In 1939, many American families faced an unusual question: which Thursday is Thanksgiving? For the next three years, the answer depended on where you lived.
Ever since Abraham Lincoln's proclamation in 1863, presidents had named the last Thursday of November as Thanksgiving Day. Usually that worked well. In 1939, however, November had five Thursdays, so the last one fell on November 30, the very last day of the month.
The country was still recovering from the Great Depression, a long period when millions of people lost their jobs and many businesses struggled. In those days, most people waited until after Thanksgiving to begin their holiday shopping. Store owners worried that a late Thanksgiving would leave too few shopping days before Christmas. President Franklin D. Roosevelt agreed that a shorter shopping season could hurt the economy, so he moved Thanksgiving one week earlier, to November 23.
The decision caused an uproar. Calendars had already been printed with the old date. Schools had planned their vacations, and football teams had scheduled their traditional Thanksgiving games. Critics complained that the President was changing a cherished tradition just to help stores sell more. Some people mockingly called the new holiday "Franksgiving."
The president's proclamation set the date for federal workers, but each state's governor decided the date for his own state. In the end, 32 states followed Roosevelt's change, while 16 kept the last Thursday. For a few years, some families celebrated a week earlier than their relatives in a neighboring state.
Finally, Congress settled the question. On December 26, 1941, Roosevelt signed a law making Thanksgiving the fourth Thursday of November. Choosing the "fourth" Thursday rather than the "last" one was a clever compromise. In most years, the fourth Thursday is also the last one, so the old tradition was mostly kept. But in a year with five Thursdays, the holiday comes a week before the end of the month, leaving more time for holiday shopping. That is why Thanksgiving always falls between November 22 and November 28.