By December, most maples and oaks across the northern United States stand bare. Yet the firs, spruces and pines that people bring home as Christmas trees are still green. How do these trees keep their needles through months of freezing weather, when so many other trees give up their leaves?
To understand the answer, it helps to know why most broadleaf trees drop their leaves in the first place. A leaf is a little factory. Using sunlight, water and carbon dioxide, it makes sugar through photosynthesis. But a broad, thin leaf also loses a lot of water through tiny openings in its surface. In winter, the ground may freeze, and roots cannot pull up much water. A tree full of broad leaves could dry out, and the leaves could be damaged by ice. So before winter, most broadleaf trees pull useful nutrients back from their leaves and let them fall.
Conifers, the cone-bearing trees, solve the same problem in a different way. Their needles are narrow and thick, so they have much less surface area than a broad leaf. Less surface means less water escapes. Each needle is also covered by a tough, waxy coating that seals moisture inside. The tiny openings that let gases in and out are few and often sunken into the needle, which further protects them from drying winds.
Conifers also have their own kind of antifreeze. As cold weather arrives, water moves out of the needle cells into the spaces between them, and sugars build up inside the cells. Like salt on an icy road, dissolved sugar lowers the temperature at which water freezes. This helps keep sharp ice crystals from forming inside the cells and tearing them apart.
Because the needles stay on, a conifer keeps its chlorophyll, the green pigment that captures sunlight. On mild winter days, many conifers can carry out some photosynthesis, and when spring returns, they can start making food right away instead of first growing a whole new set of leaves. That is a real advantage in places with short growing seasons, such as high mountains and the far north.
Even an evergreen does not keep each needle forever. Needles usually last several years and then drop, a few at a time, while new ones grow. And there is at least one surprise: the tamarack, or larch, is a conifer whose needles turn gold and fall every autumn, just like a maple's leaves.
The Christmas tree in your living room carries these winter survival tools with it. Once a tree is cut, though, it can no longer pull water from the ground, so experts recommend keeping the stand filled with water. A fresh tree can drink a surprising amount, especially in its first days indoors, and a well-watered tree keeps its needles longer and is less likely to dry out.