🍎 What Keeps Apple Slices from Turning Brown?

Dip apple slices in lemon juice, salt water, plain water or nothing and compare their color every hour. It is tasty kitchen chemistry with a real use for lunch boxes.

Free · US Letter · no sign-up
Google Classroom Save to Pinterest Email me
🎒 Kindergarten🎒 1st grade🧪 Chemistry📶 Easy⏱️ 1 afternoon💲 Under $10🧑‍🔬 Grown-up helps

Question: Which liquid keeps apple slices from turning brown the longest?

Hypothesis: If I dip apple slices in lemon juice, then they will stay white longest because lemon juice is sour and stops browning.

Variables

  • Independent variable (what you change): What the slice is dipped in (nothing, water, salt water, lemon juice)
  • Dependent variable (what you measure): Browning score from 0 (white) to 5 (very brown)
  • Controlled variables (keep the same): Slices from the same apple; Same dipping time (1 minute); Same plate and room

Materials

  • 2 apples
  • Lemon juice
  • Salt
  • Water
  • 4 small bowls
  • A plate and labels
  • A timer
  • Crayons to make a 0–5 color chart

Procedure — step by step

  1. Make a browning chart: draw 6 boxes from white (0) to dark brown (5).
  2. An adult cuts one apple into 8 slices.
  3. Leave 2 slices plain. Dip 2 slices in plain water, 2 in salt water (¼ teaspoon salt in ½ cup water) and 2 in lemon juice for 1 minute each.
  4. Put them on a labeled plate.
  5. Score every slice with your chart after 1, 2, 3 and 4 hours.
  6. Repeat with the second apple for another trial.
  7. Average the scores for each liquid.

⚠️ Safety: An adult does all the cutting.

Data table

Browning score after 4 hours (0 = white, 5 = very brown)
Dipped inSlice 1Slice 2Slice 3Slice 4Average
Nothing     
Water     
Salt water     
Lemon juice     

Graph it as a bar graph: put “Dipped in” on the x-axis and your measurement on the y-axis.

Printable project sheets

A plan with every step, and a data sheet with a graph grid and conclusion lines.

Project plan

🍎 What Keeps Apple Slices from Turning Brown?

Name:Due:

Question: Which liquid keeps apple slices from turning brown the longest?

My hypothesis: If I dip apple slices in lemon juice, then they will stay white longest because lemon juice is sour and stops browning.

Change: What the slice is dipped in (nothing, water, salt water, lemon juice) · Measure: Browning score from 0 (white) to 5 (very brown) · Keep the same: Slices from the same apple; Same dipping time (1 minute); Same plate and room

Materials

  • 2 apples
  • Lemon juice
  • Salt
  • Water
  • 4 small bowls
  • A plate and labels
  • A timer
  • Crayons to make a 0–5 color chart

Steps (check them off)

  1. ☐ Make a browning chart: draw 6 boxes from white (0) to dark brown (5).
  2. ☐ An adult cuts one apple into 8 slices.
  3. ☐ Leave 2 slices plain. Dip 2 slices in plain water, 2 in salt water (¼ teaspoon salt in ½ cup water) and 2 in lemon juice for 1 minute each.
  4. ☐ Put them on a labeled plate.
  5. ☐ Score every slice with your chart after 1, 2, 3 and 4 hours.
  6. ☐ Repeat with the second apple for another trial.
  7. ☐ Average the scores for each liquid.

Safety: An adult does all the cutting.

thinkabara.com/science/science-fair-projects/what-keeps-apples-from-browning

Data sheet + graph

Data: Browning score after 4 hours (0 = white, 5 = very brown)

Dipped inSlice 1Slice 2Slice 3Slice 4Average
Nothing
Water
Salt water
Lemon juice

My bar graph (x: Dipped in)

Conclusion: Was my hypothesis supported? What did I learn?

thinkabara.com/science/science-fair-projects/what-keeps-apples-from-browning

What usually happens

Plain slices brown the most. Lemon juice and salt water both slow browning a lot; water helps a little at first. Apple varieties brown at different speeds.

The science behind it

Inside apple cells is a helper chemical (an enzyme). When you cut an apple, the enzyme meets oxygen in the air and makes brown pigments. Lemon juice is acidic and has vitamin C, which slow the enzyme down. Salt also slows it. Water only keeps the air away for a short time.

Take it further

  • Try honey water or sparkling water.
  • Compare 3 kinds of apples.
  • Put one plate in the fridge.

Putting it on your board

Left panel: question, hypothesis and variables. Center: your title, graph and photos of the setup. Right panel: procedure summary, results and conclusion. See the scientific method guide for a printable board layout and judging checklist, or browse more kindergarten projects.

Frequently asked questions

Is “What Keeps Apple Slices from Turning Brown” a good science fair project for grades k–1?

Yes. It is rated easy, takes 1 afternoon, costs under about $10 and has a real measurable result, which is what judges look for. A grown-up should help with some steps.

What is the independent variable in this project?

What the slice is dipped in (nothing, water, salt water, lemon juice). The dependent variable (what you measure) is: browning score from 0 (white) to 5 (very brown).

What results should I expect?

Plain slices brown the most. Lemon juice and salt water both slow browning a lot; water helps a little at first. Apple varieties brown at different speeds.

How many trials should I do?

At least three for every condition, then average them. More trials make your conclusion stronger, and if one trial is very different, you can explain why (and maybe redo it).

More free printables from Thinkabara