Each January, people promise themselves they will finally practice the guitar, read more books or keep their rooms clean. By February, many of those promises have quietly disappeared. Why is it so hard to turn a fresh start into a lasting change? History and psychology both offer clues.
Making promises at the start of a year is a very old idea. Historians describe how the ancient Babylonians, about 4,000 years ago, held a great festival for their new year, which began in spring at planting time. During the festival, people made promises to their gods to pay their debts and return things they had borrowed. Today's resolutions are usually promises to ourselves, but the hope behind them is the same: that a new beginning can make us better.
Many people believe a popular rule of thumb: it takes 21 days to form a habit. The number seems to trace back to a 1960 book by Maxwell Maltz, a plastic surgeon. He noticed that his patients usually needed "a minimum of about 21 days" to get used to a change, such as a new face in the mirror. Over the years, "a minimum of about 21 days" was retold as simply "21 days," and a careful observation turned into a myth.
In 2009, researchers led by Phillippa Lally at University College London tested the question directly. Nearly 100 volunteers each chose one new daily behavior, such as eating a piece of fruit with lunch or running for 15 minutes before dinner. Every day for 12 weeks, they reported how automatic the behavior felt, meaning how much they did it without having to think about it. On average, it took 66 days for the behavior to reach its most automatic level. But the range was enormous: from 18 days for some people to an estimated 254 days for others. Simple behaviors, like drinking water with lunch, tended to become automatic faster than harder ones, like exercise.
The study had a hopeful finding, too. Missing a single day did not seriously set people back. In other words, one slip does not erase weeks of progress, so there is no reason to quit after a bad day.
Other research suggests that how a goal is worded matters. Psychologist Peter Gollwitzer and other researchers have found that people are more likely to follow through when they make specific "if-then" plans, such as "When I get home from school, I will practice guitar for ten minutes," instead of a vague wish like "I will practice more." A clear cue tied to an existing routine gives the brain a signal to act.
So the problem with many resolutions may not be weak willpower. It may be that people expect change in three weeks, aim at something huge and give up after one missed day. A small, specific plan repeated for a couple of months, with room for mistakes, is a better bet than a grand promise made at midnight.