📑 Appeal
5th Grade 🏛️ Civics & Government
An appeal is a request to a higher court to review the decision of a lower court, because someone believes the lower court made a mistake.
Judges are human and can make mistakes. An appeal gives a second chance: the side that lost a case can ask a higher court to check whether the law was applied correctly and the trial was fair. An appeals court usually doesn’t hold a new trial with new witnesses. Instead, a panel of judges reads the record of the trial, reads written arguments called briefs, and often listens to lawyers argue. Then it can agree with the decision, change it, or send the case back for a new trial.
In the federal system there are three levels: district courts (where trials happen), the US Courts of Appeals (13 “circuits”), and the Supreme Court at the top. States have a similar ladder of trial courts, appeals courts and a state supreme court. A person who loses in an appeals court can ask the US Supreme Court to hear the case, but the Court gets thousands of requests a year and agrees to hear fewer than 100 — usually cases about important questions of federal law or the Constitution.
In a criminal case, a person found guilty can appeal. But if a defendant is found not guilty by a jury, the government generally can’t appeal and try them again for the same crime — the Fifth Amendment’s protection against “double jeopardy.”
For example
- A person convicted in a trial court believes the judge wrongly allowed some evidence, so they appeal.
- A company that lost a lawsuit asks the US Court of Appeals to review the district court’s ruling.
- A case about free speech at school climbs from a district court to a court of appeals and finally to the Supreme Court.
- Noah thinks the referee missed a call, so the coach asks the league to review the video — a little like an appeal.
📌 Remember: Appeal = asking a higher court to check a lower court’s decision.
Quick quiz
What is an appeal?
What does an appeals court usually do?
Which court is at the top of the US court system?