Is it a new substance?
🎯 Objective: Students decide whether mixing two substances makes a new one.
🦫 Thinkabara · Lesson booklet
Is it a new substance?
5th Grade · Science · 5-PS1-4
🎯 Students decide whether mixing two substances makes a new one.
- Teacher’s lesson plan
- Easier worksheet
- Student worksheet
- Challenge page
- Quiz
- Answer key
Teacher: ______________________ Class: ____________
📘 This lesson comes as a booklet: teacher’s plan, student worksheet, challenge page, quiz and answer key — all in one printable booklet. Teach from this page, print it all, or give the quiz to the class online.
Full-screen slides for the projector: goals, opener, every drawing already made, the exit ticket and the quiz — click or use the arrow keys.
🗓️ Lesson at a glance
⏱️ 50 minutes
- 5 min Opener (pick one)
- 5 min Teach: the evidence checklist
- 14 min Investigate: three mixes
- 5 min Demo: separating and the new solid
- 7 min Claim and evidence
- 3 min Exit ticket
- 3 min Wrap-up
- 8 min Handing out, moving and cleaning up
Not in these 50 minutes: the worksheets (independent practice tomorrow, in centers or as homework) and the quiz (after the practice, or at the end of the week).
🧰 Materials
- Safety goggles for every student
- Sand (about 2 tablespoons per group), baking soda (1 teaspoon per group), white vinegar and water
- Food coloring (1 bottle per table, teacher-controlled) and clear plastic cups, 4 per group
- Thermometers, 1 per group (optional but recommended)
- Spoons or craft sticks, paper towels and a tray per group
- For the demo: milk, white vinegar, a clear cup and a coffee filter or paper towel
- Evidence checklist / recording sheet
🔤 Key words
- mixture
- Substances put together that each keep their own properties; they can usually be separated again.
- new substance
- A different kind of matter with new properties that forms when substances react.
- reaction
- A change where substances form one or more new substances.
- evidence
- Observations that support a claim, such as bubbles or a temperature change.
- claim
- A statement that answers the question, like “Baking soda and vinegar made a new substance.”
- separate
- To pull a mixture apart into what it was made of, for example by pouring off water.
🎯 Success criteria — read them to the class
- I can look for evidence of a new substance: a gas, a color change, a temperature change or a new solid.
- I can tell the difference between a mixture and a change that makes a new substance.
- I can write a claim with evidence about whether mixing two substances made a new one.
🎬 Open the lesson — pick one (5 min)
Get the class moving, curious and talking before the learning starts. Each one leads straight into today’s topic.
🤸 Brain break: Mix or make?
- Stand up behind your chair.
- When I say “mix”, clasp your hands together, then pull them apart again — you can always separate them.
- When I say “make”, press your palms together and slowly open them like a flower blooming into something new.
- Mix … make … mix … make.
- Shake out your hands gently and sit down.
Say: “Some mixes can be pulled apart again into what you started with. Other mixes make something brand new. Today you collect evidence to decide which is which.”
🧩 Riddle
“Pour me into water and the water turns cloudy, but wait a minute and I sink to the bottom, just as gritty as before. Pour off the water and let me dry, and I am exactly what I was. What am I?”
Hint: You find me at the beach and in a sandbox.
Answer
Sand — mixing me with water does not make a new substance. Today you find out how to tell!
🎁 Mystery object
Do: Pour about 1/2 cup of milk into a clear cup. Add 2 tablespoons of white vinegar, stir gently, and wait 1 minute. Then tip the cup slightly so the class can see inside.
Say: “I mixed two liquids. Look closely now. What do you notice that was not there before?”
Reveal: White clumps have formed — a new solid that was not in the milk or the vinegar. A new solid forming from two liquids is evidence of a new substance. Today you look for this kind of evidence in other mixes.
🤔 Would you rather
“Would you rather be a scientist who sees bubbles, a color change, or a new solid appear when you mix two things?”
Do: Students hold up 1, 2 or 3 fingers and tell a partner what each clue might mean.
Then: Each one can be evidence of a new substance — but be careful! Today you will also see a color change that does NOT make a new substance. Good scientists look at all the evidence.
🧑🏫 Teach it step by step
1 Teach: the evidence checklist 5 min
Say:“When two substances are mixed, we ask: did a new substance form, or is it just a mixture?”
“Here is our evidence checklist. A gas forms — bubbles you did not stir or blow in. The color changes by itself. The temperature changes by itself. A new solid appears.”
“One more powerful question: can we get back what we started with? If we can easily separate it, it was probably just a mixture.”
“Careful scientists never decide from one clue alone. We look at all the evidence together.”
Ask: Why might one clue not be enough?
Look for: Some clues can happen without a new substance — for example bubbles from stirring or a color that just spreads through water.
2 Investigate: three mixes 14 min
Do:- Goggles on. Groups set up three labeled cups on a tray.
- Mix 1: 2 tablespoons of sand + 1/2 cup of water. Stir, then wait 1 minute.
- Mix 2: 1 drop of food coloring (added by the teacher) + 1/2 cup of water. Do not stir; watch for 1 minute, then stir.
- Mix 3: 3 tablespoons of vinegar, then add 1 teaspoon of baking soda.
- If you have thermometers, measure each liquid before mixing and 1 minute after. Fill in the checklist for each mix.
Say:“For each mix, check every box on the checklist: gas? color change? temperature change? new solid? Write “yes” or “no” for each.”
“Then answer the last question for each mix: could we get back what we started with? How?”
“Watch the food coloring closely. The color of the water changes — but ask yourself: is that a new substance, or the same color spreading out?”
Ask: Ask a group: “The water changed color in mix 2. Does that prove a new substance formed?”
Look for: No. The food coloring is the same color it was in the bottle; its particles just spread out through the water. No gas, no temperature change, no new solid.
3 Demo: separating and the new solid 5 min
Do:- Pour the water off one group’s sand into the sink slowly, leaving wet sand in the cup. Set it in the window to dry.
- Pour the milk-and-vinegar demo through a coffee filter or paper towel in a cup. Show the white clumps left on the filter.
Say:“Look: I can pour the water off the sand. When the sand dries, it will be the same sand we started with. Nothing new formed — it was a mixture.”
“Now the milk and vinegar. The filter caught white clumps. This solid was not in the milk or the vinegar — it formed when they were mixed. And we cannot pour it back into plain milk and plain vinegar.”
“Remember: we never taste or smell up close in science, even when the materials are from the kitchen.”
Ask: What is the difference between the sand we got back and the clumps on the filter?
Look for: The sand is the same substance we started with. The clumps are a new solid that formed from the milk and vinegar.
4 Claim and evidence 7 min
Do:- Fill in a class evidence table on the board. Typical results: sand + water — no gas, no color change, no temperature change, no new solid, can be separated; food coloring + water — color spreads, nothing else, the dye is still there; baking soda + vinegar — gas (lots of bubbles) and the cup gets cooler (e.g. 20 °C → 17 °C), baking soda is used up.
- Students write a claim and two pieces of evidence for each mix.
Say:“A claim answers the question. Evidence is what we observed. For example: “Baking soda and vinegar made a new substance. Evidence: a gas formed, and the temperature dropped 3 degrees by itself.””
“Now write one for sand and water. Your claim may be that no new substance formed — that is a real claim too. What is your evidence?”
“And food coloring: what is your claim, and why is the color change alone not enough?”
Ask: Which mix had the most evidence of a new substance?
Look for: Baking soda and vinegar: a gas formed and the temperature changed, and the baking soda was used up.
5 Exit ticket 3 min
Do:- Students answer on a sticky note.
Say:“Which mix made a new substance — sand and water, or baking soda and vinegar? How do you know? Give two pieces of evidence.”
✅ Correct answer: Baking soda and vinegar. Evidence: a gas formed (bubbles that were not stirred in) and the temperature dropped by itself; also the baking soda was used up. Sand and water did not, because nothing new appeared and the sand can be separated back out. One piece of evidence is “almost”; choosing sand and water, or using “the water got cloudy” as proof, is “not yet”.
✓ Wrap-up 3 min
Do:- Groups pour liquids (not sand) down the sink, put wet sand in the trash or a bucket, and wipe trays.
- Read the three “I can” statements aloud and collect exit tickets: got it / almost / not yet.
Say:“Tell your neighbor: what is one clue that can trick you, and why?”
“Show me with your fingers how sure you are: 1 = not yet, 2 = almost, 3 = I can teach it.”
💡 Teacher tips
- Never pour sand down the sink — collect it in a bucket and let it dry to reuse.
- Add the food coloring yourself, one drop per cup, so it does not end up on hands and clothes.
- Do the milk-and-vinegar step as a teacher demo only, and check for milk allergies first. Throw the clumps away after the lesson.
- Room-temperature milk works, but slightly warm milk (warm tap-water temperature) forms clumps faster. Do not heat it on a stove in class.
- Thermometers make the temperature evidence much stronger than touching the cup. If you have only a few, use them for mix 3.
- Goggles stay on until every cup is emptied.
💬 Discussion questions
- Why is the color change in food coloring and water not evidence of a new substance?
The coloring was already that color; its particles just spread out through the water. No gas, temperature change or new solid appeared.
- How can you prove sand and water did not make a new substance?
Pour off the water and let the sand dry: you get back the same sand. Nothing new appeared.
- Which kinds of evidence did baking soda and vinegar give?
A gas formed (bubbles) and the temperature dropped by itself. The baking soda was used up.
- Where do you see new substances forming in everyday life?
Baking a cake, a rusting bike, burning wood in a campfire, milk turning sour — each makes new substances with new properties.
⚠️ Common mistakes and how to fix them
❌ Thinking any color change proves a new substance.
✔️ Compare with food coloring: the color only spread out. Look for more than one kind of evidence.
❌ Calling cloudy water (sand stirred up) a new substance.
✔️ Wait a minute: the sand settles and can be separated. Cloudy is not on the checklist.
❌ Thinking dissolving is a reaction.
✔️ Dissolved sugar or salt is still sugar or salt — you can get it back when the water dries.
❌ Making a claim with no evidence, or listing evidence without a claim.
✔️ Use the frame: “Claim: ___. Evidence: ___ and ___.”
🧩 For every learner
🤝 Extra support
- Give a checklist with picture icons for gas, color, temperature and new solid to tick for each mix.
- Compare only sand + water and baking soda + vinegar, side by side, with the teacher.
- Sentence frame: “I think ___ made a new substance because I saw ___.”
🚀 Challenge
- Sort 8 everyday changes (baking bread, melting butter, rusting nail, dissolving sugar, burning a candle wick, tearing paper, cooking an egg, freezing juice) into new substance / no new substance, with a reason for each.
- Explain why a color change in leaves in fall might be a better clue than food coloring in water.
- Design a way to separate a mixture of sand, salt and water.
🌎 English learners
- Picture cards: bubbles, color, thermometer, solid clumps.
- Gestures: hands together and apart for “mix”, hands opening for “new”.
- Sentence frame: “It is a mixture / a new substance because ___.”
🏠 At home: With a family member, look for one change at home that makes a new substance (like toast browning or a cake baking) and one that does not (like ice melting or sugar dissolving). Explain the evidence for each. Never mix cleaning products.
📊 After the exit ticket and quiz: what to do tomorrow
Sort the exit tickets (or open the quiz results — they group the class for you) and start tomorrow with 10 minutes in three groups.
✅ Got it
- Start the next lesson (plants get matter from air and water).
- Early finishers: challenge sheet — sort the everyday changes and separate sand, salt and water.
🟡 Almost
- 5 minutes: rewrite the exit ticket with the frame “Claim: ___. Evidence: ___ and ___.”
- Sort 6 picture cards (fizzing, colored water, melting ice, new clumps, cloudy sand water, cooler cup) into “evidence” and “not evidence” with a partner.
🔁 Not yet
- Small group with the teacher: redo sand + water and baking soda + vinegar side by side and tick the evidence checklist together.
- Then the Easier worksheet (circle yes or no) with the teacher nearby.
Is it a new substance? · 5th Grade
🤝 New substance or mixture?
Same skill, smaller numbers and fill-in-the-blank steps — for students who need extra support. Everyone else starts on the main worksheet.
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Circle yes or no.
- Sand + water: did a gas form? (yes / no)Answer: ________________________✅ no
- Baking soda + vinegar: did a gas form? (yes / no)Answer: ________________________✅ yes
- Baking soda + vinegar: did the temperature change? (yes / no)Answer: ________________________✅ yes (it got cooler)
- Can we get the sand back from sand and water? (yes / no)Answer: ________________________✅ yes
B. Write mixture or new substance.
- Sand + water: ________Answer: ________________________✅ mixture
- Baking soda + vinegar: ________Answer: ________________________✅ new substance
- Milk + vinegar (white clumps form): ________Answer: ________________________✅ new substance
🔑 Answers
- no
- yes
- yes (it got cooler)
- yes
- mixture
- new substance
- new substance
Is it a new substance? · 5th Grade
📝 Is it a new substance? Evidence checklist
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Our observations (gas? color change? temperature change? new solid?).
- Mix 1 — sand + water:Answer: ________________________✅ No gas, no color change, no temperature change, no new solid. The sand settles to the bottom.
- Mix 2 — food coloring + water:Answer: ________________________✅ The color spreads through the water; no gas, no temperature change, no new solid.
- Mix 3 — baking soda + vinegar:Answer: ________________________✅ Gas (lots of bubbles), the temperature drops a few degrees, no new solid we can see.
B. Claim and evidence.
- Mix 1: Claim: ___ Evidence: ___Answer: ________________________✅ No new substance. No gas, color or temperature change, and the sand can be separated back out.
- Mix 3: Claim: ___ Evidence: ___Answer: ________________________✅ A new substance formed. A gas formed and the temperature changed by itself.
- Why is the color change in mix 2 not enough to prove a new substance?Answer: ________________________✅ The coloring only spread out; it is the same coloring. There was no other evidence like a gas, a temperature change or a new solid.
C. Apply.
- Two clear liquids are mixed and a white solid appears. Claim and evidence?Answer: ________________________✅ A new substance probably formed; evidence: a new solid appeared.
- Group data: vinegar 20 °C; 1 minute after adding baking soda, 17 °C. How much did it change? What does it show?Answer: ________________________✅ It dropped 3 °C by itself — evidence of a reaction.
- How could you get the sand back from sand and water?Answer: ________________________✅ Pour off the water (or use a filter) and let the sand dry.
🔑 Answers
- No gas, no color change, no temperature change, no new solid. The sand settles to the bottom.
- The color spreads through the water; no gas, no temperature change, no new solid.
- Gas (lots of bubbles), the temperature drops a few degrees, no new solid we can see.
- No new substance. No gas, color or temperature change, and the sand can be separated back out.
- A new substance formed. A gas formed and the temperature changed by itself.
- The coloring only spread out; it is the same coloring. There was no other evidence like a gas, a temperature change or a new solid.
- A new substance probably formed; evidence: a new solid appeared.
- It dropped 3 °C by itself — evidence of a reaction.
- Pour off the water (or use a filter) and let the sand dry.
Is it a new substance? · 5th Grade
🚀 Challenge: evidence judge
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________
A. Think and explain.
- Rosa says: “I stirred sand into water and it turned cloudy, so I made a new substance.” What should she say?Answer: ________________________✅ Cloudy water is just sand stirred up. After a minute it settles, and the sand can be poured off and dried. No gas, temperature change or new solid formed, so it is a mixture.
- Sort these changes into new substance / no new substance and give a reason for each: melting butter, baking a cake, tearing paper, a nail rusting.Answer: ________________________✅ Melting butter: no (still butter, only changed state). Baking a cake: yes (gas bubbles, new solid with new properties; cannot get the eggs back). Tearing paper: no (still paper). Rusting nail: yes (a new reddish-brown solid with new properties).
- Design a way to separate sand, salt and water.Answer: ________________________✅ Pour the mix through a filter (coffee filter): the sand stays on the filter. Let the salty water that went through dry in a dish: the salt is left behind.
B. Weigh the evidence.
- A student mixes two liquids. The color changes, but there is no gas, no temperature change and no solid. They can separate the liquids again by letting one dry. What would you conclude and why?Answer: ________________________✅ Probably just a mixture. The only clue is a color change, and the starting substances can be separated again, so there is not enough evidence of a new substance.
🔑 Answers
- Cloudy water is just sand stirred up. After a minute it settles, and the sand can be poured off and dried. No gas, temperature change or new solid formed, so it is a mixture.
- Melting butter: no (still butter, only changed state). Baking a cake: yes (gas bubbles, new solid with new properties; cannot get the eggs back). Tearing paper: no (still paper). Rusting nail: yes (a new reddish-brown solid with new properties).
- Pour the mix through a filter (coffee filter): the sand stays on the filter. Let the salty water that went through dry in a dish: the salt is left behind.
- Probably just a mixture. The only clue is a color change, and the starting substances can be separated again, so there is not enough evidence of a new substance.
Is it a new substance? · 5th Grade
✅ Quiz
Name: ______________________ Date: ____________ Score: ____ / 12
12 questions. Show them on the board and answer together, or give each student the quiz on their own device and see everyone’s score.
1. Which observation is evidence of a new substance?
2. Sand is stirred into water. Is a new substance formed?
3. Milk and vinegar are mixed and white clumps form. What is the best conclusion?
4. A drop of food coloring spreads through water and turns it blue. Why is this NOT strong evidence of a new substance?
5. Rosa says: “The sand made the water cloudy, so it is a new substance.” What should she say?
6. Read the data: vinegar 20 °C, one minute after adding baking soda 17 °C. What does this show?
7. Which is NOT on the evidence checklist for a new substance?
8. Which change makes a new substance?
9. How can you show that sand and water did not make a new substance?
10. Why should scientists look for more than one kind of evidence?
11. Predict: you pour vinegar on sand. What will most likely happen?
12. Which claim is written with evidence?
12 questions
Which observation is evidence of a new substance?
- Sand sinking to the bottom of a cup
- A gas forming when baking soda and vinegar are mixed
- Water getting cloudy when stirred with sand
- Salt dissolving in water
Sand is stirred into water. Is a new substance formed?
- Yes, because the water is cloudy
- Yes, because the sand got wet
- No — the sand can be separated and is still sand
- Yes, because the sand sank
Milk and vinegar are mixed and white clumps form. What is the best conclusion?
- A new substance formed — a new solid appeared
- Nothing happened
- It is only a mixture
- The milk froze
A drop of food coloring spreads through water and turns it blue. Why is this NOT strong evidence of a new substance?
- Blue is not a real color
- Food coloring is a gas
- The water got hotter
- The coloring only spread out; there was no gas, temperature change or new solid
Rosa says: “The sand made the water cloudy, so it is a new substance.” What should she say?
- “The sand turned into water.”
- “It is a mixture — the sand settles and can be separated.”
- “It is a gas.”
- Rosa is right.
Read the data: vinegar 20 °C, one minute after adding baking soda 17 °C. What does this show?
- The temperature dropped 3 °C by itself — evidence of a reaction
- The temperature rose 3 °C
- The thermometer is broken
- No change happened
Which is NOT on the evidence checklist for a new substance?
- A gas forms
- A new solid appears
- The temperature changes by itself
- The mix is stirred with a spoon
Which change makes a new substance?
- Melting butter
- Tearing paper
- Baking a cake
- Freezing juice
How can you show that sand and water did not make a new substance?
- Pour off the water, dry the sand, and see that it is the same sand
- Add more water
- Shake it harder
- Taste the water
Why should scientists look for more than one kind of evidence?
- Because one clue, like a color change, can happen without a new substance
- Because evidence is always wrong
- To use more cups
- Because only gases count
Predict: you pour vinegar on sand. What will most likely happen?
- Lots of fizzing
- Nothing much — sand does not react with vinegar
- The sand dissolves
- A new solid appears
Which claim is written with evidence?
- “Baking soda and vinegar are cool.”
- “I think it changed.”
- “Baking soda and vinegar made a new substance because a gas formed and the temperature dropped.”
- “Sand is from the beach.”
🖨️ Classroom aids to print
Word-wall cards for this lesson’s key words. They print on their own pages.
📤 Share this lesson
Is it a new substance? · 5th Grade
🔑 Answer key
Easier worksheet
- no
- yes
- yes (it got cooler)
- yes
- mixture
- new substance
- new substance
Worksheet
- No gas, no color change, no temperature change, no new solid. The sand settles to the bottom.
- The color spreads through the water; no gas, no temperature change, no new solid.
- Gas (lots of bubbles), the temperature drops a few degrees, no new solid we can see.
- No new substance. No gas, color or temperature change, and the sand can be separated back out.
- A new substance formed. A gas formed and the temperature changed by itself.
- The coloring only spread out; it is the same coloring. There was no other evidence like a gas, a temperature change or a new solid.
- A new substance probably formed; evidence: a new solid appeared.
- It dropped 3 °C by itself — evidence of a reaction.
- Pour off the water (or use a filter) and let the sand dry.
Challenge page
- Cloudy water is just sand stirred up. After a minute it settles, and the sand can be poured off and dried. No gas, temperature change or new solid formed, so it is a mixture.
- Melting butter: no (still butter, only changed state). Baking a cake: yes (gas bubbles, new solid with new properties; cannot get the eggs back). Tearing paper: no (still paper). Rusting nail: yes (a new reddish-brown solid with new properties).
- Pour the mix through a filter (coffee filter): the sand stays on the filter. Let the salty water that went through dry in a dish: the salt is left behind.
- Probably just a mixture. The only clue is a color change, and the starting substances can be separated again, so there is not enough evidence of a new substance.
Quiz
- B — A gas forming when baking soda and vinegar are mixed. A gas that was not there before is evidence of a new substance.
- C — No — the sand can be separated and is still sand. It is a mixture; pour off the water and dry the sand.
- A — A new substance formed — a new solid appeared. A new solid forming from two liquids is evidence of a new substance.
- D — The coloring only spread out; there was no gas, temperature change or new solid. The color was already in the drop; it just spread.
- B — “It is a mixture — the sand settles and can be separated.”. Cloudy is not on the evidence checklist; the sand is still sand.
- A — The temperature dropped 3 °C by itself — evidence of a reaction. 20 − 17 = 3 degrees cooler, without cooling it.
- D — The mix is stirred with a spoon. Stirring is something we do, not evidence.
- C — Baking a cake. Baking makes new substances; the others only change shape or state.
- A — Pour off the water, dry the sand, and see that it is the same sand. Getting the starting substance back shows it was a mixture.
- A — Because one clue, like a color change, can happen without a new substance. Several clues together make a stronger claim.
- B — Nothing much — sand does not react with vinegar. Sand does not react with vinegar.
- C — “Baking soda and vinegar made a new substance because a gas formed and the temperature dropped.”. A claim plus observations that support it.
Where this lesson fits
- Before this lesson: Identifying a mystery powder — Students use properties to identify an unknown material.
- This lesson: Students decide whether mixing two substances makes a new one.
- Coming next: Plants get matter from air and water — Students support the argument that plants get materials mainly from air and water.
🌟 Thinkabara Pro
Need this lesson made for your class?
The booklet on this page is free. With Pro you get versions of it: three levels for mixed classes, in Spanish, or adapted for IEP and ELL students — plus a new booklet on any topic you teach that is not in our library.
Make a version for my class — free trial → See a real sample
7 days free, no credit card.
Practice & resources on Thinkabara
🗓️ Plan the whole year like this
Add 5th Grade Science to your free Lesson Planner: enter your class schedule once and every period shows the next lesson, skipping weekends and school breaks.
More lessons in “Structure & properties of matter”
- Particles too small to see — Students model that matter is made of particles too small to be seen.
- Conservation of matter — Students measure that weight stays the same through changes.
- Properties of materials — Students identify materials by properties.
- Mixing substances — Students determine if mixing creates new substances.
- States of matter — Students model how particles are arranged in solids, liquids and gases.
- Does the weight change? — Students measure and graph weight before and after dissolving and melting.
- Identifying a mystery powder — Students use properties to identify an unknown material.
- Is it a new substance? — Students decide whether mixing two substances makes a new one.
Something to improve in this lesson? Tell us.