Stopping erosion
🎯 Objective: Students compare ways to slow wind or water from changing the land.
🦫 Thinkabara · Lesson booklet
Stopping erosion
2nd Grade · Science · 2-ESS2-1
🎯 Students compare ways to slow wind or water from changing the land.
- Teacher’s lesson plan
- Easier worksheet
- Student worksheet
- Challenge page
- Quiz
- Answer key
Teacher: ______________________ Class: ____________
📘 This lesson comes as a booklet: teacher’s plan, student worksheet, challenge page, quiz and answer key — all in one printable booklet. Teach from this page, print it all, or give the quiz to the class online.
Full-screen slides for the projector: goals, opener, every drawing already made, the exit ticket and the quiz — click or use the arrow keys.
🗓️ Lesson at a glance
⏱️ 57 minutes
- 5 min Opener (pick one)
- 5 min Teach: the problem
- 5 min Plan a fair test
- 18 min Run the tests
- 7 min Compare the results
- 3 min Exit ticket
- 6 min Wrap-up
- 8 min Handing out, moving and cleaning up
Not in these 57 minutes: the worksheets (independent practice tomorrow, in centers or as homework) and the quiz (after the practice, or at the end of the week).
🧰 Materials
- One plastic tray or baking pan per group, propped up a little at one end with a book
- Damp sand (enough to build the same hill 4 times)
- A rain cup (paper cup with small holes in the bottom) and a measuring cup of water per group
- Solutions: small rocks; thin kitchen sponges cut into small squares (to stand for grass and roots); craft sticks or a strip of cardboard for a wall
- 4 clear plastic cups per group and a spoon, to collect the sand that washes down
- A marker, paper towels, a bucket for used water
- The results table on the worksheet
🔤 Key words
- erosion
- When wind or water carries sand, soil or rock away.
- engineer
- A person who designs and tests solutions to problems.
- solution
- A way to solve a problem.
- fair test
- A test where only one thing changes and everything else stays the same.
- compare
- To look at results side by side to see which is more or less.
- roots
- The parts of a plant under the ground that hold it in place and take in water.
🎯 Success criteria — read them to the class
- I can test different ways to slow water from washing away land.
- I can keep a test fair by changing only one thing.
- I can use my results to choose the best solution and explain why.
🎬 Open the lesson — pick one (5 min)
Get the class moving, curious and talking before the learning starts. Each one leads straight into today’s topic.
🤸 Brain break: Hold the hill
- Stand up behind your chair.
- Be a sand hill: crouch a little and make a round shape with your arms.
- Here comes the rain: wiggle your fingers down over your head.
- Be a wall: stand tall and hold your arms straight in front of you, strong!
- Be grass roots: wiggle your toes and hold the ground tight.
- Sit down slowly.
Say: “Rain can wash a sand hill away. Walls, rocks and plant roots can help hold it. Today you are engineers testing which one works best.”
🧩 Riddle
“I grow under the ground where you can’t see me. I am thin like strings, but I hold the soil tight so the rain can’t wash it away. What am I?”
Hint: Every plant has me.
Answer
Roots! Plant roots hold soil in place. Today we test plants, rocks and walls to slow erosion.
🎁 Mystery object
Do: Show two photos of the same kind of hill after a big rain: one bare with deep muddy grooves, one covered with grass and almost unchanged. Cover the labels.
Say: “Both hills got the same rain. Why does one look so different?”
Reveal: The grassy hill was protected — roots held the soil and the grass slowed the water. Today we test different ways to protect a hill.
🤔 Would you rather
“Would you rather protect a hill with a wall, with rocks, or with plants?”
Do: Students go to one of three corners and tell a partner why they chose it.
Then: Engineers don’t just pick — they test and compare. Let’s find out which one works best in our model.
🧑🏫 Teach it step by step
1 Teach: the problem 5 min
Do:- Pour a little water on a small bare sand hill in a tray, in front of the class.
Say:“Remember erosion? Look — the water is carrying sand down the hill.”
“In real life, erosion can wash soil away from farms, wash sand off beaches and make the ground under houses and roads less safe.”
“People try to slow erosion. They put rocks on riverbanks, build walls, and plant grass and trees, because roots hold soil.”
“Today you are engineers. We will test three solutions and compare them.”
Ask: Why do people want to slow erosion near houses and roads?
Look for: So the soil under them does not wash away and they stay safe.
2 Plan a fair test 5 min
Do:- Write the 4 tests on the board: 1. no solution, 2. rocks, 3. sponges (grass), 4. wall.
Say:“To compare fairly, everything must be the same except the solution.”
“Same tray, same tilt. Same hill size — we fill the same cup with sand to make each hill. Same amount of water, poured from the same rain cup at the same height.”
“After each rain, we scoop the sand that washed down to the bottom into a clear cup. More sand in the cup means more erosion.”
Ask: What changes in each test? What stays the same?
Look for: Only the solution changes; hill size, water amount and pouring stay the same.
3 Run the tests 18 min
Do:- Groups of 4 with roles: hill builder, rain maker, sand scooper, recorder. Switch roles each test.
- Test 1: bare hill. Test 2: rocks on the hill. Test 3: sponge squares pressed into the hill. Test 4: a wall of craft sticks at the bottom of the hill.
- After each test, scoop the washed-down sand into a clear cup and label it. Rebuild the hill with the same cup of sand.
Say:“Rain maker: pour the whole cup of water into the rain cup, holding it at the top of the hill each time.”
“Scooper: scoop only the sand at the bottom of the tray into the cup.”
“Recorder: write what you see in the table.”
Ask: Walk around: “Is your hill the same size as last time? How do you know?”
Look for: We used the same cup of sand.
Ask: “What do the sponges stand for?”
Look for: Grass and plant roots that hold soil.
4 Compare the results 7 min
Do:- Groups line up their 4 cups in order from most sand to least sand.
- Each group reports their order. Make a class chart: which solution had the least sand in most groups?
Say:“Line up your cups. Which cup has the most sand? That test had the most erosion.”
“Which cup has the least sand? That solution worked best in your test.”
“Let’s look at all the groups. Did most groups get the same winner? If groups disagree, that is useful too — scientists repeat tests to be sure.”
Ask: Which solution worked best for your group? What is your evidence?
Look for: The one whose cup has the least sand (any answer backed by the cups).
Ask: Why might two groups get different results?
Look for: They poured differently, built hills differently, or placed the solution differently.
5 Exit ticket 3 min
Do:- Students write in the box at the bottom of the worksheet.
Say:“Which solution worked best in your test? Write one reason, using your cups as evidence.”
✅ Correct answer: Any solution, if the student names it and backs it with evidence from the cups, e.g. “The rocks worked best — the rocks cup had the least sand.” (A choice without evidence — “I like rocks” — is not yet; ask: what did your cups show?)
✓ Wrap-up 6 min
Do:- Read the three “I can” statements aloud.
- Clean up: wet sand into the bin, sponges and rocks rinsed into a tub, trays stacked.
Say:“Tell your partner one real place where people could use your best solution.”
“Show 1, 2 or 3 fingers for how sure you feel about each “I can”.”
💡 Teacher tips
- Do the cleanup plan before the lesson: a sand bin, a tub for rocks and sponges, a bucket for water. Never pour sand down the sink.
- Measure the sand for each hill with the same cup — it is the easiest way to keep the test fair.
- Prop the trays with a book so water drains toward one end; the washed sand collects there and is easy to scoop.
- Results will vary. That is fine — the goal is comparing with evidence, not one ‘right’ winner.
- Assign roles and switch them every test so every student pours, scoops and records once.
💬 Discussion questions
- Why did we use the same amount of water every time?
So only the solution changed; then we know the solution caused the difference.
- Why do plants help stop erosion in real life?
Their roots hold the soil and the leaves slow the rain and water.
- Is there a solution that stops erosion completely?
Not usually — solutions slow erosion. Some work better than others.
⚠️ Common mistakes and how to fix them
❌ Changing two things at once (a new solution AND more water).
✔️ Ask: “If two things changed, how do we know which one made the difference?”
❌ Choosing a winner without looking at the evidence.
✔️ Point to the cups: the least sand shows the best result.
❌ Thinking one test proves it forever.
✔️ Compare with other groups; scientists repeat tests.
🧩 For every learner
🤝 Extra support
- Test only 2 solutions: bare hill and rocks.
- Give the recorder a table with pictures for each test.
- Sentence frame: “The ___ cup had the least sand, so ___ worked best.”
🚀 Challenge
- Combine two solutions (rocks + wall) and predict before testing.
- Explain how you would make the test even fairer.
- Draw a plan for protecting a real hill near a road.
🌎 English learners
- Show each solution and say its name: rocks, sponge (grass), wall.
- Act out roles before starting: builder, rain maker, scooper, recorder.
- Sentence frame: “___ worked best because ___.”
🏠 At home: Look around your home or a park with a family member. Find one place where people tried to slow erosion: grass on a slope, rocks along a ditch, a small wall. Draw it and tell how it helps.
📊 After the exit ticket and quiz: what to do tomorrow
Sort the exit tickets (or open the quiz results — they group the class for you) and start tomorrow with 10 minutes in three groups.
✅ Got it
- Start “Water: solid and liquid”.
- Early finishers: plan a combined solution on the Challenge sheet.
🟡 Almost
- 5 minutes: look at a group’s cups and say “___ worked best because the cup had ___ sand.”
- Then explain one thing that stayed the same in every test.
🔁 Not yet
- Small group with the teacher: compare just two cups (bare hill and rocks). Which has more sand? Which hill lost more?
- Then the Easier worksheet with the teacher nearby.
Stopping erosion · 2nd Grade
🤝 My erosion test
Same skill, smaller numbers and fill-in-the-blank steps — for students who need extra support. Everyone else starts on the main worksheet.
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Circle the answer.
- More sand in the cup means MORE / LESS erosion.Answer: ________________________✅ MORE
- A fair test changes ONE / MANY things.Answer: ________________________✅ ONE
- Plant roots HOLD / MOVE the soil.Answer: ________________________✅ HOLD
B. Draw your best solution.
- My best solution✅ A drawing of the solution that had the least sand in its cup.
🔑 Answers
- MORE
- ONE
- HOLD
- A drawing of the solution that had the least sand in its cup.
Stopping erosion · 2nd Grade
📝 Engineers test erosion solutions
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Results table. Draw how much sand is in each cup (low, middle or high).
- Test 1 — no solution✅ Usually the most sand.
- Test 2 — rocks✅ Less sand than test 1 (results vary).
- Test 3 — sponges (grass)✅ Less sand than test 1 (results vary).
- Test 4 — wall✅ Less sand than test 1 (results vary).
B. Answer.
- Which test had the most erosion? How do you know?Answer: ________________________✅ Usually test 1 (no solution) — its cup had the most sand.
- Which solution worked best in your test?Answer: ________________________✅ The one with the least sand in its cup (any, with evidence).
- What did we keep the same in every test?Answer: ________________________✅ Hill size, amount of water, how we poured, the tilt of the tray.
- Name one real place where people could use your best solution.Answer: ________________________✅ A riverbank, a beach, a hill by a road, a farm field.
🔑 Answers
- Usually the most sand.
- Less sand than test 1 (results vary).
- Less sand than test 1 (results vary).
- Less sand than test 1 (results vary).
- Usually test 1 (no solution) — its cup had the most sand.
- The one with the least sand in its cup (any, with evidence).
- Hill size, amount of water, how we poured, the tilt of the tray.
- A riverbank, a beach, a hill by a road, a farm field.
Stopping erosion · 2nd Grade
🚀 Challenge: improve the design
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Think and explain.
- Lily’s group poured 1 cup of water on the bare hill and half a cup on the rock hill. They say rocks worked best. Can they be sure? Why?Answer: ________________________✅ No. They used less water on the rock hill, so the test was not fair; the smaller amount of water could be why less sand moved.
- How could you combine two solutions to protect the hill even better? Predict what will happen.Answer: ________________________✅ E.g. sponges (grass) on the hill plus a wall at the bottom; predict even less sand will wash down.
- Why do people plant grass and trees on hills next to roads?Answer: ________________________✅ Roots hold the soil and the plants slow the rainwater, so less soil washes onto the road.
🔑 Answers
- No. They used less water on the rock hill, so the test was not fair; the smaller amount of water could be why less sand moved.
- E.g. sponges (grass) on the hill plus a wall at the bottom; predict even less sand will wash down.
- Roots hold the soil and the plants slow the rainwater, so less soil washes onto the road.
Stopping erosion · 2nd Grade
✅ Quiz
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________ Score: ____ / 11
11 questions. Show them on the board and answer together, or give each student the quiz on their own device and see everyone’s score.
1. What does a fair test change?
2. In our test, more sand in the cup means…
3. What did the sponge squares stand for?
4. How do plant roots help stop erosion?
5. Cups of washed sand: no solution = 6 spoons, rocks = 2, wall = 4, sponges = 3. Which worked best?
6. Using the same cups (6, 2, 4, 3 spoons), which test had the most erosion?
7. Sam poured more water on the wall hill than on the bare hill. What is wrong?
8. Which is NOT a way people slow erosion?
9. Why did we use the same cup of sand to build each hill?
10. Two groups chose different best solutions. What should scientists do?
11. Where would a wall of rocks help most?
11 questions
What does a fair test change?
- Everything
- Only one thing
- Nothing at all
- Two things
In our test, more sand in the cup means…
- less erosion
- more erosion
- no erosion
- the wall worked best
What did the sponge squares stand for?
- Rocks
- A wall
- Grass and roots
- Rain
How do plant roots help stop erosion?
- They make it rain less
- They hold the soil in place
- They push the soil away
- They dry the soil
Cups of washed sand: no solution = 6 spoons, rocks = 2, wall = 4, sponges = 3. Which worked best?
- Rocks
- Wall
- Sponges
- No solution
Using the same cups (6, 2, 4, 3 spoons), which test had the most erosion?
- Rocks
- Sponges
- Wall
- No solution
Sam poured more water on the wall hill than on the bare hill. What is wrong?
- Nothing
- He used the wrong sand
- The test is not fair — the water amount changed
- He should use hot water
Which is NOT a way people slow erosion?
- Planting grass
- Putting rocks on a riverbank
- Building a wall
- Digging up all the plants
Why did we use the same cup of sand to build each hill?
- To make the hills the same size
- To make the hills taller
- To save time
- To make more erosion
Two groups chose different best solutions. What should scientists do?
- Give up
- Repeat the test and compare results
- Pick the group with neater writing
- Change everything
Where would a wall of rocks help most?
- Inside a closet
- On a riverbank
- On a rooftop
- In a school library
🖨️ Classroom aids to print
Word-wall cards for this lesson’s key words. They print on their own pages.
📤 Share this lesson
Stopping erosion · 2nd Grade
🔑 Answer key
Easier worksheet
- MORE
- ONE
- HOLD
- A drawing of the solution that had the least sand in its cup.
Worksheet
- Usually the most sand.
- Less sand than test 1 (results vary).
- Less sand than test 1 (results vary).
- Less sand than test 1 (results vary).
- Usually test 1 (no solution) — its cup had the most sand.
- The one with the least sand in its cup (any, with evidence).
- Hill size, amount of water, how we poured, the tilt of the tray.
- A riverbank, a beach, a hill by a road, a farm field.
Challenge page
- No. They used less water on the rock hill, so the test was not fair; the smaller amount of water could be why less sand moved.
- E.g. sponges (grass) on the hill plus a wall at the bottom; predict even less sand will wash down.
- Roots hold the soil and the plants slow the rainwater, so less soil washes onto the road.
Quiz
- B — Only one thing. Change one thing so you know what caused the result.
- B — more erosion. The cup holds the sand the water washed down.
- C — Grass and roots. Sponges stood for plants that hold soil.
- B — They hold the soil in place. Roots hold soil together.
- A — Rocks. Rocks had the least sand (2 spoons).
- D — No solution. No solution had the most sand, 6 spoons.
- C — The test is not fair — the water amount changed. Only the solution should change.
- D — Digging up all the plants. Removing plants makes erosion worse.
- A — To make the hills the same size. Same-size hills keep the test fair.
- B — Repeat the test and compare results. Repeating tests helps us be sure.
- B — On a riverbank. Rocks along a riverbank slow the water washing soil away.
Where this lesson fits
- Before this lesson: Landforms — Students name and model mountains, hills, valleys and plains.
- This lesson: Students compare ways to slow wind or water from changing the land.
- Coming next: Water: solid and liquid — Students find where water is solid ice and where it is liquid on Earth.
🌟 Thinkabara Pro
Need this lesson made for your class?
The booklet on this page is free. With Pro you get versions of it: three levels for mixed classes, in Spanish, or adapted for IEP and ELL students — plus a new booklet on any topic you teach that is not in our library.
Make a version for my class — free trial → See a real sample
7 days free, no credit card.
Practice & resources on Thinkabara
🗓️ Plan the whole year like this
Add 2nd Grade Science to your free Lesson Planner: enter your class schedule once and every period shows the next lesson, skipping weekends and school breaks.
More lessons in “Earth’s land & water”
- Fast and slow changes — Students compare quick events (earthquakes) and slow events (erosion).
- Wind and water erosion — Students model erosion and compare solutions to slow it.
- Maps of land and water — Students model shapes and kinds of land and water in an area.
- Where water is found — Students identify where water is found as solid or liquid.
- Landforms — Students name and model mountains, hills, valleys and plains.
- Stopping erosion — Students compare ways to slow wind or water from changing the land.
- Water: solid and liquid — Students find where water is solid ice and where it is liquid on Earth.
Something to improve in this lesson? Tell us.