Renewable and nonrenewable
🎯 Objective: Students compare energy resources and how their use affects the environment.
🦫 Thinkabara · Lesson booklet
Renewable and nonrenewable
4th Grade · Science · 4-ESS3-1
🎯 Students compare energy resources and how their use affects the environment.
- Teacher’s lesson plan
- Easier worksheet
- Student worksheet
- Challenge page
- Quiz
- Answer key
Teacher: ______________________ Class: ____________
📘 This lesson comes as a booklet: teacher’s plan, student worksheet, challenge page, quiz and answer key — all in one printable booklet. Teach from this page, print it all, or give the quiz to the class online.
Full-screen slides for the projector: goals, opener, every drawing already made, the exit ticket and the quiz — click or use the arrow keys.
🗓️ Lesson at a glance
⏱️ 50 minutes
- 5 min Opener (pick one)
- 7 min Teach: where does our electricity come from?
- 5 min Sort: sun, wind, water, coal, oil, gas
- 5 min Model: one row of the chart
- 12 min Group work: pros and cons chart
- 6 min Discuss: choose for a town
- 3 min Exit ticket
- 2 min Wrap-up
- 5 min Handing out, moving and cleaning up
Not in these 50 minutes: the worksheets (independent practice tomorrow, in centers or as homework) and the quiz (after the practice, or at the end of the week).
🧰 Materials
- 6 resource picture cards per group: Sun, wind, moving water, coal, oil, natural gas
- Chart paper with a pros and cons table (Resource | Renewable? | Pros | Cons) — 1 per group
- Markers
- A lamp or charger with its plug (for the opener — never plugged in during the demo)
- Worksheet and pencils
🔤 Key words
- renewable
- A resource nature replaces quickly, so it won’t run out — sun, wind, moving water.
- nonrenewable
- A resource that takes millions of years to form and can run out — coal, oil, natural gas.
- power plant
- A place where electricity is made.
- turbine
- A machine with blades that spin to help make electricity.
- pollution
- Harmful things added to the air, water or land.
- pro / con
- A pro is a good point about a choice. A con is a bad point.
🎯 Success criteria — read them to the class
- I can describe how electricity is made from different energy resources.
- I can sort sun, wind, water, coal, oil and gas into renewable and nonrenewable.
- I can use a pros and cons chart to compare how energy resources affect the environment.
🎬 Open the lesson — pick one (5 min)
Get the class moving, curious and talking before the learning starts. Each one leads straight into today’s topic.
🤸 Brain break: Spin the turbine
- Stand up with space around you.
- Hold one arm out to the side and make slow, small circles with your hand — you are a wind turbine in a soft breeze. 5 circles.
- The wind gets stronger — make the circles a little faster. 5 circles.
- Switch arms and do 5 more.
- The wind stops — freeze! Lower your arm slowly and sit down.
Say: “When the wind blew, your turbine spun. When the wind stopped, you froze. Real wind turbines spin to make electricity — but only when the wind blows. Today we compare where our electricity comes from and what each choice does to our environment.”
🧩 Riddle
“I shine every day, I never run out, and I make no smoke. But at night and on cloudy days, I give you less power. What energy resource am I?”
Hint: Solar panels catch me.
Answer
The Sun — a renewable resource. Today we weigh its pros and cons against other resources.
🎁 Mystery object
Do: Hold up a phone charger or a lamp plug (unplugged) and follow its cord with your hand to the wall outlet. Do not plug anything in.
Say: “When we plug something in here, electricity comes out of the wall. But where does it really come from before it gets to the wall?”
Reveal: It travels through wires from a power plant, sometimes many miles away. The power plant might burn coal or natural gas, or use wind, water or sunlight. Today we find out which resources make our electricity, and what each one does to the environment.
🤔 Would you rather
“Would you rather live next to a big wind farm or next to a coal power plant?”
Do: Students move to one side of the room and tell someone on the other side one reason for their choice.
Then: Wind turbines make no smoke but can be noisy and can harm birds. A coal plant makes electricity on calm days and at night, but it pollutes the air. Every choice has pros and cons — that is what we chart today.
🧑🏫 Teach it step by step
1 Teach: where does our electricity come from? 7 min
Say:“Electricity comes to our school through wires from power plants. To make electricity, a power plant must spin a machine called a turbine.”
“Some power plants burn coal, oil or natural gas. The fire heats water into steam, and the steam spins the turbine.”
“Wind turbines are spun by the wind. Dams use falling water to spin turbines. And solar panels change sunlight straight into electricity — no spinning at all.”
“In the United States, a lot of electricity comes from burning natural gas and coal, and more and more comes from wind and the Sun.”
“Remember from our energy resources lesson: sun, wind and moving water are renewable. Coal, oil and natural gas are nonrenewable fossil fuels.”
Ask: What do coal, natural gas and wind power plants all need to do to make electricity?
Look for: Spin a turbine — with steam from burning fuel, or with the wind.
2 Sort: sun, wind, water, coal, oil, gas 5 min
Do:- Groups sort the 6 cards into two piles: renewable and nonrenewable. Check together.
Say:“Sort your six cards. For each one, say why: “nature replaces it quickly” or “it took millions of years to form”.”
“Renewable: sun, wind, moving water. Nonrenewable: coal, oil, natural gas.”
Ask: Someone says: “Oil comes from nature, so it is renewable.” What do you say?
Look for: Coming from nature isn’t enough. Oil took millions of years to form, so it is nonrenewable.
3 Model: one row of the chart 5 min
Do:- Fill in the first row of the pros and cons chart on the board together: Wind.
Say:“Let’s do wind together. Is it renewable? Yes.”
“Pros — good points: it won’t run out, and turbines make no smoke or air pollution.”
“Cons — bad points: turbines only work when the wind blows, they can harm birds and bats, and some people don’t like how they look or sound.”
“Now your group does the other five resources. Use what you remember from the resource cards.”
4 Group work: pros and cons chart 12 min
Do:- Groups of 4 fill in their chart for sun, moving water, coal, oil and natural gas.
- Each person writes at least one pro and one con with a marker of their own color, so every voice shows.
Say:“For each resource, write at least one pro and one con.”
“Think about: Will it run out? Does it make smoke or pollution? Does it change the land or water where plants and animals live? Does it work all the time?”
“Fossil fuels have pros too — be fair. For example, coal and gas plants can make electricity at night and on calm days.”
Ask: Ask a group: “What is a con of using a dam?”
Look for: It floods land behind it and can block fish from swimming up the river.
Ask: Ask: “What is a pro of natural gas?”
Look for: It can make electricity any time, day or night, and it burns cleaner than coal.
5 Discuss: choose for a town 6 min
Do:- Pose the problem: a small town by a windy hill and a river needs a new power plant. Groups choose one resource (or a mix) and give two reasons from their chart.
Say:“There is no perfect answer. Engineers and town leaders weigh the pros and cons, like you did.”
“Many places use a mix: wind and solar when they work, and other power plants when they don’t.”
“And remember: the cleanest energy is the energy we don’t waste. Turning off lights helps with every resource.”
Ask: Why might a town use a mix of resources instead of just one?
Look for: Wind and solar don’t work all the time, so a mix keeps the lights on while still cutting pollution.
6 Exit ticket 3 min
Do:- Students answer on a sticky note.
Say:“Name one renewable resource. Then name one effect on the environment of burning a fuel like coal, oil or natural gas.”
✅ Correct answer: Renewable: sun, wind or moving water. Effect: burning the fuel pollutes the air (also accepted: mining or drilling changes land where animals live, oil spills harm ocean animals). If a student names wood as the renewable resource, accept it with a note “only if new trees are planted”. If they name coal, oil or gas as renewable, they are “not yet”.
✓ Wrap-up 2 min
Do:- Read the three “I can” statements aloud.
- Sort exit tickets: got it / almost / not yet.
Say:“Tell your neighbor one pro and one con of solar power.”
“Show me with your fingers how sure you are: 1 = not yet, 2 = almost, 3 = I can teach it.”
💡 Teacher tips
- Never plug in or unplug anything during the opener — just follow the cord with your hand.
- Hang the charts from the energy resources lesson, if you saved them, so groups can look back at the facts.
- Keep the tone balanced: every resource has pros and cons, and families work in many energy jobs.
- Give each group member a different marker color so you can see who contributed to the chart.
- If your town or state has a wind farm, dam or solar farm nearby, mention it — local examples make the lesson stick.
💬 Discussion questions
- Why can’t we use only wind and solar power all the time?
The wind doesn’t always blow, and the Sun doesn’t shine at night, so other power is needed at those times unless energy is stored.
- What do all fuels that we burn have in common?
Burning them makes smoke or gases that pollute the air.
- How could your school use less electricity?
Turn off lights and screens when not used, use daylight, close doors when heating or cooling.
⚠️ Common mistakes and how to fix them
❌ Thinking anything “from nature” is renewable.
✔️ All resources come from nature. Ask: “Does nature replace it quickly, or did it take millions of years?”
❌ Thinking renewable resources have no cons.
✔️ Show the wind row: only works when windy, can harm birds. Every resource has cons.
❌ Thinking electricity is made inside the wall outlet.
✔️ Trace the path: power plant → wires → outlet. The outlet is just the end of the path.
❌ Writing only cons for fossil fuels.
✔️ Ask: “Why do people still use them?” They work day and night and in any weather.
🧩 For every learner
🤝 Extra support
- Give a chart with the Renewable? column already filled in.
- Use a word bank for pros and cons: won’t run out, makes smoke, harms animals, works all the time, only when sunny/windy.
- Fill in only 3 rows: sun, wind, coal.
🚀 Challenge
- Write a letter to the town council recommending an energy plan, using the chart as evidence.
- Research which resources make electricity in your state, with help from a family member or the librarian.
- Explain how a town could still have electricity on calm nights if it uses mostly wind power.
🌎 English learners
- Picture cards for each resource, with renewable (circle arrow) and nonrenewable (X) symbols.
- Thumbs up for pro, thumbs down for con while reading the chart aloud.
- Sentence frames: “A pro of ___ is ___.” “A con of ___ is ___.”
🏠 At home: With a family member, find out (from a bill, a website or by asking) one energy resource used to make electricity where you live. Make a mini pros and cons chart for it, and choose one way your family can save electricity this week.
📊 After the exit ticket and quiz: what to do tomorrow
Sort the exit tickets (or open the quiz results — they group the class for you) and start tomorrow with 10 minutes in three groups.
✅ Got it
- Start the next unit with the next lesson (wave models).
- Early finishers: challenge sheet — the letter to the town council.
🟡 Almost
- 5 minutes: re-sort the 6 cards and add one effect on the environment to each nonrenewable card.
- Fix the exit ticket so it names a specific effect (e.g. air pollution), not just “it’s bad”.
🔁 Not yet
- Small group with the teacher: sort sun, wind, coal and oil, saying “nature replaces it quickly” or “millions of years” for each, then add one pro and one con for two of them.
- Then the Easier worksheet (renewable or nonrenewable?) with the teacher nearby.
Renewable and nonrenewable · 4th Grade
🤝 Renewable or nonrenewable?
Same skill, smaller numbers and fill-in-the-blank steps — for students who need extra support. Everyone else starts on the main worksheet.
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Write R (renewable) or N (nonrenewable).
- Sun ___ Wind ___ Moving water ___Answer: ________________________✅ R, R, R
- Coal ___ Oil ___ Natural gas ___Answer: ________________________✅ N, N, N
B. Pro or con? Write PRO or CON.
- Wind will never run out. ________Answer: ________________________✅ PRO
- Burning coal makes smoke. ________Answer: ________________________✅ CON
- Solar panels don’t work at night. ________Answer: ________________________✅ CON
- Solar panels make no smoke. ________Answer: ________________________✅ PRO
🔑 Answers
- R, R, R
- N, N, N
- PRO
- CON
- CON
- PRO
Renewable and nonrenewable · 4th Grade
📝 Pros and cons of energy resources
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Complete the chart: renewable or not, one pro, one con.
- Sun:Answer: ________________________✅ Renewable. Pro: won’t run out, no smoke. Con: no power at night, less on cloudy days, panels need space.
- Moving water (dam):Answer: ________________________✅ Renewable. Pro: won’t run out, no smoke. Con: floods land, can block fish.
- Coal:Answer: ________________________✅ Nonrenewable. Pro: works day and night. Con: pollutes the air; mining harms land.
- Oil:Answer: ________________________✅ Nonrenewable. Pro: makes gasoline for cars, works any time. Con: spills harm ocean animals; burning pollutes air.
- Natural gas:Answer: ________________________✅ Nonrenewable. Pro: works any time, burns cleaner than coal. Con: still pollutes the air; will run out.
B. Explain.
- How does a coal power plant make electricity?Answer: ________________________✅ It burns coal to heat water into steam, and the steam spins a turbine that makes electricity.
- Why do many places use a mix of resources?Answer: ________________________✅ Wind and sun don’t work all the time, so other power plants help when they don’t.
- Name one way you can use less electricity.Answer: ________________________✅ e.g. turn off lights and screens, unplug chargers, open curtains for daylight.
🔑 Answers
- Renewable. Pro: won’t run out, no smoke. Con: no power at night, less on cloudy days, panels need space.
- Renewable. Pro: won’t run out, no smoke. Con: floods land, can block fish.
- Nonrenewable. Pro: works day and night. Con: pollutes the air; mining harms land.
- Nonrenewable. Pro: makes gasoline for cars, works any time. Con: spills harm ocean animals; burning pollutes air.
- Nonrenewable. Pro: works any time, burns cleaner than coal. Con: still pollutes the air; will run out.
- It burns coal to heat water into steam, and the steam spins a turbine that makes electricity.
- Wind and sun don’t work all the time, so other power plants help when they don’t.
- e.g. turn off lights and screens, unplug chargers, open curtains for daylight.
Renewable and nonrenewable · 4th Grade
🚀 Challenge: energy planner
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Think and explain.
- Ben says: “Solar power is perfect. It has no cons.” Is he right? Explain with two facts.Answer: ________________________✅ No. Solar panels don’t make power at night and make less on cloudy days, and they take up a lot of space.
- A town uses only wind power. On a calm night, what problem could happen? Suggest one solution.Answer: ________________________✅ Not enough electricity because the wind isn’t blowing. Solutions: also use another resource (e.g. moving water or natural gas), or store energy for later.
- Why is natural gas called nonrenewable even though it comes from nature?Answer: ________________________✅ It took millions of years to form underground, so once it is used, it cannot be replaced quickly.
B. Write.
- Write a short letter to a town council recommending an energy resource for a town near a windy hill and a river. Give one pro, one con, and how you would handle the con.Answer: ________________________✅ Any letter with a resource, a correct pro and con, and a sensible plan for the con (e.g. wind plus a dam for calm days).
🔑 Answers
- No. Solar panels don’t make power at night and make less on cloudy days, and they take up a lot of space.
- Not enough electricity because the wind isn’t blowing. Solutions: also use another resource (e.g. moving water or natural gas), or store energy for later.
- It took millions of years to form underground, so once it is used, it cannot be replaced quickly.
- Any letter with a resource, a correct pro and con, and a sensible plan for the con (e.g. wind plus a dam for calm days).
Renewable and nonrenewable · 4th Grade
✅ Quiz
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________ Score: ____ / 12
12 questions. Show them on the board and answer together, or give each student the quiz on their own device and see everyone’s score.
1. Which group shows ONLY renewable resources?
2. How does a coal power plant make electricity?
3. What is a con of wind power?
4. What is a pro of solar panels?
5. Eli says: “Natural gas comes from nature, so it is renewable.” What should he say?
6. Which is NOT a renewable resource?
7. A dam is built to make electricity. Which is a con?
8. Pros and cons chart — Sun: “won’t run out” / “no power at night”. Coal: “works day and night” / “pollutes the air”. A town wants NO air pollution. Which should it pick?
9. Where does the electricity in a wall outlet come from?
10. Why do many towns use a mix of energy resources?
11. What do coal, oil and natural gas have in common when they are burned?
12. Which action helps the environment no matter which resource makes the electricity?
12 questions
Which group shows ONLY renewable resources?
- Coal, oil, gas
- Sun, wind, moving water
- Sun, coal, wind
- Oil, wind, water
How does a coal power plant make electricity?
- Coal shines light on panels
- Wind blows the coal
- Burning coal makes steam that spins a turbine
- Coal flows down a river
What is a con of wind power?
- It only works when the wind blows
- It will run out soon
- It makes thick smoke
- It needs coal
What is a pro of solar panels?
- They work best at night
- They need oil
- They pollute the air
- They make no smoke
Eli says: “Natural gas comes from nature, so it is renewable.” What should he say?
- Eli is right
- Natural gas took millions of years to form, so it is nonrenewable
- Natural gas comes from the Sun
- Natural gas is made in the wall outlet
Which is NOT a renewable resource?
- Sunlight
- Wind
- Coal
- Moving water
A dam is built to make electricity. Which is a con?
- It floods land and can block fish
- It runs out of water in a week
- It makes smoke
- It only works at night
Pros and cons chart — Sun: “won’t run out” / “no power at night”. Coal: “works day and night” / “pollutes the air”. A town wants NO air pollution. Which should it pick?
- Coal
- Neither
- Both equally
- Sun
Where does the electricity in a wall outlet come from?
- It is made inside the wall
- From a power plant, through wires
- From the plug
- From the light bulb
Why do many towns use a mix of energy resources?
- Wind and sun don’t work all the time
- It makes electricity louder
- One resource is against the law
- Turbines need coal
What do coal, oil and natural gas have in common when they are burned?
- They make no smoke
- They are renewable
- They pollute the air
- They come from the wind
Which action helps the environment no matter which resource makes the electricity?
- Leaving screens on all night
- Turning off lights you aren’t using
- Opening windows with the heat on
- Using more electricity
🖨️ Classroom aids to print
Word-wall cards for this lesson’s key words. They print on their own pages.
📤 Share this lesson
Renewable and nonrenewable · 4th Grade
🔑 Answer key
Easier worksheet
- R, R, R
- N, N, N
- PRO
- CON
- CON
- PRO
Worksheet
- Renewable. Pro: won’t run out, no smoke. Con: no power at night, less on cloudy days, panels need space.
- Renewable. Pro: won’t run out, no smoke. Con: floods land, can block fish.
- Nonrenewable. Pro: works day and night. Con: pollutes the air; mining harms land.
- Nonrenewable. Pro: makes gasoline for cars, works any time. Con: spills harm ocean animals; burning pollutes air.
- Nonrenewable. Pro: works any time, burns cleaner than coal. Con: still pollutes the air; will run out.
- It burns coal to heat water into steam, and the steam spins a turbine that makes electricity.
- Wind and sun don’t work all the time, so other power plants help when they don’t.
- e.g. turn off lights and screens, unplug chargers, open curtains for daylight.
Challenge page
- No. Solar panels don’t make power at night and make less on cloudy days, and they take up a lot of space.
- Not enough electricity because the wind isn’t blowing. Solutions: also use another resource (e.g. moving water or natural gas), or store energy for later.
- It took millions of years to form underground, so once it is used, it cannot be replaced quickly.
- Any letter with a resource, a correct pro and con, and a sensible plan for the con (e.g. wind plus a dam for calm days).
Quiz
- B — Sun, wind, moving water. Sun, wind and moving water are replaced by nature.
- C — Burning coal makes steam that spins a turbine. The heat turns water to steam, and the steam spins a turbine.
- A — It only works when the wind blows. Turbines stop when the wind stops.
- D — They make no smoke. Solar panels make electricity without burning anything.
- B — Natural gas took millions of years to form, so it is nonrenewable. Coming from nature is not enough — it can’t be replaced quickly.
- C — Coal. Coal is a fossil fuel.
- A — It floods land and can block fish. Dams change rivers and the land around them.
- D — Sun. Solar makes no air pollution; coal does.
- B — From a power plant, through wires. Wires carry electricity from a power plant to the outlet.
- A — Wind and sun don’t work all the time. Other resources help when it is calm or dark.
- C — They pollute the air. Burning fossil fuels pollutes the air.
- B — Turning off lights you aren’t using. Using less electricity means less of every resource is used.
Where this lesson fits
- Before this lesson: Heat moves — Students observe heat moving from a warm object to a cooler one.
- This lesson: Students compare energy resources and how their use affects the environment.
- Coming next: Wave models — Students model waves with amplitude and wavelength.
🌟 Thinkabara Pro
Need this lesson made for your class?
The booklet on this page is free. With Pro you get versions of it: three levels for mixed classes, in Spanish, or adapted for IEP and ELL students — plus a new booklet on any topic you teach that is not in our library.
Make a version for my class — free trial → See a real sample
7 days free, no credit card.
Practice & resources on Thinkabara
🗓️ Plan the whole year like this
Add 4th Grade Science to your free Lesson Planner: enter your class schedule once and every period shows the next lesson, skipping weekends and school breaks.
More lessons in “Energy”
- Speed and energy — Students use evidence to relate an object’s speed to its energy.
- Collisions — Students observe energy changes when objects collide.
- Energy transfer — Students show energy moves by sound, light, heat and electricity.
- Circuits — Students build simple circuits.
- Energy converter design — Students design a device that converts energy from one form to another.
- Energy resources — Students compare renewable and nonrenewable energy and their effects.
- Forms of energy — Students find evidence of energy in sound, light, heat and motion.
- Heat moves — Students observe heat moving from a warm object to a cooler one.
- Renewable and nonrenewable — Students compare energy resources and how their use affects the environment.
Something to improve in this lesson? Tell us.