🔬 5th Grade · Science5-LS2-1Unit 2: Matter & energy in ecosystems

When one part changes

🎯 Objective: Students predict what happens to an ecosystem when one organism is removed.

📘 This lesson comes as a booklet: teacher’s plan, student worksheet, challenge page, quiz and answer key — all in one printable booklet. Teach from this page, print it all, or give the quiz to the class online.

Full-screen slides for the projector: goals, opener, every drawing already made, the exit ticket and the quiz — click or use the arrow keys.

✅ Quiz & class code

🗓️ Lesson at a glance

⏱️ 54 minutes

  1. 5 min Opener (pick one)
  2. 7 min Teach: reading a pond food web
  3. 6 min Model: what if the algae disappeared?
  4. 12 min Activity: the yarn web
  5. 8 min Predict: a pond without frogs
  6. 5 min Share the reasoning — if time
  7. 3 min Exit ticket
  8. 3 min Wrap-up
  9. 5 min Handing out, moving and cleaning up

Short on time? Skip the steps marked “if time” — the lesson still works.

Not in these 54 minutes: the worksheets (independent practice tomorrow, in centers or as homework) and the quiz (after the practice, or at the end of the week).

🧰 Materials

  • A pond food web on chart paper (or the board): algae, water plants, insects, snails, small fish, frogs, herons, snakes, bacteria
  • Organism cards on yarn necklaces or with tape — one card per student, several students per organism
  • A ball of yarn
  • A prediction sheet per student (or notebook paper)
  • Sticky notes

🔤 Key words

food web
A model of many connected food chains showing who eats whom.
ecosystem
All the living and nonliving things in an area and how they interact.
population
All the organisms of one kind living in one place, like all the frogs in a pond.
depend
To need something or someone to survive.
predict
To say what you think will happen, using evidence.
remove
To take away.

🎯 Success criteria — read them to the class

  • I can read a food web and tell who depends on whom.
  • I can predict what might happen to other organisms when one organism is removed.
  • I can explain my prediction using the arrows in the food web.

🎬 Open the lesson — pick one (5 min)

Get the class moving, curious and talking before the learning starts. Each one leads straight into today’s topic.

🤸 Brain break: Hold the web

  1. Stand up and hold hands (or hold the ends of a pencil) with the people next to you in your row.
  2. Everyone lean back very slightly — gently! Feel how you hold each other up.
  3. Now one person in each row lets go. Feel what changes for the people next to them.
  4. Stand straight again, let go and shake out your hands.
  5. Take one slow breath and sit down.

Say: “When one person let go, the people next to them felt it right away. Living things in an ecosystem are connected in the same way. Today we find out what happens when one part is taken away.”

🧩 Riddle

“I am made of many food chains tangled together. Pull one thread out of me, and many others feel the tug. What am I?”

Hint: Spiders make one kind of me, but mine is made of arrows that show who eats whom.

Answer

A food web! Today we pull one organism out of a pond food web and predict what happens.

🎁 Mystery object

Do: A pond food web drawn on chart paper, with one organism covered by a sticky note.

Say: “One animal is hidden under this sticky note. It eats insects, and herons and snakes eat it. It can live in water and on land. Who is it?”

Reveal: Lift the sticky note: frogs! Today we imagine this pond with no frogs at all. What would change?

🤔 Would you rather

“Would you rather be a heron that eats only frogs, or a heron that eats both frogs and fish?”

Do: Frogs-only fans stand on one foot like a heron; frogs-and-fish fans stand on two feet. Ask each side: what if the frogs disappeared?

Then: The heron that eats both has a backup food. Having more than one food source helps an animal when one part of the web changes. That is today’s big idea.

🧑‍🏫 Teach it step by step

  1. 1 Teach: reading a pond food web 7 min

    Do:
    • Show the board slide and the pond food web. Point to each arrow as you read it.
    Say:

    “This is a food web for a pond. Remember, the arrow points from the food to the eater, the way the energy and matter move.”

    “Producers: algae and water plants make food using sunlight. Insects and snails eat algae. Small fish eat insects. Frogs eat insects too. Herons eat fish and frogs. Snakes eat frogs and fish. Bacteria break down anything that dies.”

    “A food web is many food chains tangled together. That means organisms depend on each other. If one population gets bigger or smaller, the others can feel it.”

    “When scientists predict, they use evidence. Our evidence is the arrows. We will use words like “might” and “could,” because real ecosystems are complicated.”

    Ask: Which two animals eat frogs in this web?

    Look for: Herons and snakes.

    Ask: What do frogs eat?

    Look for: Insects.

  2. 2 Model: what if the algae disappeared? 6 min

    Do:
    • Show the board slide. Cover the algae on the chart with a sticky note. Think aloud and trace the arrows out of algae with your finger.
    Say:

    “Let’s practice. Imagine the algae disappeared. I follow the arrows that leave algae. They go to insects and snails. So insects and snails lose food. Their populations might shrink.”

    “Now I keep going. Fewer insects means less food for frogs and small fish. Their populations might shrink too.”

    “And then herons and snakes have less to eat. So one change at the bottom can travel all the way up the web.”

    “Notice my sentence: “If ___ is removed, then ___ might ___, because ___.” The “because” part always uses the arrows.”

    Ask: Why might the herons be affected, even though they don’t eat algae?

    Look for: They eat fish and frogs, which eat insects, which eat algae — the energy for herons starts with the algae.

  3. 3 Activity: the yarn web 12 min

    Do:
    • Give every student an organism card. Make several students each of algae, insects and small fish, and fewer frogs, herons and snakes. Stand in a large circle.
    • Start with an algae student holding the yarn end. Pass the ball from food to eater: algae to insect, insect to frog, frog to heron, and so on, until every student holds the yarn at least once. Everyone holds the yarn snugly.
    • Then say: “A disease wiped out the frogs in this pond.” All frog students drop their yarn.
    • Students raise a hand if they felt the yarn go slack. Ask them who they are and why they felt it.
    Say:

    “Pass the yarn from the food to the eater. Say the link out loud: “I am an insect, and the frog eats me.””

    “Hold the yarn snugly — not too tight.”

    “Something has happened. The frogs are gone. Frogs, let go of your yarn.”

    “Raise your hand if you felt the yarn get loose. Who are you? How are you connected to the frogs?”

    Ask: Herons, snakes: why did you feel the yarn go slack?

    Look for: Frogs were part of their food; now they have less to eat.

    Ask: Insects: what might happen to you without frogs?

    Look for: Fewer insects are eaten, so the insect population might grow.

  4. 4 Predict: a pond without frogs 8 min

    Do:
    • Students go back to their seats. On the prediction sheet they write three predictions using the frame — one for insects, one for herons, and one more of their choice.
    Say:

    “Write three predictions using our frame: If frogs are removed, then ___ might ___, because ___.”

    “One must be about the insects, one about the herons, and one about any other organism you choose.”

    “Your “because” must use the arrows in the food web.”

    Ask: Walk around and ask: “What might happen to the algae if there are more insects?”

    Look for: More insects might eat more algae, so the algae might decrease.

    Ask: What might the herons do with no frogs?

    Look for: Eat more fish (so the fish might decrease), or the heron population might shrink or move away.

  5. 5 Share the reasoningif time 5 min

    Do:
    • Three students read one prediction each. The class checks: does the “because” use an arrow?
    Say:

    “Listen for the “because.” Did the reason use the food web?”

    “Two people can make different predictions and both be reasonable. For herons, one person might say “they will eat more fish” and another might say “there will be fewer herons.” Both use evidence.”

    Ask: Why might two scientists make different predictions?

    Look for: Ecosystems are complicated; more than one thing can happen, and each prediction can be supported by evidence.

  6. 6 Exit ticket 3 min

    Do:
    • Students write on a sticky note and stick it on the pond food web.
    Say:

    “Write one effect of removing frogs from the pond. Use the frame and a “because.””

    ✅ Correct answer: Any effect supported by the web, e.g. “If frogs are removed, the insects might increase, because fewer of them are eaten,” or “herons might eat more fish (or decrease), because they lose one of their foods,” or “snakes might have less food.” A prediction with no “because,” or one that is not connected to frogs by an arrow, is the near-miss to reteach.

  7. ✓ Wrap-up 3 min

    Do:
    • Read the three “I can” statements. Students show 1, 2 or 3 fingers.
    • Collect the sticky notes and sort them into got it / almost / not yet.
    Say:

    “Tell your neighbor: why can removing one organism affect animals that never eat it?”

    “Next time we zoom out from one pond to the whole Earth and look at four big systems that work together.”

💡 Teacher tips

  • Make the organism cards before class: several algae, insects and small fish, and only one or two frogs, herons and snakes. That matches real ecosystems — more producers and small animals than top predators.
  • The yarn web works best in a cleared area or outside. Tell students to hold the yarn snugly, not tight, and never wrap it around fingers or wrists.
  • Push for the word “because.” A prediction without evidence from the web is a guess.
  • Accept different reasonable predictions. Real ecosystems are complicated; the goal is reasoning from the arrows, not one right answer.
  • If time is short, skip the sharing step and read three good predictions aloud at the start of the next lesson.

💬 Discussion questions

  1. Why can removing frogs affect herons and algae, even though herons and algae are not connected to each other directly?

    They are connected through other organisms: herons eat frogs, frogs eat insects, insects eat algae. A change travels along the arrows.

  2. Which animal in the pond would be hurt more by losing frogs — a heron or a snake? Why might it depend?

    Both lose a food. An animal that has other foods it can eat (like fish) has a backup, so it may be hurt less.

  3. What are some reasons a population might disappear from an ecosystem?

    Disease, pollution, a drought drying up the pond, or people changing the habitat.

⚠️ Common mistakes and how to fix them

❌ Thinking only the animal that eats frogs is affected.

✔️ Follow arrows in both directions: frogs eat insects too, so insects are affected.

❌ Writing a prediction with no reason.

✔️ Require the frame: “…because ___” using an arrow.

❌ Saying “all the herons will die” as if it is certain.

✔️ Teach “might” and “could.” Herons can eat fish too, so they may survive with less food.

❌ Reading arrows backward (thinking frog → heron means the frog eats the heron).

✔️ Repeat: the arrow points from the food to the eater.

🧩 For every learner

🤝 Extra support

  • Use a smaller web: algae → insects → frogs → herons.
  • Give two choices for each prediction: “more or fewer insects?”
  • Sentence frame with a word bank: increase, decrease, less food, more food.

🚀 Challenge

  • Predict what happens if the frogs come back after two years.
  • Remove the bacteria instead. What changes over many months?
  • Draw a web for a different ecosystem and remove one organism.

🌎 English learners

  • Use gestures for increase (hands moving apart) and decrease (hands moving together).
  • Word-wall cards with pictures: food web, population, remove.
  • Frame: “No frogs → ___ more / fewer, because ___.”

🏠 At home: Draw a food web with your family for a place you know (a backyard, a park, a pond). Then ask: “What might happen if one animal disappeared?” Write one prediction with “because.”

📊 After the exit ticket and quiz: what to do tomorrow

Sort the exit tickets (or open the quiz results — they group the class for you) and start tomorrow with 10 minutes in three groups.

✅ Got it

  • Start the next lesson (Four spheres).
  • Early finishers: the Challenge worksheet — build a forest web and remove one organism.

🟡 Almost

  • 5 minutes with the pond web chart: cover one organism with a sticky note and write one prediction with “because” with a partner.
  • Redo the “Find the mistake” part of the main worksheet.

🔁 Not yet

  • Small group with the teacher: use the 4-part chain algae → insects → frogs → herons. Remove frogs and ask “more or fewer?” for each, tracing the arrows with a finger.
  • Then the Easier worksheet (a pond without frogs) with the teacher nearby.

🤝 A pond without frogs

Same skill, smaller numbers and fill-in-the-blank steps — for students who need extra support. Everyone else starts on the main worksheet.

Name: ______________________   Date: ____________

Food web: algae → insects → frogs → herons. Word bank: more · fewer · less food

A. Fill in the blank.

  1. Frogs eat insects. If frogs are gone, there might be ________ insects.Answer: ________________________
  2. Herons eat frogs. If frogs are gone, herons have ________.Answer: ________________________
  3. Insects eat algae. If there are more insects, there might be ________ algae.Answer: ________________________

B. Circle.

  1. The arrow frogs → herons means herons eat frogs / frogs eat herons.Answer: ________________________
  2. Removing frogs affects only frogs / many organisms.Answer: ________________________
🔑 Answers
  1. more
  2. less food
  3. fewer (less)
  4. herons eat frogs
  5. many organisms

📝 When one part changes

Name: ______________________   Date: ____________

Pond web: algae → insects, algae → snails, insects → small fish, insects → frogs, small fish → herons, frogs → herons, frogs → snakes, small fish → snakes.

A. Read the web.

  1. What do frogs eat?Answer: ________________________
  2. Which animals eat frogs?Answer: ________________________
  3. Which organism is the producer in this web?Answer: ________________________

B. Predict. Use “might … because …”.

  1. If frogs are removed, what might happen to the insects?Answer: ________________________
  2. If frogs are removed, what might happen to the herons?Answer: ________________________
  3. If the insects increase, what might happen to the algae?Answer: ________________________

C. Find the mistake.

  1. Jake says, “Removing frogs only changes things for the frogs.” What is wrong?Answer: ________________________
  2. Ava says, “Snails eat frogs, so without frogs the snails will go hungry.” What is wrong? Use the web.Answer: ________________________
🔑 Answers
  1. Insects
  2. Herons and snakes
  3. Algae
  4. They might increase, because fewer insects are eaten.
  5. They might eat more small fish, or their population might decrease, because they lose one of their foods.
  6. It might decrease, because more insects eat more algae.
  7. Frogs are connected to insects, herons and snakes, so all of them can be affected.
  8. Snails do not eat frogs; the arrow goes algae → snails, so snails eat algae.

🚀 Challenge: ecosystem ripple

Name: ______________________   Date: ____________

A. Think and explain.

  1. Trace a ripple: frogs are removed. Explain how this could change the algae, step by step.Answer: ________________________
  2. A heron eats frogs and small fish. A different bird eats only frogs. Which bird is more at risk if frogs disappear? Why?Answer: ________________________
  3. What might happen to this pond if the bacteria (decomposers) disappeared?Answer: ________________________

B. Create.

  1. Draw a food web for a forest or a field with at least 6 organisms. Remove one organism and write two predictions with “because.”
🔑 Answers
  1. Fewer frogs → fewer insects eaten → more insects → more algae eaten → less algae.
  2. The bird that eats only frogs, because it loses all of its food; the heron still has fish.
  3. Dead plants and animals would pile up, and matter would not be returned to the water and mud for producers to use.
  4. Any correct web (arrows from food to eater) and two predictions supported by its arrows, e.g. remove hawks → mice might increase → seeds might decrease.

✅ Quiz

12 questions. Show them on the board and answer together, or give each student the quiz on their own device and see everyone’s score.

Students scan the QR code or type the short code, write their name and answer. You get a table with every student’s score and the questions most of the class missed.

1. Frogs eat insects. If all the frogs are removed, the insects might…

2. Herons eat frogs and fish. With no frogs, herons might…

3. If all the algae disappeared, who would lose food first?

4. Sam says, “Removing frogs only affects frogs.” What is wrong?

5. In the web, frogs → snakes means…

6. In a field, hawks eat mice and mice eat seeds. If the hawks are removed, the mice might…

7. Then, with more mice, the seeds might…

8. Which change would NOT be caused by removing frogs?

9. Why do scientists say “might” in these predictions?

10. Which prediction uses evidence from the web?

11. What is a food web?

12. Which animal would be hurt MOST if frogs disappeared?

12 questions

🖨️ Classroom aids to print

Word-wall cards for this lesson’s key words. They print on their own pages.

food webA model of many connected food chains showing who eats whom.
ecosystemAll the living and nonliving things in an area and how they interact.
populationAll the organisms of one kind living in one place, like all the frogs in a pond.
dependTo need something or someone to survive.
predictTo say what you think will happen, using evidence.
removeTo take away.

Where this lesson fits

  • Before this lesson: Building a food chain — Students trace the energy in an animal’s food back to the sun.
  • This lesson: Students predict what happens to an ecosystem when one organism is removed.
  • Coming next: Four spheres — Students model how Earth’s spheres interact.

📐 Standard

5-LS2-1

Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS), Grade 5 — typical US unit order

🏁 Unit goals

  • Explain plants get matter from air and water
  • Model energy from the sun through food webs
  • Model matter cycling among organisms

🌟 Thinkabara Pro

Need this lesson made for your class?

The booklet on this page is free. With Pro you get versions of it: three levels for mixed classes, in Spanish, or adapted for IEP and ELL students — plus a new booklet on any topic you teach that is not in our library.

Make a version for my class — free trial → See a real sample

7 days free, no credit card.

Practice & resources on Thinkabara

🗓️ Plan the whole year like this

Add 5th Grade Science to your free Lesson Planner: enter your class schedule once and every period shows the next lesson, skipping weekends and school breaks.

Add to my planner See the year’s sequence

More lessons in “Matter & energy in ecosystems”

  1. Plants get matter from air and water — Students support the argument that plants get materials mainly from air and water.
  2. Energy from the sun — Students model how energy in food was once energy from the sun.
  3. Food webs — Students model food webs with producers, consumers and decomposers.
  4. Decomposers — Students observe decomposition and explain matter cycling.
  5. Producers, consumers and decomposers — Students sort organisms by how they get matter and energy.
  6. Building a food chain — Students trace the energy in an animal’s food back to the sun.
  7. When one part changes — Students predict what happens to an ecosystem when one organism is removed.

Something to improve in this lesson? Tell us.