Which solution works better?
๐ฏ Objective: Students test two ways to solve a problem and say which worked better and why.
๐ฆซ Thinkabara ยท Lesson booklet
Which solution works better?
Kindergarten ยท Science ยท K-2-ETS1-3
๐ฏ Students test two ways to solve a problem and say which worked better and why.
- Teacherโs lesson plan
- Easier worksheet
- Student worksheet
- Challenge page
- Quiz
- Answer key
Teacher: ______________________ Class: ____________
๐ This lesson comes as a booklet: teacherโs plan, student worksheet, challenge page, quiz and answer key โ all in one printable booklet. Teach from this page, print it all, or give the quiz to the class online.
Full-screen slides for the projector: goals, opener, every drawing already made, the exit ticket and the quiz โ click or use the arrow keys.
๐๏ธ Lesson at a glance
โฑ๏ธ 44 minutes
- 5 min Opener (pick one)
- 4 min Teach: a problem and two solutions
- 5 min Plan a fair test
- 11 min Test both solutions
- 6 min Share data: which worked better?
- 3 min Exit ticket: which worked better?
- 4 min Wrap-up
- 6 min Handing out, moving and cleaning up
Not in these 44 minutes: the worksheets (independent practice tomorrow, in centers or as homework) and the quiz (after the practice, or at the end of the week).
๐งฐ Materials
- Half sheets of paper โ 2 per pair (all the same size)
- Smooth rocks about the size of a childโs palm โ 1 per pair
- Paper clips โ 1 per pair
- File folders or stiff cardboard to fan with โ 1 per pair
- A simple chart for each pair: rock / paper clip, with 3 boxes each for โ (stayed) or โ (blew away)
- Optional: a small desk fan run only by the teacher
๐ค Key words
- problem
- Something that is not working that we want to fix.
- solution
- A way to fix a problem.
- test
- To try something to see what happens.
- predict
- To say what you think will happen before you test.
- better
- Works more times or works more strongly.
- fair
- The same for both, so the test is even.
๐ฏ Success criteria โ read them to the class
- I can test two ways to solve a problem.
- I can watch what happens and keep track.
- I can say which way worked better and tell why.
๐ฌ Open the lesson โ pick one (5 min)
Get the class moving, curious and talking before the learning starts. Each one leads straight into todayโs topic.
๐คธ Brain break: Windy day
- Stand up tall like a tree.
- The wind blows softly. Sway your arms gently left and right.
- The wind blows harder. Sway a little more โ keep your feet still!
- Pretend you hold a paper. Whoosh! Reach to catch it as it flies away.
- Hold your pretend paper down flat on your pretend desk with both hands.
- The wind stops. Sit down slowly.
Say: โOh no โ the wind wanted to take our paper! That is a problem. Today we test two ways to keep a paper from blowing away.โ
๐งฉ Riddle
โYou cannot see me, but you can feel me on your face. I can make leaves dance and papers fly away. What am I?โ
Hint: I am moving air.
Answer
The wind! Wind can blow papers away. Today we solve that problem.
๐ Mystery object
Do: A paper bag with a rock and a paper clip inside.
Say: โIn my bag are two things. Each one might help us solve a problem. One is small, gray and heavy. One is small, shiny and bendy.โ
Reveal: Take out the rock and the paper clip. Say: โOur problem: keep a paper from blowing away. Will the rock work better or the paper clip? Scientists donโt just guess. They test!โ
๐ค Would you rather
โWould you rather hold your paper down with a rock or with a paper clip?โ
Do: Rock fans make a fist. Paper clip fans make a tiny pinch with their fingers. Count each side and write the numbers on the board.
Then: Those are our predictions. Now letโs test both and see which one really works better.
๐งโ๐ซ Teach it step by step
1 Teach: a problem and two solutions 4 min
Do:- Put a paper on a table and fan it with a folder. Let it blow away. Show the board slide.
Say:โWatch. When I fan, the paper blows away. That is a problem. A problem is something we want to fix.โ
โA way to fix a problem is called a solution. We have two solutions: a rock and a paper clip.โ
โScientists and engineers test solutions. Then they look at what happened and pick the one that works better.โ
Ask: What is our problem?
Look for: The paper blows away when the wind blows (when we fan it).
2 Plan a fair test 5 min
Do:- Model one try with each solution. Put the rock in the middle of one paper. Clip the paper clip on the edge of the other paper. Fan each one 3 times the same way.
- Show how to mark the chart: โ if the paper stayed, โ if it blew away.
Say:โTo be fair, everything is the same except the solution. Same paper. Same folder. Same fanning: 3 big fans, the same way, from the same spot.โ
โIf I fan the rock paper softly and the paper clip paper really hard, is that fair? No! Same fanning for both.โ
โAfter each try, mark your chart. Check mark: the paper stayed. X: the paper blew away.โ
Ask: What must be the same for both papers?
Look for: The paper, the folder, and how we fan (3 fans, the same way).
3 Test both solutions 11 min
Do:- Pairs work on the floor or at tables with space. One partner fans, one partner watches and marks. They test each solution 3 times, then switch jobs.
- Walk around. Check that fanning is the same and that marks are made after every try.
Say:โFanner: fan 3 times, the same way each time. Watcher: did the paper stay or blow away? Make your mark.โ
โTest the rock 3 times. Test the paper clip 3 times.โ
โFan only the paper โ never fan your partnerโs face.โ
Ask: What happened with the rock?
Look for: The paper stayed under the rock (mostly โ).
Ask: What happened with the paper clip?
Look for: The paper still blew away or slid (mostly โ) โ the clip is too light to hold it down.
4 Share data: which worked better? 6 min
Do:- Make a class chart on the board. Each pair tells how many โ for the rock and how many โ for the paper clip. Make tally marks.
Say:โLetโs look at our data. Data is what we saw and marked.โ
โThe rock has many check marks. The paper clip has only a few. More check marks means it worked more times.โ
โSo the rock worked better. Why? The rock is heavier. It pushes down on the paper, so the wind could not lift it.โ
Ask: How do we know the rock worked better?
Look for: It got more check marks โ the paper stayed more times.
Ask: Why did the rock work better?
Look for: It is heavier, so it held the paper down.
5 Exit ticket: which worked better? 3 min
Do:- Each child points to the rock or the paper clip and finishes the frame out loud as they line up.
Say:โWhich worked better? Point to it. Then finish: โThe ___ worked better because ___.โโ
โ Correct answer: โThe rock worked better because it is heavier and held the paper down / the paper stayed.โ If a pairโs data showed something different, accept an answer that matches their own chart and ask what they saw. If a child says โbecause I like it,โ ask: โWhat did your chart show?โ
โ Wrap-up 4 min
Do:- Read the three โI canโ statements. Students show thumbs up, sideways or down.
- Collect rocks, clips and folders in bins.
Say:โTell your neighbor: was your prediction right? It is okay if it was not โ scientists learn from tests!โ
โWhat else could hold a paper down? Maybe we can test it next time.โ
๐ก Teacher tips
- Choose rocks that are smooth and heavy enough to hold a half sheet; test one before class.
- Model the exact fan move (3 big fans from the same spot) โ fair fanning is the key idea.
- Give pairs floor space so papers do not blow into the next group.
- If you use a desk fan, only the teacher turns it on and children keep fingers away.
- Keep the chart very simple: 3 boxes per solution, โ or โ.
๐ฌ Discussion questions
- Why did we test each solution 3 times?
To be sure โ one try could be a fluke.
- Why must we fan the same way for both?
So the test is fair; only the solution changes.
- What else could keep a paper from blowing away?
A heavy book, a block, a stapler, tape, a heavy cup โ heavier things work well.
โ ๏ธ Common mistakes and how to fix them
โ Choosing the solution they like instead of the one that worked.
โ๏ธ Point to the chart: โWhich got more check marks?โ
โ Fanning harder for one solution.
โ๏ธ Count โ1, 2, 3โ together and fan from the same spot.
โ Forgetting to mark after each try.
โ๏ธ Watcher marks right away โ before the next fan.
โ Saying โbetterโ without a reason.
โ๏ธ Use the frame: โ___ worked better because ___.โ
๐งฉ For every learner
๐ค Extra support
- Test each solution only once, with the teacher fanning.
- Use a chart with a happy face (stayed) and a sad face (blew away).
- Give the frame: โThe ___ worked better.โ
๐ Challenge
- Test a third solution (a block, an eraser, a glue stick) and add it to the chart.
- Predict: would two paper clips work better than one? Test it.
- Tell how you would make the test fair.
๐ English learners
- Act out the problem (paper flying) and the solution (holding it down).
- Use picture cards: rock, paper clip, โ, โ.
- Frame: โThe ___ worked better.โ
๐ At home: With a grown-up, put a napkin by an open window or wave a book to make wind. Test two things to hold it down โ like a spoon and a cup. Which worked better? Why?
๐ After the exit ticket and quiz: what to do tomorrow
Sort the exit tickets (or open the quiz results โ they group the class for you) and start tomorrow with 10 minutes in three groups.
โ Got it
- Start the next lesson (push or pull?).
- Early finishers: the Challenge worksheet, then test a third solution (a block or a glue stick) and add it to the chart.
๐ก Almost
- 5 minutes with the teacher: read a finished chart, count the โ for each solution and say โThe ___ worked better because ___.โ
- Then the main worksheetโs chart part with a partner.
๐ Not yet
- Small group with the teacher: the teacher fans; the child puts the rock on one paper and the clip on the other, watches, and places a โ or โ card after each try.
- Then the Easier worksheet (stayed or blew away?) with the teacher reading aloud.
Which solution works better? ยท Kindergarten
๐ค Stayed or blew away?
Same skill, smaller numbers and fill-in-the-blank steps โ for students who need extra support. Everyone else starts on the main worksheet.
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
The teacher reads each line aloud.
A. Circle what happened in our test.
- Paper with a rock: stayed / blew awayAnswer: ________________________โ stayed
- Paper with a paper clip: stayed / blew awayAnswer: ________________________โ blew away
- Which worked better? rock / paper clipAnswer: ________________________โ rock
B. Draw.
- Draw the rock holding the paper down.โ A paper with a rock on top of it.
๐ Answers
- stayed
- blew away
- rock
- A paper with a rock on top of it.
Which solution works better? ยท Kindergarten
๐ Which solution works better?
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
The teacher reads each line aloud.
A. Look at the chart. Rock: โ โ โ Paper clip: โ โ โ
- How many โ for the rock? 1 / 2 / 3Answer: ________________________โ 3
- How many โ for the paper clip? 1 / 2 / 3Answer: ________________________โ 1
- Which worked better? rock / paper clipAnswer: ________________________โ rock (more check marks)
B. Fair or not fair? Circle.
- We fanned both papers 3 times the same way. fair / not fairAnswer: ________________________โ fair
- We fanned the rock paper softly and the clip paper hard. fair / not fairAnswer: ________________________โ not fair
C. Draw.
- Draw the solution that worked better. Tell why.โ A rock on a paper; it is heavier, so it held the paper down.
๐ Answers
- 3
- 1
- rock (more check marks)
- fair
- not fair
- A rock on a paper; it is heavier, so it held the paper down.
Which solution works better? ยท Kindergarten
๐ Challenge: engineer thinking
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
The teacher reads each line aloud.
A. Tell or write.
- Why did the rock work better than the paper clip?Answer: ________________________โ The rock is heavier. It pressed the paper down so the wind could not lift it.
- Kai says, โThe paper clip is better because it is shiny.โ What should he look at?Answer: ________________________โ The data โ the chart shows the rock kept the paper down more times.
- Name one more thing you could test to hold a paper down.Answer: ________________________โ Any heavy, safe object: a book, a block, a stapler, a cup of water, tape.
B. Draw.
- Draw your own test chart for a new solution. Show 3 tries.โ A chart with the new solution and 3 boxes for โ or โ.
๐ Answers
- The rock is heavier. It pressed the paper down so the wind could not lift it.
- The data โ the chart shows the rock kept the paper down more times.
- Any heavy, safe object: a book, a block, a stapler, a cup of water, tape.
- A chart with the new solution and 3 boxes for โ or โ.
Which solution works better? ยท Kindergarten
โ Quiz
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________ Score: ____ / 11
11 questions. Show them on the board and answer together, or give each student the quiz on their own device and see everyoneโs score.
1. What was our problem?
2. What is a solution?
3. Which worked better in our test?
4. Why did the rock work better?
5. Rock: โโโ. Clip: โโโ. Which got more โ?
6. What does โ mean on our chart?
7. Ana fanned one paper softly and one hard. What is wrong?
8. Kai says the clip is better because it is shiny. What should he do?
9. Which could ALSO hold a paper down well?
10. Why test 3 times?
11. What do we do before a test?
11 questions
What was our problem?
- The paper blew away
- The rock was wet
- The clip broke
- The desk was small
What is a solution?
- A problem
- A way to fix a problem
- A kind of rock
- A paper
Which worked better in our test?
- The paper clip
- Neither one
- The rock
- Both the same
Why did the rock work better?
- It is shiny
- It is gray
- It is round
- It is heavier
Rock: โโโ. Clip: โโโ. Which got more โ?
- Rock
- Clip
- Same
- No โ
What does โ mean on our chart?
- Blew away
- The paper stayed
- We did not test
- Broken
Ana fanned one paper softly and one hard. What is wrong?
- Nothing
- She used paper
- It is not fair
- She marked โ
Kai says the clip is better because it is shiny. What should he do?
- Pick by color
- Guess again
- Pick the smallest
- Look at the data
Which could ALSO hold a paper down well?
- A feather
- A heavy book
- A tissue
- A leaf
Why test 3 times?
- To be sure
- To be fast
- To make noise
- To use more paper
What do we do before a test?
- Clean up
- Go home
- Predict
- Erase the chart
๐จ๏ธ Classroom aids to print
Word-wall cards for this lessonโs key words. They print on their own pages.
๐ค Share this lesson
Which solution works better? ยท Kindergarten
๐ Answer key
Easier worksheet
- stayed
- blew away
- rock
- A paper with a rock on top of it.
Worksheet
- 3
- 1
- rock (more check marks)
- fair
- not fair
- A rock on a paper; it is heavier, so it held the paper down.
Challenge page
- The rock is heavier. It pressed the paper down so the wind could not lift it.
- The data โ the chart shows the rock kept the paper down more times.
- Any heavy, safe object: a book, a block, a stapler, a cup of water, tape.
- A chart with the new solution and 3 boxes for โ or โ.
Quiz
- A โ The paper blew away. Wind (fanning) made the paper blow away.
- B โ A way to fix a problem. A solution fixes a problem.
- C โ The rock. The rock kept the paper down more times.
- D โ It is heavier. Heavier things hold the paper down.
- A โ Rock. The rock has 3 โ; the clip has 1.
- B โ The paper stayed. โ means the paper stayed.
- C โ It is not fair. Both papers must get the same fanning.
- D โ Look at the data. Data tells which worked better, not color.
- B โ A heavy book. A heavy book is heavy like the rock.
- A โ To be sure. More tries help us be sure.
- C โ Predict. We predict what will happen.
Where this lesson fits
- Before this lesson: Comparing with โmoreโ and โlessโ โ Students compare objects by size, weight and length using their senses and simple tools.
- This lesson: Students test two ways to solve a problem and say which worked better and why.
- Coming next: Push or pull? โ Students identify pushes and pulls in everyday actions.
๐ Thinkabara Pro
Need this lesson made for your class?
The booklet on this page is free. With Pro you get versions of it: three levels for mixed classes, in Spanish, or adapted for IEP and ELL students โ plus a new booklet on any topic you teach that is not in our library.
Make a version for my class โ free trial โ See a real sample
7 days free, no credit card.
Practice & resources on Thinkabara
๐๏ธ Plan the whole year like this
Add Kindergarten Science to your free Lesson Planner: enter your class schedule once and every period shows the next lesson, skipping weekends and school breaks.
More lessons in โWe are scientists: observing with our sensesโ
- Our five senses โ Students use their senses to observe objects safely.
- Asking questions โ Students ask questions about things they observe.
- Science tools โ Students use magnifiers and balances to observe.
- Drawing like a scientist โ Students draw and label what they observe so others can understand it.
- Comparing with โmoreโ and โlessโ โ Students compare objects by size, weight and length using their senses and simple tools.
- Which solution works better? โ Students test two ways to solve a problem and say which worked better and why.
Something to improve in this lesson? Tell us.