On some winter days near the Great Lakes, one town is buried under two feet of snow while another, only ten miles away, sees the sun. Drivers can pass from bright sky into a blinding whiteout in a few minutes. This is lake-effect snow, and it is one of the most dramatic kinds of winter weather in the United States.
Lake-effect snow begins with a contrast. Water heats up and cools down much more slowly than land or air. All summer, the Great Lakes soak up the Sun's energy, and they hold on to that warmth well into late fall and early winter. Then, behind a cold front, frigid air from Canada sweeps south and east across the lakes.
When that cold, dry air passes over the relatively warm water, two things happen. The bottom layer of air is warmed, so it becomes lighter and rises. At the same time, water evaporates from the lake into the air. As the warm, moist air rises into the colder air above, its water vapor condenses into clouds, and the clouds grow tall enough to produce snow. Meteorologists generally look for the lake surface to be at least about 13 degrees Celsius (about 23 degrees Fahrenheit) warmer than the air about a mile overhead.
Distance across the water matters too. Meteorologists call the stretch of open water that the wind crosses the fetch. The longer the fetch, the more heat and moisture the air can gather, and the stronger the snow becomes. That is why the heaviest snow falls when the wind blows along the length of a lake rather than straight across its narrow side.
When the clouds reach land, friction with the ground slows the air, and hills can push it upward, squeezing out even more snow. In winter the wind often blows from the west or northwest, so the snowiest places, called snowbelts, usually lie on the eastern and southern shores of the lakes. In western New York, the city of Buffalo sits at the eastern end of Lake Erie, and the Tug Hill Plateau east of Lake Ontario is one of the snowiest places east of the Rocky Mountains.
Because lake-effect snow falls in narrow bands, a band that stalls in one place can be extreme. In November 2014, steady winds held a band over the area just south of Buffalo for many hours, and some towns reported more than six feet of snow while parts of the city a few miles north received very little.
The snow machine has an off switch. As winter goes on, the lakes lose their heat, and when much of a lake's surface freezes, it can no longer supply much warmth or moisture. Lake Erie, the shallowest of the Great Lakes, freezes most often, so lake-effect snow downwind of it usually fades in the depths of winter, while the deeper lakes may keep the machine running much longer.