In 1963, a teenager named Erasto Mpemba was making ice cream in a cooking class at his school in what is now Tanzania. The students were supposed to boil milk with sugar, let it cool and then put it in the freezer. Space in the freezer was limited, and Mpemba was worried that another student would take the last spot. So instead of waiting for his mixture to cool, he put it in the freezer while it was still hot. To his surprise, his ice cream froze before the ice cream of students who had cooled theirs first.
When Mpemba later asked his teacher about it, the teacher told him he must be confused. Other students laughed at him. But Mpemba did not give up. A few years later, a physics professor named Denis Osborne visited his school, and Mpemba asked him the same question: why would hot water freeze faster than cold water?
Osborne did not laugh. Instead, he tested the idea in his laboratory, and in some trials the warmer water did freeze first. In 1969, Mpemba and Osborne published a paper together describing their results. Since then, the strange idea has been called the Mpemba effect.
Mpemba was not actually the first person to notice it. More than two thousand years earlier, the Greek philosopher Aristotle wrote that warm water seems to freeze more quickly. Centuries later, the thinkers Francis Bacon and René Descartes also mentioned it. Still, it was a student's simple question that pushed modern scientists to investigate.
If the effect is real, what could cause it? Scientists have suggested several explanations. Hot water evaporates faster, so there may be less water left to freeze. Hot water also contains fewer dissolved gases, which might change how it freezes. Another idea involves how heat moves through the water as it cools, with warmer water losing heat faster at the start.
However, not everyone is convinced. Freezing water is a surprisingly messy experiment. Small changes, such as the shape of the container, where a thermometer is placed or how "frozen" is defined, can change the result. In 2016, two researchers carefully repeated the experiment many times and found no clear evidence that hot water freezes faster. Other scientists have reported results that seem to support the effect.
So, can hot water freeze faster than cold? The honest answer is: sometimes, maybe, and it depends. What is clear is the lesson from Mpemba's story. A good question deserves to be tested, even when it comes from a student and even when others laugh.