In December 1914, World War I was only a few months old. On the Western Front, which stretched across Belgium and France, millions of soldiers faced each other from long lines of muddy trenches. The strip of ground between the enemy lines was called no man's land, because anyone who stepped into it risked being shot. Many soldiers had been told the war would be over by Christmas. Instead, it had settled into a cold, wet standstill.
Then, on Christmas Eve, something unexpected happened. In a number of places, German soldiers set small Christmas trees with candles along the tops of their trenches. Across the way, British soldiers heard them singing carols, including "Stille Nacht," the German original of "Silent Night." The British answered with carols of their own. Voices called out across the dark: no shooting tomorrow?
On Christmas morning, along many stretches of the front, men climbed out of their trenches and walked into no man's land without their rifles. Soldiers who had been trying to kill each other the day before shook hands. They traded what they had: chocolate, plum pudding, sausages, buttons and badges from their uniforms. They showed each other photographs of their families. In some places, both sides used the quiet to bury soldiers who had died in earlier fighting, sometimes holding services together.
The most famous part of the story is football, or soccer. Letters written by soldiers describe kickabouts with a ball, or even a tin can, on Christmas Day. Historians agree that some games took place, but they were probably small and informal, and fewer than the popular legend suggests. Accurate history means separating what the evidence shows from what we wish had happened.
The truce was never official. No government or general ordered it; it grew from the bottom up, among ordinary soldiers. It was also not everywhere. In some sectors the fighting went on, and in others the peace lasted only a few hours. Elsewhere it stretched for days. Commanders on both sides were worried. If enemies got to know each other as people, would they still fight? Orders soon went out forbidding friendly contact with the enemy, and the war went on for nearly four more years.
We know about the truce largely because the soldiers wrote home about it, and in Britain many of these letters were printed in newspapers. The next Christmas, after another year of terrible losses and with strict orders in place, nothing like it happened on the same scale again.
Why does the Christmas truce still move people more than a century later? Perhaps because it shows that even in one of the worst wars in history, the people doing the fighting never completely forgot that the men across no man's land were human beings, too.