⚖️ How Courts Work: From Trial Courts to the Supreme Court

6th Grade 🏛️ Civics & Government

Courts are the judicial branch: they settle disputes between people, decide the cases of people accused of crimes, and make sure the government itself follows the law and the Constitution. The United States has two court systems — federal and state — with the Supreme Court at the very top.

Free · US Letter · no sign-up
Google Classroom Save to Pinterest Email me

Two court systems

The United States has two court systems side by side. State courts handle the vast majority of cases — most crimes, traffic tickets, family matters, arguments over contracts and accidents. Each state organizes its own courts, and many have special courts too, like small claims court for minor money disputes, family court and juvenile court for cases involving kids.

Federal courts handle cases about the US Constitution and federal laws, cases where the US government is a party, and some disputes between people from different states. They are much fewer, but their decisions can affect the whole country.

Three levels, like a pyramid

Both systems are built like a pyramid. At the bottom are trial courts, where cases start. In the federal system they are called district courts, and there are 94 of them across the country. Here witnesses testify, evidence is shown, and a judge or jury decides what happened.

In the middle are the appeals courts. The federal system has 13 courts of appeals, also called circuit courts. At the top is the Supreme Court of the United States in Washington, D.C. Each state also has its own highest court, usually called the state supreme court.

What is an appeal?

Judges are human and can make mistakes. So a person who believes the decision in their case was wrong can usually appeal — ask a higher court to review it. An appeals court doesn’t hold a new trial with new witnesses. Instead, a panel of judges reads the record of the trial, listens to the lawyers’ arguments and decides whether the law was applied correctly.

The Supreme Court is the final word. There is nowhere to appeal after it decides, and all other courts must follow its rulings. That’s why one Supreme Court decision can change how a law is understood across the whole country.

The Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has nine justices: one Chief Justice and eight Associate Justices. The President nominates them, the Senate must confirm them, and they serve “during good behavior” — which in practice means for life, unless they retire, resign or are impeached and removed. Life terms are meant to let justices decide cases without worrying about losing their jobs.

Thousands of people ask the Supreme Court to hear their cases every year, but it agrees to decide only a small number — usually fewer than 100. It picks cases that raise important questions about the Constitution or federal law. Decisions are made by majority vote, and the justices write opinions explaining their reasons. The Court can also rule that a law or a government action is unconstitutional — the power called judicial review.

Independent judges and fair trials

For judges to decide cases without fear or favoritism, they have to be independent. A judge doesn’t take orders from the President or from members of Congress about how to rule; a judge follows the law. Federal judges have life terms, and their pay can’t be cut while they serve. In many states, judges are elected by voters or appointed and then face retention elections.

In a trial, each side gets to present its arguments and its evidence. A person accused of a crime is presumed innocent until proven guilty, and the government must prove guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt.” The Sixth Amendment gives every person accused of a crime the right to a lawyer — and if they can’t afford one, the government must provide one.

What happens at a trial

In the courtroom sits a judge, and in front of the judge are the two sides and their lawyers. In a criminal case, where someone is accused of a crime, the government brings the case, and a lawyer called a prosecutor speaks for it. In a civil case — for example, an argument between neighbors or between a customer and a store — two people or companies face each other.

Many trials in the United States have a jury: a group of ordinary citizens, often 12 people, who listen to the evidence and decide the facts — for example, whether the accused person is guilty. The Constitution guarantees the right to a jury trial in serious criminal cases (Sixth Amendment) and in many civil cases (Seventh Amendment). The judge runs the trial, explains the law to the jury and, if someone is found guilty, usually decides the sentence. Most trials are open to the public, so anyone can see that justice is done fairly.

Key facts

  • The US has two court systems: state courts, which handle most cases, and federal courts.
  • The levels are trial courts, appeals courts and a supreme court at the top.
  • The Supreme Court has nine justices, who are nominated by the President, confirmed by the Senate and serve for life.
  • An appeal asks a higher court to review a decision.
  • A person accused of a crime is presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and has the right to a jury trial.

Quick quiz

  1. How many justices sit on the US Supreme Court?

  2. Which courts handle most cases in the United States?

  3. What is an appeal?

  4. Who must confirm a Supreme Court justice after the President nominates one?

  5. What does a jury do?

  6. What are the federal trial courts called?

  7. What does “presumed innocent until proven guilty” mean?

  8. Why do federal judges serve for life?

💭 Think and talk about it

  1. Why do you think it matters that people can appeal a court decision?
  2. What could happen if judges were afraid to rule against powerful people?
  3. Why should even someone accused of a serious crime get a fair trial and a lawyer?

Questions kids ask

What is the difference between state and federal courts?

State courts handle cases about state laws, which includes most crimes, traffic cases and family matters. Federal courts handle cases about the US Constitution and federal laws, and cases involving the US government.

Why does the Supreme Court have nine justices?

The Constitution doesn’t set a number — Congress does. The number changed several times in the early years, and it has been nine since 1869.

Can kids go to court?

Yes. Juvenile courts handle cases involving young people, and sometimes kids testify as witnesses or share their views in family court, with adults there to support and protect them.

🔎 Ask Thinkapedia another question