🥚 Egg Drop Challenge: Which Cushion Works Best?

Package raw eggs in boxes filled with different cushioning — cotton balls, bubble wrap, popcorn, crumpled paper — and drop them from the same height. You turn the classic challenge into a fair test.

Free · US Letter · no sign-up
Google Classroom Save to Pinterest Email me
🎒 5th grade🎒 6th grade🛠️ Engineering📶 Easy⏱️ 1 week💲 Under $10🧑‍🔬 Grown-up helps

Question: Which cushioning material best protects an egg dropped from 10 feet?

Hypothesis: If the egg is surrounded by bubble wrap, then it will survive most often, because the air bubbles squeeze and stretch out the time of the impact.

Variables

  • Independent variable (what you change): Cushioning material
  • Dependent variable (what you measure): Eggs surviving out of 3 (and crack score 0–3)
  • Controlled variables (keep the same): Same box size; Same amount of material (fill the box); Same drop height: 10 feet (3 m); Same landing surface; Same egg size

Materials

  • 15 raw large eggs
  • 15 identical small boxes (tissue or shoe boxes)
  • Cotton balls, bubble wrap, plain popcorn, crumpled newspaper
  • Tape
  • Tape measure
  • Plastic sandwich bags
  • A safe drop spot (porch or step stool) with adult help
  • Tarp for cleanup

Procedure — step by step

  1. Put each egg in a sandwich bag to catch any mess.
  2. Fill boxes with one cushioning material each, with the egg in the center; make 3 boxes per material and 3 with no cushion (control).
  3. Tape every box shut the same way.
  4. With an adult, drop each box from exactly 10 feet onto the tarp, letting go without throwing.
  5. Open the box and score the egg: 0 = no crack, 1 = hairline crack, 2 = cracked shell, 3 = broken.
  6. Repeat for all boxes.
  7. Count survivors and average the crack scores.

⚠️ Safety: An adult should supervise drops from a height; wash hands after handling raw eggs.

Data table

Egg drop results
MaterialEgg 1 scoreEgg 2 scoreEgg 3 scoreSurvived (of 3)
No cushion (control)    
Cotton balls    
Bubble wrap    
Popcorn    
Crumpled paper    

Graph it as a bar graph: put “Material” on the x-axis and your measurement on the y-axis.

Printable project sheets

A plan with every step, and a data sheet with a graph grid and conclusion lines.

Project plan

🥚 Egg Drop Challenge: Which Cushion Works Best?

Name:Due:

Question: Which cushioning material best protects an egg dropped from 10 feet?

My hypothesis: If the egg is surrounded by bubble wrap, then it will survive most often, because the air bubbles squeeze and stretch out the time of the impact.

Change: Cushioning material · Measure: Eggs surviving out of 3 (and crack score 0–3) · Keep the same: Same box size; Same amount of material (fill the box); Same drop height: 10 feet (3 m); Same landing surface; Same egg size

Materials

  • 15 raw large eggs
  • 15 identical small boxes (tissue or shoe boxes)
  • Cotton balls, bubble wrap, plain popcorn, crumpled newspaper
  • Tape
  • Tape measure
  • Plastic sandwich bags
  • A safe drop spot (porch or step stool) with adult help
  • Tarp for cleanup

Steps (check them off)

  1. ☐ Put each egg in a sandwich bag to catch any mess.
  2. ☐ Fill boxes with one cushioning material each, with the egg in the center; make 3 boxes per material and 3 with no cushion (control).
  3. ☐ Tape every box shut the same way.
  4. ☐ With an adult, drop each box from exactly 10 feet onto the tarp, letting go without throwing.
  5. ☐ Open the box and score the egg: 0 = no crack, 1 = hairline crack, 2 = cracked shell, 3 = broken.
  6. ☐ Repeat for all boxes.
  7. ☐ Count survivors and average the crack scores.

Safety: An adult should supervise drops from a height; wash hands after handling raw eggs.

thinkabara.com/science/science-fair-projects/egg-drop-design-test

Data sheet + graph

Data: Egg drop results

MaterialEgg 1 scoreEgg 2 scoreEgg 3 scoreSurvived (of 3)
No cushion (control)
Cotton balls
Bubble wrap
Popcorn
Crumpled paper

My bar graph (x: Material)

Conclusion: Was my hypothesis supported? What did I learn?

thinkabara.com/science/science-fair-projects/egg-drop-design-test

What usually happens

The control eggs almost always break. Bubble wrap and crumpled paper often protect well when the box is packed tightly; loose filling lets the egg move and hit the box wall.

The science behind it

A falling egg gains momentum. Stopping it suddenly takes a large force, which cracks the shell. Cushioning increases the time it takes the egg to stop, and a longer stopping time means a smaller force (the impulse–momentum idea, F × t = change in momentum). Car air bags and bike helmets use the same principle.

Take it further

  • Raise the drop height until even the best cushion fails.
  • Add a parachute and compare.
  • Test the same mass of each material to make it even fairer.

Putting it on your board

Left panel: question, hypothesis and variables. Center: your title, graph and photos of the setup. Right panel: procedure summary, results and conclusion. See the scientific method guide for a printable board layout and judging checklist, or browse more 5th grade projects.

Frequently asked questions

Is “Egg Drop Challenge: Which Cushion Works Best” a good science fair project for grades 5–6?

Yes. It is rated easy, takes 1 week, costs under about $10 and has a real measurable result, which is what judges look for. A grown-up should help with some steps.

What is the independent variable in this project?

Cushioning material. The dependent variable (what you measure) is: eggs surviving out of 3 (and crack score 0–3).

What results should I expect?

The control eggs almost always break. Bubble wrap and crumpled paper often protect well when the box is packed tightly; loose filling lets the egg move and hit the box wall.

How many trials should I do?

At least three for every condition, then average them. More trials make your conclusion stronger, and if one trial is very different, you can explain why (and maybe redo it).

More free printables from Thinkabara