Building for earthquakes
🎯 Objective: Students design and test a structure that stays up when the ground shakes.
🦫 Thinkabara · Lesson booklet
Building for earthquakes
4th Grade · Science · 4-ESS3-2
🎯 Students design and test a structure that stays up when the ground shakes.
- Teacher’s lesson plan
- Easier worksheet
- Student worksheet
- Challenge page
- Quiz
- Answer key
Teacher: ______________________ Class: ____________
📘 This lesson comes as a booklet: teacher’s plan, student worksheet, challenge page, quiz and answer key — all in one printable booklet. Teach from this page, print it all, or give the quiz to the class online.
Full-screen slides for the projector: goals, opener, every drawing already made, the exit ticket and the quiz — click or use the arrow keys.
🗓️ Lesson at a glance
⏱️ 60 minutes
- 5 min Opener (pick one)
- 7 min Teach: what helps a building survive shaking
- 6 min The challenge: criteria and constraints
- 14 min Build prototype 1
- 8 min Test on the shake table
- 8 min Improve and retest
- 3 min Exit ticket
- 3 min Wrap-up
- 6 min Handing out, moving and cleaning up
Not in these 60 minutes: the worksheets (independent practice tomorrow, in centers or as homework) and the quiz (after the practice, or at the end of the week).
🧰 Materials
- Toothpicks (30 per group) and one ball of modeling clay per group, about the size of a golf ball
- Shake tables: a shoe-box lid or small tray placed on 6–8 marbles inside a larger baking tray
- One small eraser or washer per group as the “roof weight”
- Rulers and a timer
- Pictures of a cracked road or a damaged wall after an earthquake (no people)
- Planning sheet (worksheet)
🔤 Key words
- engineer
- A person who designs and builds things to solve problems.
- criteria
- What a design must do to succeed, like stand up while shaking.
- constraints
- Limits on a design, like the materials and time you are allowed.
- base
- The bottom part of a structure that rests on the ground.
- brace
- An extra piece, often diagonal, that makes a structure stiffer.
- prototype
- A first model of a design that you test and then improve.
🎯 Success criteria — read them to the class
- I can design a tower that meets criteria and stays inside the constraints.
- I can test my tower fairly on a shake table and record what happens.
- I can improve my design and explain which change helped most.
🎬 Open the lesson — pick one (5 min)
Get the class moving, curious and talking before the learning starts. Each one leads straight into today’s topic.
🤸 Brain break: Strong stance
- Stand up with your feet close together. I will count to 3 — sway very gently side to side. Feel how wobbly you are?
- Now spread your feet wide, as wide as your shoulders. Sway gently again. Steadier?
- Bend your knees a little and sway again — like a skier.
- Stand tall, arms crossed in an X in front of your chest. Hold for 3 seconds.
- Relax your arms and sit down.
Say: “A wide base and bending a little made you steadier. Your crossed arms made a strong X shape. Engineers use these same ideas to help buildings stay up when the ground shakes — and today you get to test them.”
🧩 Riddle
“I have three sides and three corners. Push on my corner and I don’t squish into a different shape, the way a square can. Engineers put me in bridges, towers and roofs to make them stiff. What shape am I?”
Hint: Look at the shape made by a bridge’s metal beams.
Answer
A triangle — today’s secret building tool.
🎁 Mystery object
Do: Build two small towers before class from toothpicks and clay: one square box shape and one with a diagonal toothpick across each side (making triangles). Hide them under a towel.
Say: “Under the towel are two towers made of the same materials. I will gently push the top of each one sideways. Predict: will they act the same?”
Reveal: Lift the towel and push each one gently. The square box leans and squishes; the one with diagonals (triangles) stays stiff. The design — not the materials — made the difference.
🤔 Would you rather
“Would you rather live in a tall, thin tower or a short, wide building in a place that has earthquakes?”
Do: Students make a tall thin shape with their arms or a short wide shape, then tell a partner why.
Then: Many people choose short and wide, and that’s a smart start — a wide base is harder to tip. But engineers can make tall buildings safe too, with good design. You’ll test it today!
🧑🏫 Teach it step by step
1 Teach: what helps a building survive shaking 7 min
Do:- Show the earthquake pictures (a cracked road, a damaged wall). Then show the board slide — or write three design ideas: wide base, triangles (braces), heavy parts low.
Say:“In the last lesson we saw that many earthquakes happen near plate edges. People live in those places, so engineers design buildings to stay standing when the ground shakes.”
“Idea 1: a wide base. A wide bottom is harder to tip over — like your wide stance.”
“Idea 2: triangles. A square frame can squish sideways, but a triangle keeps its shape. Engineers add diagonal braces that make triangles.”
“Idea 3: keep heavy things low. A heavy top makes a tower sway and tip more easily.”
“Today you are engineers. Your job is to design, build, test and improve a tower.”
Ask: Why do engineers add diagonal braces?
Look for: They make triangles, which keep their shape and stop the frame from squishing sideways.
2 The challenge: criteria and constraints 6 min
Do:- Write the challenge on the board. Groups of 3–4 sketch a plan on the worksheet before they get materials.
Say:“Criteria — your tower must: be at least 15 centimeters tall, hold the eraser roof on top, and stay standing for 10 seconds of shaking.”
“Constraints — you may use only 30 toothpicks and one ball of clay, and you have 14 minutes to build.”
“Sketch first. Show where your base, your triangles and your roof will be. Every group member adds one idea.”
Ask: What is the difference between criteria and constraints?
Look for: Criteria are what the tower must do; constraints are the limits — materials and time.
3 Build prototype 1 14 min
Do:- Hand out materials. Groups build using small clay balls as joints and toothpicks as beams.
- Measure the height with a ruler before testing. Count the toothpicks used.
Say:“Use small pieces of clay at each joint — big blobs make the top heavy.”
“Wiggle your tower gently with one finger as you build. If it squishes, where could a triangle help?”
“Remember: you can only use 30 toothpicks. Keep count.”
Ask: Walk around and ask: “Where are the triangles in your tower?”
Look for: They point to diagonal toothpicks making triangles on the sides.
Ask: “How tall is it right now? Will it meet the 15 cm criterion?”
Look for: They measure and compare with 15 cm.
4 Test on the shake table 8 min
Do:- One group at a time places its tower on the shake table with the eraser roof on top.
- Fair test: the teacher (or one chosen shaker) slides the tray side to side the same distance (about 5 cm each way) for 10 seconds at the same speed for every group.
- Groups record: stood / leaned / fell, and at how many seconds it fell, if it did.
Say:“To be fair, every tower gets the same shake: same distance, same speed, same time.”
“Watch closely where each tower bends or breaks first. That’s the weak spot to fix.”
Ask: Why should the same person shake every tower the same way?
Look for: So only the tower design is different; otherwise a harder shake could unfairly knock a tower down.
Ask: Where did your tower fail first?
Look for: Answers vary: a joint at the base, the top swaying, a square side squishing.
5 Improve and retest 8 min
Do:- Groups choose ONE change based on the weak spot: add braces, widen the base, move clay lower, or shorten the tower (but still 15 cm or taller).
- Rebuild for 5 minutes, then retest with the same shake. Record the result next to the first test.
Say:“Change one thing so you know what helped. If you change three things, you can’t tell which one worked.”
“Engineers almost never get it right the first time. Testing, fixing and testing again is how designs get better.”
Ask: Which change did your group make, and did it help?
Look for: They name one change and compare the two test results.
6 Exit ticket 3 min
Do:- Students answer on a sticky note or at the bottom of the worksheet.
Say:“What one change helped your tower the most? Use your test results as evidence. If nothing helped, what would you try next?”
✅ Correct answer: For example: “Adding diagonal braces helped most. Our first tower fell at 4 seconds; with braces it stood all 10 seconds.” Any change with before-and-after results, or a reasoned next idea (wider base, triangles, lighter top). (An answer with no test result is almost there — ask what happened in each test.)
✓ Wrap-up 3 min
Do:- Read the three “I can” statements aloud.
- Sort the exit tickets into three piles: got it / almost / not yet.
Say:“Tell your neighbor one design idea that real engineers use for earthquake buildings, and why it works.”
“Show me with your fingers how sure you are about each “I can”: 1 = not yet, 2 = almost, 3 = I can teach it.”
💡 Teacher tips
- Make and try the shake table before class. Taping a short loop of string to the lid lets you pull it the same distance each time.
- Count out 30 toothpicks per group into cups ahead of time — handing out loose toothpicks costs minutes.
- Choose earthquake pictures that show damage to things, not people, and keep the conversation on how engineers help people stay safe.
- You be the only shaker for the whole class; a fair, steady shake keeps arguments down.
- Line up all the towers on a table at the end — students quickly see that the winners share wide bases and triangles.
💬 Discussion questions
- Why do towers with triangles do better on the shake table?
Triangles keep their shape when pushed, so the frame doesn’t squish sideways and fall.
- Why is it important to test, improve and test again?
Testing shows weak spots; fixing one thing at a time shows what really helps.
- How does this connect to our map of earthquakes?
People in places near plate edges need buildings designed to handle shaking, so engineers use ideas like these where earthquakes are common.
⚠️ Common mistakes and how to fix them
❌ Building tall first and adding a base later.
✔️ Start from the base: make a wide, braced bottom before building up.
❌ Using big blobs of clay at the top.
✔️ Use small clay joints; keep heavy parts low.
❌ Changing many things before the retest.
✔️ Change one thing so you know which change helped.
❌ Shaking towers differently.
✔️ One shaker, same distance and same time for every test.
🧩 For every learner
🤝 Extra support
- Give a picture of a triangle-braced cube to copy for the base.
- Sentence frame: “Our tower ___ (stood / fell) because ___.”
- Assign roles: builder, counter (toothpicks), measurer, recorder.
🚀 Challenge
- Try to build the tallest tower that still survives 10 seconds of shaking. Record the height.
- Compare: does a wider base or more braces help more? Plan a fair test.
- Write a short letter to a city explaining two ideas for safer buildings, using your data.
🌎 English learners
- Label real objects: toothpick = beam, clay = joint, triangle, base.
- Sentence frame: “We changed ___. It helped / did not help.”
- Show, point and act: wide feet = wide base; crossed arms = brace.
🏠 At home: Build a mini tower at home with paper strips and tape (or folded paper). Gently shake the table it stands on. Add a triangle brace and test again. Tell your family what changed.
📊 After the exit ticket and quiz: what to do tomorrow
Sort the exit tickets (or open the quiz results — they group the class for you) and start tomorrow with 10 minutes in three groups.
✅ Got it
- This is the last lesson of the unit — use the challenge sheet’s data question as a review, or start the next unit.
- Early finishers: build a 25 cm tower that still survives the shake.
🟡 Almost
- 5 minutes: compare two towers (braced and unbraced) on the shake table and write one sentence of evidence.
- Practice naming criteria vs. constraints with the challenge card.
🔁 Not yet
- Small group with the teacher: build one braced square and one plain square, push each gently, and say why the triangle helps.
- Then the Easier worksheet (record and circle) with the teacher nearby.
Building for earthquakes · 4th Grade
🤝 Tower test: record it
Same skill, smaller numbers and fill-in-the-blank steps — for students who need extra support. Everyone else starts on the main worksheet.
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Fill in your results.
- Our tower was ___ cm tall and used ___ toothpicks.Answer: ________________________✅ Answers vary; at least 15 cm, at most 30 toothpicks.
- Test 1: our tower ______ (stood / leaned / fell).Answer: ________________________✅ Answers vary.
- The one thing we changed was ______.Answer: ________________________✅ Answers vary, e.g., added braces, widened the base.
- Test 2: our tower ______ (stood / leaned / fell).Answer: ________________________✅ Answers vary.
B. Circle the idea that makes a tower stronger.
- narrow base / wide baseAnswer: ________________________✅ wide base
- squares only / trianglesAnswer: ________________________✅ triangles
🔑 Answers
- Answers vary; at least 15 cm, at most 30 toothpicks.
- Answers vary.
- Answers vary, e.g., added braces, widened the base.
- Answers vary.
- wide base
- triangles
Building for earthquakes · 4th Grade
📝 Design an earthquake-safe tower
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Plan: sketch your tower before you build. Label the base, the triangles and the roof.
- Prototype 1 sketch.✅ Sketch with labeled base, diagonal braces (triangles) and roof.
B. Test results.
- Height of prototype 1: ___ cm. Does it meet the 15 cm criterion?Answer: ________________________✅ Answers vary; yes if 15 cm or more.
- Test 1 result (stood / leaned / fell at ___ seconds):Answer: ________________________✅ Answers vary.
- Where did it fail first, or where was it weakest?Answer: ________________________✅ Answers vary, e.g., the base joints, a square side, the top swaying.
- The one change we made, and the test 2 result:Answer: ________________________✅ Answers vary; one named change and the new result.
C. Think about it.
- Group A’s tower used 34 toothpicks and stood. Did it succeed? Explain.Answer: ________________________✅ No — it broke a constraint (only 30 toothpicks allowed), even though it stood.
- Group B shook their tower harder than everyone else and it fell. Was that a fair test? Why?Answer: ________________________✅ No. Every tower must get the same shake (same distance, speed and time); a harder shake isn’t fair.
- Why do triangles make a tower stronger?Answer: ________________________✅ A triangle keeps its shape when pushed, so braces stop the frame from squishing sideways.
- Name two ways real engineers help buildings survive earthquakes.Answer: ________________________✅ Any two: wide bases, diagonal braces/triangles, keeping heavy parts low, strong joints, designs that bend a little without breaking.
🔑 Answers
- Sketch with labeled base, diagonal braces (triangles) and roof.
- Answers vary; yes if 15 cm or more.
- Answers vary.
- Answers vary, e.g., the base joints, a square side, the top swaying.
- Answers vary; one named change and the new result.
- No — it broke a constraint (only 30 toothpicks allowed), even though it stood.
- No. Every tower must get the same shake (same distance, speed and time); a harder shake isn’t fair.
- A triangle keeps its shape when pushed, so braces stop the frame from squishing sideways.
- Any two: wide bases, diagonal braces/triangles, keeping heavy parts low, strong joints, designs that bend a little without breaking.
Building for earthquakes · 4th Grade
🚀 Challenge: engineer’s report
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Analyze the class data.
- Six towers were tested. 4 had diagonal braces and all 4 stood. 2 had no braces and both fell. What can you conclude? What else would you want to check?Answer: ________________________✅ Braces seem to help a lot: 4 of 4 braced towers stood, 0 of 2 unbraced stood. I would check that the towers were the same height and base width, and test more towers, to be sure it was the braces.
- Your tower stood with a 15 cm height. You want to make it 25 cm. Predict what might happen and name one change you would add.Answer: ________________________✅ A taller tower sways more and may tip; add more braces and a wider base, and keep clay joints small at the top.
- Why is it better to change only one thing between tests?Answer: ________________________✅ So you know which change caused the different result.
B. Design.
- Draw your best design for a 25 cm tower. Label every feature that helps it survive shaking and explain each one.✅ Drawing with labeled wide base, triangles/braces, light top; short reasons for each.
🔑 Answers
- Braces seem to help a lot: 4 of 4 braced towers stood, 0 of 2 unbraced stood. I would check that the towers were the same height and base width, and test more towers, to be sure it was the braces.
- A taller tower sways more and may tip; add more braces and a wider base, and keep clay joints small at the top.
- So you know which change caused the different result.
- Drawing with labeled wide base, triangles/braces, light top; short reasons for each.
Building for earthquakes · 4th Grade
✅ Quiz
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________ Score: ____ / 12
12 questions. Show them on the board and answer together, or give each student the quiz on their own device and see everyone’s score.
1. Which shape keeps its form best when you push on its corner?
2. Which tower is hardest to tip over?
3. What are constraints in our challenge?
4. Group A’s tower used 34 toothpicks and stood. What is the problem?
5. Why should every tower get the same shake?
6. Maya changed the base, added braces and made the tower shorter all at once. Her tower stood. What can’t she know?
7. What is a brace?
8. Test 1: fell at 4 seconds. After adding braces, test 2: stood 10 seconds. What does this show?
9. Which change would most likely make a tower WORSE in an earthquake?
10. Why do engineers design special buildings for places near plate edges?
11. What is a prototype?
12. After a test, what should an engineer do next?
12 questions
Which shape keeps its form best when you push on its corner?
- A triangle
- A square
- A circle made of toothpicks
- A rectangle
Which tower is hardest to tip over?
- Tall with a narrow base
- Short with a wide base
- Heavy on top
- Standing on one toothpick
What are constraints in our challenge?
- The tower must stand 10 seconds
- The roof must stay on
- Only 30 toothpicks, 1 ball of clay and 14 minutes
- The tower must be pretty
Group A’s tower used 34 toothpicks and stood. What is the problem?
- Nothing — it stood
- It was too short
- It used clay
- It broke a constraint by using more than 30 toothpicks
Why should every tower get the same shake?
- So the test is fair
- To save time
- So towers fall faster
- Because marbles are expensive
Maya changed the base, added braces and made the tower shorter all at once. Her tower stood. What can’t she know?
- Whether her tower stood
- Which change helped
- How many toothpicks she had
- What the shake table is
What is a brace?
- The roof weight
- A ball of clay
- An extra, often diagonal piece that makes a structure stiffer
- The shake table
Test 1: fell at 4 seconds. After adding braces, test 2: stood 10 seconds. What does this show?
- Braces made the tower weaker
- Braces probably helped the tower survive shaking
- The shake was different
- Nothing can be learned
Which change would most likely make a tower WORSE in an earthquake?
- Adding braces
- Making the base wider
- Using small clay joints
- Putting a big heavy blob of clay on top
Why do engineers design special buildings for places near plate edges?
- Earthquakes are more common there
- It is always sunny there
- There are no earthquakes there
- Plates are softer there
What is a prototype?
- The final, perfect building
- A first model you test and improve
- A kind of earthquake
- A type of clay
After a test, what should an engineer do next?
- Throw the design away
- Shake harder
- Find the weak spot and improve one thing
- Stop testing
🖨️ Classroom aids to print
Word-wall cards for this lesson’s key words. They print on their own pages.
📤 Share this lesson
Building for earthquakes · 4th Grade
🔑 Answer key
Easier worksheet
- Answers vary; at least 15 cm, at most 30 toothpicks.
- Answers vary.
- Answers vary, e.g., added braces, widened the base.
- Answers vary.
- wide base
- triangles
Worksheet
- Sketch with labeled base, diagonal braces (triangles) and roof.
- Answers vary; yes if 15 cm or more.
- Answers vary.
- Answers vary, e.g., the base joints, a square side, the top swaying.
- Answers vary; one named change and the new result.
- No — it broke a constraint (only 30 toothpicks allowed), even though it stood.
- No. Every tower must get the same shake (same distance, speed and time); a harder shake isn’t fair.
- A triangle keeps its shape when pushed, so braces stop the frame from squishing sideways.
- Any two: wide bases, diagonal braces/triangles, keeping heavy parts low, strong joints, designs that bend a little without breaking.
Challenge page
- Braces seem to help a lot: 4 of 4 braced towers stood, 0 of 2 unbraced stood. I would check that the towers were the same height and base width, and test more towers, to be sure it was the braces.
- A taller tower sways more and may tip; add more braces and a wider base, and keep clay joints small at the top.
- So you know which change caused the different result.
- Drawing with labeled wide base, triangles/braces, light top; short reasons for each.
Quiz
- A — A triangle. Triangles don’t squish into a new shape; squares and rectangles can.
- B — Short with a wide base. A wide base and low weight make a tower steadier.
- C — Only 30 toothpicks, 1 ball of clay and 14 minutes. Constraints are the limits on materials and time.
- D — It broke a constraint by using more than 30 toothpicks. A design must meet the criteria inside the constraints.
- A — So the test is fair. Only the tower design should be different between tests.
- B — Which change helped. She changed three things, so she can’t tell which one made the difference.
- C — An extra, often diagonal piece that makes a structure stiffer. Braces make triangles that stop squishing.
- B — Braces probably helped the tower survive shaking. One change, same shake, better result — the braces likely helped.
- D — Putting a big heavy blob of clay on top. Heavy tops make towers sway and tip.
- A — Earthquakes are more common there. Many earthquakes happen near plate edges.
- B — A first model you test and improve. Engineers test prototypes and make them better.
- C — Find the weak spot and improve one thing. Test, find the weak spot, improve, test again.
Where this lesson fits
- Before this lesson: Earthquakes and volcanoes on a map — Students find patterns in where earthquakes and volcanoes happen.
- This lesson: Students design and test a structure that stays up when the ground shakes.
🌟 Thinkabara Pro
Need this lesson made for your class?
The booklet on this page is free. With Pro you get versions of it: three levels for mixed classes, in Spanish, or adapted for IEP and ELL students — plus a new booklet on any topic you teach that is not in our library.
Make a version for my class — free trial → See a real sample
7 days free, no credit card.
Practice & resources on Thinkabara
🗓️ Plan the whole year like this
Add 4th Grade Science to your free Lesson Planner: enter your class schedule once and every period shows the next lesson, skipping weekends and school breaks.
More lessons in “Earth’s processes & history”
- Rock layers — Students use rock layers and fossils to explain change over time.
- Weathering and erosion — Students measure the effects of water, ice, wind and plants.
- Maps of Earth’s features — Students analyze maps for patterns of mountains, volcanoes and earthquakes.
- Reducing hazards — Students design solutions to reduce the impact of natural hazards.
- Fossils in rock layers — Students use fossils in rock layers to explain how a landscape changed.
- Water shapes the land — Students measure how the amount and speed of water change erosion.
- Earthquakes and volcanoes on a map — Students find patterns in where earthquakes and volcanoes happen.
- Building for earthquakes — Students design and test a structure that stays up when the ground shakes.
Something to improve in this lesson? Tell us.