up the test
- 6 min How we will record
- 3 min Exit ticket
- 3 min Wrap-up
- 6 min Handing out, moving and cleaning up
Not in these 48 minutes: Use the worksheet's Plan part today and the Record part each day this week; give the quiz on Friday after the groups compare results.
🧰 Materials
- Two clear cups per group with soil and 3–4 bean or grass seedlings each, planted on the same day (about the same height)
- A shoebox (or a dark cupboard) for each group’s dark cup
- A measuring spoon or small cup for water
- A ruler per group
- Labels: LIGHT and DARK, and group names
- A one-week recording table per student (in the printable worksheet)
🔤 Key words
- fair test
- A test where we change only one thing and keep everything else the same.
- change
- The one thing we make different on purpose — today, the light.
- same
- Things we keep exactly alike so the test is fair.
- measure
- To find out how long or tall something is, using a tool like a ruler.
- result
- What happened in the test.
🎯 Success criteria — read them to the class
- I can plan a fair test that changes only the light.
- I can list what stays the same in my test.
- I can measure and record my plants for a week.
🎬 Open the lesson — pick one (5 min)
Get the class moving, curious and talking before the learning starts. Each one leads straight into today’s topic.
🤸 Brain break: Sunflower turn
- Stand up. You are a sunflower. Point your face and arms toward the window.
- The sun moves across the sky — slowly turn your body a little to follow it.
- Night time: let your arms float down and close your eyes for 3 seconds.
- Morning: open your eyes, reach up to the sun again.
- Sit down slowly, like a flower closing for the night.
Say: “Plants turn toward the light. Does that mean they need it to grow? Today you plan your own test to find out — a fair test.”
🧩 Riddle
“In a test, I am the ONE thing you change. Everything else stays the same. What am I?”
Hint: In today’s test, I am the light.
Answer
The thing we change on purpose — today it is the light! Every other thing must stay the same. That is what makes a test fair.
🎁 Mystery object
Do: A shoebox with the lid on. Inside: a pale, yellowish sprout grown in the dark (grow it a week ahead). Next to it, a green sprout of the same kind grown in light.
Say: “These two sprouts were planted on the same day, in the same soil, with the same water. One spent the week inside this box. Which one?”
Reveal: Open the box: the pale sprout. Ask: “Is one plant enough to be sure light made the difference?” Today we plan a real fair test.
🤔 Would you rather
“Would you rather race on a track where everyone starts at the same line, or a track where some kids start halfway?”
Do: Students vote with thumbs and tell a partner why.
Then: Same starting line is fair! A science test must be fair too: everything starts the same, and we change only one thing.
🧑🏫 Teach it step by step
1 Teach: one thing changes 6 min
Do:- Write the question: “Do plants need light to grow?”
Say:“Our class plants are teaching us a lot. Today every group runs its own test about light.”
“In a fair test we change only one thing. Today that one thing is light: one cup gets light, one cup gets dark.”
“Everything else must be the same. If we gave the dark plant less water too, we would not know if the dark or the water made the difference.”
“Scientists also repeat tests. Every group doing the same test helps us be more sure.”
Ask: Why does every group do the same test?
Look for: If many groups get the same result, we can be more sure it is true.
2 What stays the same? 7 min
Do:- Make a class list on the board as students call out ideas.
Say:“Let’s list everything that must stay the same for both cups.”
“Same kind of plant. Same size cup. Same soil. Same number of seedlings. Same amount of water. Same time to water. Same room temperature.”
“And the one thing we change? The light.”
Ask: If the dark cup is near the heater and the light cup is near the cold window, is it fair?
Look for: No — the temperature is different too. Put the box next to the light cup.
3 Set up the test 12 min
Do:- Each group labels its cups LIGHT and DARK.
- Measure the tallest seedling in each cup and record Day 1.
- Water both cups with the same spoonful.
- Put the LIGHT cup on the windowsill and the DARK cup inside the shoebox right next to it, lid on.
Say:“Measure from the soil to the top of the tallest seedling. Read the ruler carefully and write the number.”
“Same spoon, same amount, both cups.”
“Put the box right next to the light cup, so the only difference is light.”
Ask: Walk around and ask: “What is different about your two cups? What is the same?”
Look for: Only the light is different; plant, soil, cup and water are the same.
4 How we will record 6 min
Do:- Show the recording table: Day 1–5, height, color of leaves, one word.
Say:“Every day this week, the group measures both cups, writes the height and the leaf color, and adds one word: green, pale, tall, droopy.”
“On Friday we compare. Write your prediction now: what will the dark plant look like on Friday?”
Ask: Why do we write the color as well as the height?
Look for: Plants in the dark may grow tall and thin but turn pale; height alone doesn’t tell if they are healthy.
5 Exit ticket 3 min
Do:- Students write on a sticky note or the bottom of the worksheet.
Say:“What was the only thing we changed? Name two things we kept the same.”
✅ Correct answer: We changed only the light. Kept the same (any two): kind of plant, cup, soil, amount of water, number of seedlings, place/temperature. (“We changed the box” is close — the box only takes away light.)
✓ Wrap-up 3 min
Do:- Read the three “I can” statements aloud.
- Sort the exit tickets into got it / almost / not yet.
Say:“Tell your neighbor your prediction for the dark plant.”
“Fingers: 1 = not yet, 2 = almost, 3 = I can teach it.”
💡 Teacher tips
- Plant the seedlings about a week before the lesson. Grass seed sprouts in a few days and is cheap; beans are bigger and easier to measure.
- Grow one demo plant in the dark ahead of time for the mystery opener.
- Water every day at the same time — make it a class job. Use the same spoon for every cup.
- Expect the dark seedlings to turn pale or yellowish and often grow thin and floppy. Let students observe it instead of telling them.
- On Friday, bring the dark cups back to the light: many turn green again — a great extra observation.
💬 Discussion questions
- Why must the dark cup get the same water as the light cup?
So the only difference is light; then we know light caused any change.
- Why do all groups do the same test?
Repeating a test makes us more sure of the result.
- What do you think the dark plant will look like after a week?
Pale or yellow, maybe thin and droopy (accept predictions with reasons).
⚠️ Common mistakes and how to fix them
❌ Changing two things (the box AND less water).
✔️ Ask: “If the plant looks sick, how would we know which change did it?”
❌ Measuring from the table instead of the soil.
✔️ Put the ruler’s zero on the soil every time.
❌ Thinking taller always means healthier.
✔️ Compare color too: a tall, pale plant in the dark is not healthy.
🧩 For every learner
🤝 Extra support
- Recording table with pictures: color the leaves each day instead of writing.
- Partner with a student who reads the ruler.
- Frame: “The ___ plant is ___.”
🚀 Challenge
- Plan the next test: does the amount of light matter (window vs. middle of the room)?
- Make a line plot or bar graph of the heights on Friday.
- Explain why the box should sit next to the light cup and not by the heater.
🌎 English learners
- Word cards: light, dark, same, change — with pictures.
- Point and say: “Light cup. Dark cup. Same water.”
- Frame: “We change the ___. We keep the ___ the same.”
🏠 At home: Ask a grown-up to help you find a spot under a flowerpot, rock or board in the yard where grass was covered. What color is the grass under it? Draw it and tell why.
📊 After the exit ticket and quiz: what to do tomorrow
Sort the exit tickets (or open the quiz results — they group the class for you) and start tomorrow with 10 minutes in three groups.
✅ Got it
- Start the next lesson (design a seed that travels) — keep measuring the cups each day.
- Early finishers: the Challenge sheet — plan the window vs. middle-of-the-room test.
🟡 Almost
- 5 minutes at the cups: point to each thing that is the same and say it aloud, then name the one change.
- Check: do they measure from the soil?
🔁 Not yet
- Small group with the teacher: measure both cups together and record Day 2.
- Then the Easier worksheet (circle the answer) with the teacher nearby.
Plants need light: a fair test · 2nd Grade
🤝 My light test
Same skill, smaller numbers and fill-in-the-blank steps — for students who need extra support. Everyone else starts on the main worksheet.
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Circle the answer.
- We change the (light / water).Answer: ________________________✅ light
- Both cups get the (same / different) water.Answer: ________________________✅ same
- The dark cup goes in the (box / window).Answer: ________________________✅ box
B. Day 1.
- Draw your light cup and your dark cup.✅ Two cups of seedlings, about the same.
🔑 Answers
- light
- same
- box
- Two cups of seedlings, about the same.
Plants need light: a fair test · 2nd Grade
📝 Plants need light: a fair test
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Plan.
- Our question: Do plants need ______ to grow?Answer: ________________________✅ light
- The one thing we change: ______Answer: ________________________✅ the light (one cup in light, one in the dark)
- Three things we keep the same: ______Answer: ________________________✅ Any three: kind of plant, cup, soil, water, number of seedlings, place/temperature.
- My prediction for the dark plant: ______Answer: ________________________✅ Any prediction with a reason.
B. Is it fair? Write yes or no.
- Both cups get 1 spoon of water. ___Answer: ________________________✅ yes
- The light cup gets bean seeds and the dark cup gets grass seeds. ___Answer: ________________________✅ no
- The dark box is right next to the light cup. ___Answer: ________________________✅ yes
C. Record (fill in each day).
- Day 1–5: light cup height ___ color ___ ; dark cup height ___ color ___Answer: ________________________✅ Measured heights each day; light cup green, dark cup turning pale or yellow.
- On Friday: what happened to the dark plant?Answer: ________________________✅ It turned pale or yellow (and often thin and droopy) — plants need light to grow well.
🔑 Answers
- light
- the light (one cup in light, one in the dark)
- Any three: kind of plant, cup, soil, water, number of seedlings, place/temperature.
- Any prediction with a reason.
- yes
- no
- yes
- Measured heights each day; light cup green, dark cup turning pale or yellow.
- It turned pale or yellow (and often thin and droopy) — plants need light to grow well.
Plants need light: a fair test · 2nd Grade
🚀 Challenge: test detective
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Think and explain.
- Ella put her dark cup next to the heater. Why is her test not fair?Answer: ________________________✅ The temperature is different too, so two things changed.
- The dark plant grew taller than the light plant but was yellow. Does that mean it grew better? Explain.Answer: ________________________✅ No. It grew tall and thin looking for light, but its yellow color shows it is not healthy.
- Plan a new fair test to see if plants grow better near the window or in the middle of the room. What do you change and keep the same?Answer: ________________________✅ Change the place (amount of light). Keep plant, cup, soil, water and temperature the same.
- Why is it good that every group did the same test?Answer: ________________________✅ If all groups get the same result, we are more sure it is true.
🔑 Answers
- The temperature is different too, so two things changed.
- No. It grew tall and thin looking for light, but its yellow color shows it is not healthy.
- Change the place (amount of light). Keep plant, cup, soil, water and temperature the same.
- If all groups get the same result, we are more sure it is true.
Plants need light: a fair test · 2nd Grade
✅ Quiz
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________ Score: ____ / 12
12 questions. Show them on the board and answer together, or give each student the quiz on their own device and see everyone’s score.
1. In our test, what did we change?
2. Which should stay the SAME for both cups?
3. Ben gave the light cup 1 spoon and the dark cup 3 spoons. What should he do?
4. Where should the dark cup go?
5. What tool do we use to measure the plants?
6. After a week, the dark plant is pale and yellow. What does it show?
7. Which test is NOT fair?
8. Why do all the groups do the same test?
9. Where do you start measuring a plant?
10. The dark plant is taller but yellow. Is it healthier?
11. What is a result?
12. Which words describe a fair test?
12 questions
In our test, what did we change?
- The water
- The light
- The soil
- The cup
Which should stay the SAME for both cups?
- The light
- The amount of water
- The box
- Nothing
Ben gave the light cup 1 spoon and the dark cup 3 spoons. What should he do?
- Give both cups 1 spoon
- Give the light cup no water
- Put both cups in the box
- Use a bigger cup
Where should the dark cup go?
- Next to the heater
- Outside
- In a box next to the light cup
- In the fridge
What tool do we use to measure the plants?
- A clock
- A thermometer
- A spoon
- A ruler
After a week, the dark plant is pale and yellow. What does it show?
- Plants need light to stay green and healthy
- Plants don’t need light
- Plants need boxes
- Plants need more soil
Which test is NOT fair?
- Same plant, same water, one in a box
- Same soil, same cup, one in a box
- Bean in the light, grass in the dark
- Same water, same plant, box next to the window
Why do all the groups do the same test?
- To make more mess
- To be more sure of the result
- To use more cups
- Because it is faster
Where do you start measuring a plant?
- From the table
- From the top of the cup
- From the soil
- From the window
The dark plant is taller but yellow. Is it healthier?
- Yes, taller is always better
- Yes, yellow is healthy
- We can’t ever know
- No, the yellow color shows it is not healthy
What is a result?
- What happened in the test
- A guess
- A kind of seed
- The box
Which words describe a fair test?
- Change everything
- Change one thing, keep the rest the same
- Change nothing
- Change two things
🖨️ Classroom aids to print
Word-wall cards for this lesson’s key words. They print on their own pages.
📤 Share this lesson
Plants need light: a fair test · 2nd Grade
🔑 Answer key
Easier worksheet
- light
- same
- box
- Two cups of seedlings, about the same.
Worksheet
- light
- the light (one cup in light, one in the dark)
- Any three: kind of plant, cup, soil, water, number of seedlings, place/temperature.
- Any prediction with a reason.
- yes
- no
- yes
- Measured heights each day; light cup green, dark cup turning pale or yellow.
- It turned pale or yellow (and often thin and droopy) — plants need light to grow well.
Challenge page
- The temperature is different too, so two things changed.
- No. It grew tall and thin looking for light, but its yellow color shows it is not healthy.
- Change the place (amount of light). Keep plant, cup, soil, water and temperature the same.
- If all groups get the same result, we are more sure it is true.
Quiz
- B — The light. Only the light was changed.
- B — The amount of water. In a light test, the water stays the same.
- A — Give both cups 1 spoon. Water must be the same so only light changes.
- C — In a box next to the light cup. Next to the light cup, so only light is different.
- D — A ruler. A ruler measures height.
- A — Plants need light to stay green and healthy. Only light was different, so light made the difference.
- C — Bean in the light, grass in the dark. Two things changed: the kind of plant and the light.
- B — To be more sure of the result. Repeating a test makes the result more trustworthy.
- C — From the soil. Put the ruler’s zero on the soil.
- D — No, the yellow color shows it is not healthy. Look at the color, not just the height.
- A — What happened in the test. The result is what really happened.
- B — Change one thing, keep the rest the same. Only one thing changes.
Where this lesson fits
- Before this lesson: Habitats around the world — Students compare the diversity of life in different habitats.
- This lesson: Students plan a fair test to show that plants need light.
- Coming next: Design a seed that travels — Students build a model that copies how seeds move by wind, water or animals.
🌟 Thinkabara Pro
Need this lesson made for your class?
The booklet on this page is free. With Pro you get versions of it: three levels for mixed classes, in Spanish, or adapted for IEP and ELL students — plus a new booklet on any topic you teach that is not in our library.
Make a version for my class — free trial → See a real sample
7 days free, no credit card.
Practice & resources on Thinkabara
🗓️ Plan the whole year like this
Add 2nd Grade Science to your free Lesson Planner: enter your class schedule once and every period shows the next lesson, skipping weekends and school breaks.
More lessons in “Plants, animals & habitats”
- What plants need to grow — Students plan and run an investigation on plants’ needs for water and light.
- Seed dispersal — Students model how animals or wind disperse seeds.
- Pollination — Students model how animals pollinate plants.
- Habitats around the world — Students compare the diversity of life in different habitats.
- Plants need light: a fair test — Students plan a fair test to show that plants need light.
- Design a seed that travels — Students build a model that copies how seeds move by wind, water or animals.
- Comparing two habitats — Students compare the plants and animals of two habitats.
Something to improve in this lesson? Tell us.