The Surprising Story of Pumpkin Pie

4th Grade Common Core RI.4.1 Fact text 190 words ⏱ 25 minESL A2

A fact text about the history of pumpkin pie: Native American squash, early English pies with apples, the 1796 "pompkin" recipe in the first American cookbook, and canned pumpkin.

Free · US Letter · no sign-up
Google Classroom Save to Pinterest Email me

📚 Print with more 4th Grade passages (one packet)

🎧 Listen to the passage

Pumpkin pie is one of the most famous Thanksgiving desserts. Yet the pie you know is younger than you might think.

Pumpkins are a kind of squash, and Native Americans grew squash for thousands of years before Europeans arrived. English settlers soon learned to grow pumpkins, too. In 1655, one writer noticed that the English colonists liked pumpkins very much and used them in pies.

Those early pies did not look like ours. In England in the 1600s, cooks often layered slices of pumpkin with apples, sugar and spices, and baked them between two crusts.

The smooth pie came later. In 1796, Amelia Simmons published American Cookery, the first cookbook written by an American and printed in America. It had two recipes for "pompkin" pudding baked in a crust. The filling was made of stewed pumpkin, eggs, sugar, milk or cream, and spices such as ginger and nutmeg. Does that sound familiar? It is very close to the way most pumpkin pie is made today.

By the early 1900s, factories were selling pumpkin in cans. Families no longer had to cut and cook a whole pumpkin to bake a pie.

📘 Word bank
desserts
sweet foods eaten after a meal
squash
a group of vegetables that grow on vines, such as pumpkins
settlers
people who move to a new land to live there
layered
put one on top of another
published
printed and offered to the public
recipes
directions for cooking a dish
stewed
cooked slowly in liquid
familiar
known; seen or heard before

✏️ Questions

  1. Main idea

    What is the text mostly about?

  2. Key details

    Who grew squash for thousands of years before Europeans arrived?

  3. Key details

    What did English cooks in the 1600s often put in pumpkin pie with the pumpkin?

  4. Key details

    What was special about American Cookery?

  5. Key details

    List THREE things that went into the 1796 "pompkin" filling.

  6. Word meaning

    In paragraph 4, the word "stewed" means…

  7. Compare & contrast

    How was the 1796 pie different from the English pies of the 1600s?

  8. Cause & effect

    How did canned pumpkin change pie baking?

✍️ Need a passage on a different topic?

Tell us the topic and the grade — we’ll write a new reading passage with questions, an answer key and a printable worksheet, free like everything here.

⏱️ It isn’t instant: every new passage is written and fact-checked before it goes up. It’s usually ready within 24 hours (often in a few hours). Leave your email and we’ll send you the link the moment it’s live.

More 4th Grade reading passages

All 4th Grade passages →