Does the weight change?
🎯 Objective: Students measure and graph weight before and after dissolving and melting.
🦫 Thinkabara · Lesson booklet
Does the weight change?
5th Grade · Science · 5-PS1-2
🎯 Students measure and graph weight before and after dissolving and melting.
- Teacher’s lesson plan
- Easier worksheet
- Student worksheet
- Challenge page
- Quiz
- Answer key
Teacher: ______________________ Class: ____________
📘 This lesson comes as a booklet: teacher’s plan, student worksheet, challenge page, quiz and answer key — all in one printable booklet. Teach from this page, print it all, or give the quiz to the class online.
Full-screen slides for the projector: goals, opener, every drawing already made, the exit ticket and the quiz — click or use the arrow keys.
🗓️ Lesson at a glance
⏱️ 50 minutes
- 5 min Opener (pick one)
- 5 min Predict and explain
- 4 min Plan a fair measurement
- 11 min Investigate: dissolving and melting
- 9 min Graph and compare
- 5 min Discuss: what about small differences?
- 3 min Exit ticket
- 3 min Wrap-up
- 5 min Handing out, moving and cleaning up
Not in these 50 minutes: the worksheets (independent practice tomorrow, in centers or as homework) and the quiz (after the practice, or at the end of the week).
🧰 Materials
- Digital kitchen scales that show grams, 1 per group
- Clear plastic cups with water and small paper cups with salt and with sugar (2–3 tablespoons each)
- Zip-top bags with ice cubes (sealed and weighed by each group at the start of the lesson) and paper towels
- Spoons or craft sticks for stirring
- Graph paper or the worksheet graph grid, rulers, two colored pencils per student
- Class data chart on chart paper
🔤 Key words
- prediction
- What you think will happen, and why, before you test.
- dissolve
- To break apart into particles too small to see and spread out in a liquid.
- melt
- To change from a solid to a liquid.
- bar graph
- A graph that uses bars of different heights to compare numbers.
- measurement error
- A small difference that comes from the tool or the way we measure, not from a real change.
- trial
- One run of a test. Doing more trials makes results more trustworthy.
🎯 Success criteria — read them to the class
- I can predict and measure the total weight before and after dissolving and melting.
- I can make a bar graph that compares weights before and after a change.
- I can use my graph as evidence that the total weight of matter stays the same.
🎬 Open the lesson — pick one (5 min)
Get the class moving, curious and talking before the learning starts. Each one leads straight into today’s topic.
🤸 Brain break: Balance scale
- Stand up behind your chair and hold both arms straight out to the sides, like a balance scale.
- I put a heavy backpack in your right hand: lower your right arm a little and raise your left.
- Now I put the same backpack in your left hand: switch.
- Both hands get the same weight: arms level. Hold for 3 slow breaths.
- Lower your arms slowly and sit down.
Say: “Level arms mean the same weight on both sides. Today we measure carefully to answer a question many people get wrong: when salt dissolves in water, does the total weight change?”
🧩 Riddle
“Before: 200 grams of water and 20 grams of salt. After stirring, you cannot see the salt at all. A scale will tell the truth about me. What number will I show?”
Hint: Add the two weights.
Answer
220 grams — the salt is still there. Today you test it yourself!
🎁 Mystery object
Do: Put a cup of water and a small paper cup of salt side by side on a digital scale. Cover the display with a sticky note. Pour the salt into the water, stir until it dissolves, and put the empty paper cup back on the scale.
Say: “The salt has vanished from sight. Predict: when I lift the sticky note, will the number be higher, lower or the same as before I poured? (Write down the “before” number for the class first.)”
Reveal: Lift the sticky note: the number is the same (or within 1 gram). The salt particles are still in the water, so their weight is still on the scale.
🤔 Would you rather
“Would you rather carry a bucket with 1 kilogram of water and a bag of 100 grams of sugar, or the same bucket after the sugar is stirred in?”
Do: Students choose a side of the room and explain to a partner which would feel lighter.
Then: They weigh the same — 1,100 grams either way. Dissolving does not make the sugar weightless. Today your scale and your graph will prove it.
🧑🏫 Teach it step by step
1 Predict and explain 5 min
Do:- Each group seals 4–5 ice cubes in a zip-top bag, dries it, weighs it and writes the weight and time. The bag melts on a paper towel during the lesson.
Say:“Our question: will salt water weigh more, less or the same as the salt and the water weighed separately?”
“Some people think dissolved salt weighs nothing because it cannot be seen. Some people think the water gets heavier than the two together. Write your prediction with a reason: “I predict the total will be ___ because ___.””
“Remember the particle model: when salt dissolves, its particles spread out between the water particles.”
Ask: What does the particle model help you predict?
Look for: If the salt particles are still there and none leave, the total weight should be the same.
2 Plan a fair measurement 4 min
Say:“Weigh the cup of water and the paper cup of salt together on the scale. Write the total.”
“Pour the salt in, stir until it dissolves, and put the empty paper cup and the stirring stick back on the scale with the water cup. Write the total.”
“Then do a second trial with sugar instead of salt. Two trials give us more evidence than one.”
“Do not press the zero button in the middle. Read the number only when it stops changing.”
Ask: Why do the empty paper cup and stirring stick go back on the scale?
Look for: They were part of the “before” total, so they must be part of the “after” total too.
3 Investigate: dissolving and melting 11 min
Do:- Groups run the salt trial, then the sugar trial, and record both in the data table.
- At the end of this step, groups wipe their ice bags dry and weigh them again.
- Collect the class data on chart paper. Sample results from one group: salt trial 280 g before, 280 g after; sugar trial 290 g before, 290 g after; ice bag 180 g before, 180 g after melting.
Say:“Stir gently until you cannot see any grains — that may take a minute.”
“Dry the outside of the ice bag before you weigh it. Cold bags collect water from the air on the outside.”
“If your after-weight is 1 gram different, write the number you see anyway. We will talk about it.”
Ask: Ask a group: “Your salt disappeared. Did your number disappear too?”
Look for: No. The total stayed the same, so the salt is still there.
4 Graph and compare 9 min
Do:- Students make a double bar graph: for each trial (salt, sugar, ice), a bar for before in one color and a bar for after in another color.
- Model the axes on the board: trial names along the bottom, weight in grams up the side, counting by 20s from 0 to 300.
Say:“Label your graph: a title, the trials along the bottom, and “Weight (g)” up the side. Count by 20s.”
“Draw the before bar in one color and the after bar in another color, right next to each other.”
“Now look at your graph from a distance. What do you notice about each pair of bars?”
“Each pair is the same height. The graph shows it at a glance: dissolving and melting did not change the total weight.”
Ask: What would the graph look like if dissolving destroyed the salt?
Look for: The after bar for salt would be shorter than the before bar.
5 Discuss: what about small differences? 5 min
Do:- Point to any group on the class chart whose before and after differ by 1–3 g.
Say:“This group had a 2-gram difference. Did matter appear or disappear? Let’s look for reasons first.”
“A spill, a forgotten paper cup, water drops on the outside of a cold bag, or a scale that is off by a gram can all cause small differences. Scientists call this measurement error.”
“When most groups get the same weight before and after, and the few differences are small and explainable, our conclusion is strong: the total weight of matter stays the same.”
Ask: A group’s ice bag weighed 182 g after melting and 180 g before. What is the likely cause?
Look for: Water from the air collected on the cold outside of the bag. Drying it should bring it back to 180 g.
6 Exit ticket 3 min
Do:- Students answer on a sticky note or the bottom of the graph page.
Say:“What happened to the total weight when the salt dissolved? Use a number from your data and say what your graph shows.”
✅ Correct answer: The total weight stayed the same, for example 280 g before and 280 g after; the before and after bars are the same height, so the salt particles were still in the water. “It stayed the same” without data is “almost”; “it got lighter because the salt disappeared” is “not yet”.
✓ Wrap-up 3 min
Do:- Read the three “I can” statements aloud.
- Collect exit tickets and sort them: got it / almost / not yet.
Say:“Turn to your neighbor: was your prediction right? What would you tell someone who thinks dissolved salt weighs nothing?”
“Show me with your fingers how sure you are: 1 = not yet, 2 = almost, 3 = I can teach it.”
💡 Teacher tips
- Have groups seal and weigh their ice bags in the first step so the ice has the whole lesson to melt. Crushed ice melts faster than cubes.
- Use the same scale for before and after in each trial. Different scales can disagree by a gram or two.
- Draw the graph axes on the board before the lesson. Counting by 20s from 0 to 300 fits all the sample weights.
- Short on scales? Run the salt trial as a class demo and give groups only the sugar trial and the ice bag.
- Keep the class data chart for the next lesson — the pattern across many groups is powerful evidence.
- Remind students: no tasting the salt or sugar water. Pour it down the sink at the end.
💬 Discussion questions
- Why did the salt water weigh the same as the salt and water before mixing?
The salt particles did not disappear. They spread out between the water particles, so all the matter (and its weight) is still on the scale.
- Why is a graph useful for this investigation?
It makes the pattern easy to see: each before and after bar is the same height.
- Why did we do more than one trial?
One result could be a mistake. When salt, sugar and ice all show the same pattern, the conclusion is stronger.
- If an ice cube melts in an open cup on a sunny windowsill for two days, would the weight stay the same? Why or why not?
It might weigh less, because some water changes to a gas and leaves the cup. The matter still exists — it is just not on the scale.
⚠️ Common mistakes and how to fix them
❌ Thinking dissolved substances weigh nothing.
✔️ Show the data: 250 g + 30 g = 280 g before, and 280 g after. The salt is still adding weight.
❌ Graphing only the after weights, or using uneven scale steps.
✔️ Each trial needs two bars side by side, and the side of the graph must count by equal steps (by 20s).
❌ Pressing zero (tare) between weighings.
✔️ Zero the scale once, before anything is on it, and do not touch the button again.
❌ Deciding the rule is wrong because of a 1–2 g difference.
✔️ Look for spills, a missing cup or a wet bag first; small differences are usually measurement error.
🧩 For every learner
🤝 Extra support
- Give a graph with the axes and labels already drawn so students only draw the bars.
- Do the salt trial with the teacher, reading the scale aloud together.
- Sentence frame: “Before: ___ g. After: ___ g. The weight ___.”
🚀 Challenge
- Add a trial: dissolve 2 spoonfuls of sugar in warm tap water instead of 1. Predict the total before you weigh.
- Calculate the class average difference between before and after for each trial.
- Write a paragraph for a younger student explaining why dissolved salt still has weight.
🌎 English learners
- Word cards with pictures: before, after, same, more, less.
- Point to each bar and say “before” and “after” together.
- Sentence frame: “The bars are the same height, so the weight ___.”
🏠 At home: With a family member, make a two-bar graph of something at home that changes but keeps its weight — for example a sealed bag of ice before and after melting (weigh it on a kitchen scale if you have one). Label before and after and explain your graph.
📊 After the exit ticket and quiz: what to do tomorrow
Sort the exit tickets (or open the quiz results — they group the class for you) and start tomorrow with 10 minutes in three groups.
✅ Got it
- Start the next lesson (identifying a mystery powder).
- Early finishers: challenge sheet — read the class data and plan the butter trial.
🟡 Almost
- 5 minutes: fix the graph with a partner (equal steps by 20s, before and after bars side by side, labels).
- Write the exit ticket again with a number from the data.
🔁 Not yet
- Small group with the teacher: weigh water and a paper cup of salt together, mix, weigh again, and color two bars of the same height on a ready-made graph.
- Then the Easier worksheet (add to find the total) with the teacher nearby.
Does the weight change? · 5th Grade
🤝 Before and after
Same skill, smaller numbers and fill-in-the-blank steps — for students who need extra support. Everyone else starts on the main worksheet.
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Add to find the total before mixing.
- Water 100 g + salt 10 g = ___ gAnswer: ________________________✅ 110 g
- Water 200 g + sugar 20 g = ___ gAnswer: ________________________✅ 220 g
- Water 150 g + salt 25 g = ___ gAnswer: ________________________✅ 175 g
B. Circle the answer.
- After the salt dissolves, the total weight is (more / less / the same).Answer: ________________________✅ the same
- A bag of ice weighs 90 g. After melting it weighs (90 g / less than 90 g).Answer: ________________________✅ 90 g
- On a graph, the before and after bars are the (same height / different heights).Answer: ________________________✅ same height
🔑 Answers
- 110 g
- 220 g
- 175 g
- the same
- 90 g
- same height
Does the weight change? · 5th Grade
📝 Does the weight change? Data and graph
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Our data.
- My prediction for salt + water: more, less or the same? Why?Answer: ________________________✅ Any prediction with a reason (the best answer: the same, because the salt particles are still there).
- Salt trial: before ___ g, after ___ g, difference ___ g.Answer: ________________________✅ Group’s data; the totals match or are within 1 g.
- Sugar trial: before ___ g, after ___ g, difference ___ g.Answer: ________________________✅ Group’s data; the totals match or are within 1 g.
- Ice bag: before ___ g, after melting ___ g, difference ___ g.Answer: ________________________✅ Group’s data; the weights match or are within 1–2 g.
B. Graph your data.
- Make a double bar graph: salt, sugar and ice along the bottom; weight in grams up the side (count by 20s). Draw a before bar and an after bar for each trial.✅ Three pairs of bars; in each pair the before and after bars are the same (or almost the same) height.
C. Use the data.
- A cup of water weighs 230 g. A paper cup of salt weighs 25 g. What should both cups weigh together after the salt dissolves?Answer: ________________________✅ 255 g
- What does your graph show about the total weight?Answer: ________________________✅ The before and after bars are the same height, so the total weight stayed the same.
- Did your prediction match the result? Explain.Answer: ________________________✅ Student’s answer; it should compare the prediction to the data showing the weight stayed the same.
- Give one reason a group might measure 2 g less after mixing.Answer: ________________________✅ Any one: a spill, salt left out, the empty cup not weighed, reading the scale too soon.
🔑 Answers
- Any prediction with a reason (the best answer: the same, because the salt particles are still there).
- Group’s data; the totals match or are within 1 g.
- Group’s data; the totals match or are within 1 g.
- Group’s data; the weights match or are within 1–2 g.
- Three pairs of bars; in each pair the before and after bars are the same (or almost the same) height.
- 255 g
- The before and after bars are the same height, so the total weight stayed the same.
- Student’s answer; it should compare the prediction to the data showing the weight stayed the same.
- Any one: a spill, salt left out, the empty cup not weighed, reading the scale too soon.
Does the weight change? · 5th Grade
🚀 Challenge: data analyst
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Read the class data.
- Five groups dissolved salt. Before: 280, 265, 300, 275, 290 g. After: 280, 265, 298, 275, 290 g. Which group’s data is different? What is the most likely explanation?Answer: ________________________✅ The third group (300 g → 298 g, 2 g less). Most likely a small spill or measurement error — the other four groups got exactly the same weight.
- Leo says: “One group lost 2 g, so dissolving destroys a little bit of salt.” What should he say instead?Answer: ________________________✅ Four of five groups got the same weight, and 2 g can come from a spill or measurement error. The evidence shows dissolving does not destroy matter.
B. Think and explain.
- An ice bag weighs 180 g. After melting, a student weighs it without drying it and gets 183 g. Explain the extra 3 g using particles.Answer: ________________________✅ Water particles in the air touched the cold bag and collected as drops on the outside. They were added to the scale; the water inside did not gain weight.
- Plan a trial to test whether melting butter in a sealed bag changes its weight. What will you measure, and what do you predict?Answer: ________________________✅ Weigh the sealed bag of butter, warm it (in the sun or in a bowl of warm tap water, then dry the bag) until it melts, and weigh it again. Predict the same weight, because no particles enter or leave the bag.
🔑 Answers
- The third group (300 g → 298 g, 2 g less). Most likely a small spill or measurement error — the other four groups got exactly the same weight.
- Four of five groups got the same weight, and 2 g can come from a spill or measurement error. The evidence shows dissolving does not destroy matter.
- Water particles in the air touched the cold bag and collected as drops on the outside. They were added to the scale; the water inside did not gain weight.
- Weigh the sealed bag of butter, warm it (in the sun or in a bowl of warm tap water, then dry the bag) until it melts, and weigh it again. Predict the same weight, because no particles enter or leave the bag.
Does the weight change? · 5th Grade
✅ Quiz
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________ Score: ____ / 12
12 questions. Show them on the board and answer together, or give each student the quiz on their own device and see everyone’s score.
1. 100 g of water and 15 g of salt are mixed. What does the salt water weigh?
2. A sealed bag of ice weighs 160 g. After the ice melts, what does it weigh?
3. On a bar graph, the before bar for the sugar trial is 290 g. If dissolving does not change weight, how tall is the after bar?
4. Ana says: “The salt disappeared, so the salt water weighs the same as the plain water.” What should she say?
5. Class data for salt trials: 250 → 250 g, 270 → 270 g, 240 → 239 g, 260 → 260 g. What is the best conclusion?
6. Why did groups put the empty paper cup back on the scale after pouring?
7. Which mistake would make the after weight too high?
8. Why is a double bar graph good for this investigation?
9. Which change would NOT keep the total weight the same on the scale?
10. Predict: 250 g of water and 40 g of sugar. What is the total after the sugar dissolves?
11. What does it mean when a graph shows all the before and after bars at the same height?
12. Why do scientists do more than one trial?
12 questions
100 g of water and 15 g of salt are mixed. What does the salt water weigh?
- 100 g
- 85 g
- 115 g
- 150 g
A sealed bag of ice weighs 160 g. After the ice melts, what does it weigh?
- 160 g
- More than 160 g
- Less than 160 g
- 0 g
On a bar graph, the before bar for the sugar trial is 290 g. If dissolving does not change weight, how tall is the after bar?
- 270 g
- 300 g
- 145 g
- 290 g
Ana says: “The salt disappeared, so the salt water weighs the same as the plain water.” What should she say?
- “The salt water weighs less than the plain water.”
- “The salt is still there, so the total is the water plus the salt.”
- “Salt water has no weight.”
- Ana is right.
Class data for salt trials: 250 → 250 g, 270 → 270 g, 240 → 239 g, 260 → 260 g. What is the best conclusion?
- Dissolving changes weight a lot
- The total weight stays the same; the 1 g difference is measurement error
- Salt gets heavier in water
- We cannot conclude anything
Why did groups put the empty paper cup back on the scale after pouring?
- It was part of the before weight, so it must be part of the after weight
- To make the number bigger
- Paper cups are magnetic
- To dry the cup
Which mistake would make the after weight too high?
- Spilling some water
- Forgetting the empty paper cup
- Weighing a cold bag with water drops on the outside
- Pouring some salt on the table
Why is a double bar graph good for this investigation?
- It shows the color of the salt
- It lets you compare before and after weights side by side
- It shows the temperature
- It replaces the scale
Which change would NOT keep the total weight the same on the scale?
- Dissolving sugar in water
- Melting ice in a sealed bag
- Letting water dry up from an open dish for a week
- Stirring salt into water
Predict: 250 g of water and 40 g of sugar. What is the total after the sugar dissolves?
- 290 g
- 250 g
- 210 g
- 40 g
What does it mean when a graph shows all the before and after bars at the same height?
- The scale is broken
- The substances disappeared
- The trials were not fair
- The total weight did not change
Why do scientists do more than one trial?
- To use up materials
- To make the results more trustworthy
- Because the first trial is always wrong
- To change the answer
🖨️ Classroom aids to print
Word-wall cards for this lesson’s key words. They print on their own pages.
📤 Share this lesson
Does the weight change? · 5th Grade
🔑 Answer key
Easier worksheet
- 110 g
- 220 g
- 175 g
- the same
- 90 g
- same height
Worksheet
- Any prediction with a reason (the best answer: the same, because the salt particles are still there).
- Group’s data; the totals match or are within 1 g.
- Group’s data; the totals match or are within 1 g.
- Group’s data; the weights match or are within 1–2 g.
- Three pairs of bars; in each pair the before and after bars are the same (or almost the same) height.
- 255 g
- The before and after bars are the same height, so the total weight stayed the same.
- Student’s answer; it should compare the prediction to the data showing the weight stayed the same.
- Any one: a spill, salt left out, the empty cup not weighed, reading the scale too soon.
Challenge page
- The third group (300 g → 298 g, 2 g less). Most likely a small spill or measurement error — the other four groups got exactly the same weight.
- Four of five groups got the same weight, and 2 g can come from a spill or measurement error. The evidence shows dissolving does not destroy matter.
- Water particles in the air touched the cold bag and collected as drops on the outside. They were added to the scale; the water inside did not gain weight.
- Weigh the sealed bag of butter, warm it (in the sun or in a bowl of warm tap water, then dry the bag) until it melts, and weigh it again. Predict the same weight, because no particles enter or leave the bag.
Quiz
- C — 115 g. 100 + 15 = 115 g. Dissolving does not change the total.
- A — 160 g. The same particles are still in the bag.
- D — 290 g. Same weight, same bar height.
- B — “The salt is still there, so the total is the water plus the salt.”. The salt particles are still in the water and still have weight.
- B — The total weight stays the same; the 1 g difference is measurement error. Most trials match exactly; one is off by only 1 g.
- A — It was part of the before weight, so it must be part of the after weight. Weigh everything before and after.
- C — Weighing a cold bag with water drops on the outside. Drops from the air on the outside add extra weight.
- B — It lets you compare before and after weights side by side. Side-by-side bars make the comparison easy.
- C — Letting water dry up from an open dish for a week. The water leaves the dish as a gas, so it is no longer weighed.
- A — 290 g. 250 + 40 = 290 g.
- D — The total weight did not change. Equal bars mean equal weights.
- B — To make the results more trustworthy. Repeated results make a conclusion stronger.
Where this lesson fits
- Before this lesson: States of matter — Students model how particles are arranged in solids, liquids and gases.
- This lesson: Students measure and graph weight before and after dissolving and melting.
- Coming next: Identifying a mystery powder — Students use properties to identify an unknown material.
🌟 Thinkabara Pro
Need this lesson made for your class?
The booklet on this page is free. With Pro you get versions of it: three levels for mixed classes, in Spanish, or adapted for IEP and ELL students — plus a new booklet on any topic you teach that is not in our library.
Make a version for my class — free trial → See a real sample
7 days free, no credit card.
Practice & resources on Thinkabara
🗓️ Plan the whole year like this
Add 5th Grade Science to your free Lesson Planner: enter your class schedule once and every period shows the next lesson, skipping weekends and school breaks.
More lessons in “Structure & properties of matter”
- Particles too small to see — Students model that matter is made of particles too small to be seen.
- Conservation of matter — Students measure that weight stays the same through changes.
- Properties of materials — Students identify materials by properties.
- Mixing substances — Students determine if mixing creates new substances.
- States of matter — Students model how particles are arranged in solids, liquids and gases.
- Does the weight change? — Students measure and graph weight before and after dissolving and melting.
- Identifying a mystery powder — Students use properties to identify an unknown material.
- Is it a new substance? — Students decide whether mixing two substances makes a new one.
Something to improve in this lesson? Tell us.