🧊 What Melts Ice the Fastest: Salt, Sugar or Sand?

Sprinkle salt, sugar and sand on ice cubes and time how fast they melt. It explains why trucks spread salt on icy winter roads.

Free · US Letter · no sign-up
Google Classroom Save to Pinterest Email me
🎒 1st grade🎒 2nd grade🧪 Chemistry📶 Easy⏱️ 1 afternoon💲 Under $10

Question: Which melts ice the fastest: salt, sugar or sand?

Hypothesis: If I sprinkle salt, sugar and sand on ice cubes, then the salt will melt the ice fastest because salt is used on icy roads.

Variables

  • Independent variable (what you change): What is sprinkled on the ice (salt, sugar, sand or nothing)
  • Dependent variable (what you measure): Minutes until the cube is completely melted
  • Controlled variables (keep the same): Same-size ice cubes from the same tray; 1 teaspoon of each substance; Same room and same kind of plate

Materials

  • 4 ice cubes per trial (same tray)
  • 4 small plates
  • Table salt, sugar, sand
  • A teaspoon
  • Labels
  • A timer

Procedure — step by step

  1. Label 4 plates: SALT, SUGAR, SAND, NOTHING.
  2. Put one ice cube on each plate at the same time.
  3. Sprinkle 1 level teaspoon of salt on the SALT cube, sugar on the SUGAR cube and sand on the SAND cube. Leave the last cube plain.
  4. Start the timer.
  5. Check every 5 minutes. Write down the time when each cube is completely melted (no solid ice left).
  6. Do the whole test 3 times with fresh cubes and dry plates.
  7. Find the average melting time for each plate.

⚠️ Safety: Keep salt away from eyes and wash hands after.

Data table

Minutes to melt completely
Sprinkled withTrial 1Trial 2Trial 3Average
Salt    
Sugar    
Sand    
Nothing    

Graph it as a bar graph: put “Sprinkled with” on the x-axis and your measurement on the y-axis.

Printable project sheets

A plan with every step, and a data sheet with a graph grid and conclusion lines.

Project plan

🧊 What Melts Ice the Fastest: Salt, Sugar or Sand?

Name:Due:

Question: Which melts ice the fastest: salt, sugar or sand?

My hypothesis: If I sprinkle salt, sugar and sand on ice cubes, then the salt will melt the ice fastest because salt is used on icy roads.

Change: What is sprinkled on the ice (salt, sugar, sand or nothing) · Measure: Minutes until the cube is completely melted · Keep the same: Same-size ice cubes from the same tray; 1 teaspoon of each substance; Same room and same kind of plate

Materials

  • 4 ice cubes per trial (same tray)
  • 4 small plates
  • Table salt, sugar, sand
  • A teaspoon
  • Labels
  • A timer

Steps (check them off)

  1. ☐ Label 4 plates: SALT, SUGAR, SAND, NOTHING.
  2. ☐ Put one ice cube on each plate at the same time.
  3. ☐ Sprinkle 1 level teaspoon of salt on the SALT cube, sugar on the SUGAR cube and sand on the SAND cube. Leave the last cube plain.
  4. ☐ Start the timer.
  5. ☐ Check every 5 minutes. Write down the time when each cube is completely melted (no solid ice left).
  6. ☐ Do the whole test 3 times with fresh cubes and dry plates.
  7. ☐ Find the average melting time for each plate.

Safety: Keep salt away from eyes and wash hands after.

thinkabara.com/science/science-fair-projects/what-melts-ice-fastest

Data sheet + graph

Data: Minutes to melt completely

Sprinkled withTrial 1Trial 2Trial 3Average
Salt
Sugar
Sand
Nothing

My bar graph (x: Sprinkled with)

Conclusion: Was my hypothesis supported? What did I learn?

thinkabara.com/science/science-fair-projects/what-melts-ice-fastest

What usually happens

Salt usually wins clearly. Sugar helps a little. Sand and plain ice are close — sand may help slightly in sunlight because dark sand warms up. Results change with room temperature, so run all plates side by side.

The science behind it

Ice is always melting a tiny bit on its surface. Salt dissolves in that thin layer of water and makes salt water, which freezes at a lower temperature than plain water, so the ice keeps melting. Sugar dissolves too, but a teaspoon of sugar makes fewer dissolved particles than a teaspoon of salt, so it works less. Sand does not dissolve, so it mostly just adds grip.

Take it further

  • Try different amounts of salt (½, 1, 2 teaspoons).
  • Compare table salt with rock salt or Epsom salt.
  • Test outside on a freezing day.

Putting it on your board

Left panel: question, hypothesis and variables. Center: your title, graph and photos of the setup. Right panel: procedure summary, results and conclusion. See the scientific method guide for a printable board layout and judging checklist, or browse more 1st grade projects.

Frequently asked questions

Is “What Melts Ice the Fastest: Salt, Sugar or Sand” a good science fair project for grades 1–2?

Yes. It is rated easy, takes 1 afternoon, costs under about $10 and has a real measurable result, which is what judges look for.

What is the independent variable in this project?

What is sprinkled on the ice (salt, sugar, sand or nothing). The dependent variable (what you measure) is: minutes until the cube is completely melted.

What results should I expect?

Salt usually wins clearly. Sugar helps a little. Sand and plain ice are close — sand may help slightly in sunlight because dark sand warms up. Results change with room temperature, so run all plates side by side.

How many trials should I do?

At least three for every condition, then average them. More trials make your conclusion stronger, and if one trial is very different, you can explain why (and maybe redo it).

More free printables from Thinkabara